TLDR
Neighborhood gem w/ alums from Eleven Madison Park. Offers stellar service & diverse brunch/tasting menus.
Details
The Noortwyck is a charming neighborhood American restaurant helmed by alums from Eleven Madison Park [1]. It's noted for its excellent service and a diverse menu that includes both savory and sweet brunch options, as well as notable main courses [1]. The restaurant also offers impressive tasting menus and wine pairings [2].
Food Overview
The food at The Noortwyck features American and contemporary European cuisine, with many recommending dishes like roasted chicken with bread stuffing [2] and clam and chili linguine [4]. Some visitors found the bread and oysters decent, but mains and steak were considered underwhelming [3]. It's also recognized for its cinnamon rolls [5], [1].
Caveats
One reviewer found the steak to be of poor quality and not worth the price, feeling it was comparable to a home-cooked meal [1]. Another commenter criticized the restaurant for terrible service, being crowded, and being "awfully basic" [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE NOORT WYCK
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Is Your Favorite Seafood Pasta Youve Had In
"The Noortwyck is mentioned for having a great clam and chilli linguine."
PositiveFrom post: How Is Il Buco Alimentari Good For Out Of Town
"Noortwyk is suggested as a dining option, with the note that while not strictly Italian, it often features excellent pasta dishes."
PositiveFrom post: Excellent Tuna Crudo Or Tuna Tartare
"The Noortwyck was listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Go With Parents That Isnt Fussy Hyped
"The Noortwyck was recommended as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Food Cinnamon Roll Recs
"Recommends Benjis, Sunday Morning, and Noortwyck for cinnamon rolls."
PositiveFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"The Noortwyck is described as charming but primarily a neighborhood spot that is not very memorable, especially when compared to other highly-rated restaurants."
NeutralFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"This commenter criticizes Noortwyck for terrible service, being crowded, and being "awfully basic," doubting the quality of their tasting menu."
NegativeFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"This commenter notes that while both Kabawa and Noortwyck serve good food, Noortwyck is a more suitable option if one prefers a quiet and romantic evening, whereas Kabawa might offer more of a 'party' vibe."
NeutralFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"This commenter suggests Kabawa over Noortwyck."
NegativeFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"The food at The Noortwyck was considered fantastic, particularly a roasted chicken dish with bread stuffing."
PositiveFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"The Noortwyck is described as a terrific restaurant with a chef formerly from Eleven Madison Park and excellent wine pairings, even offering impressive tasting menus."
PositiveFrom post: Kabawa Vs Noortwyck And Frenchette Vs Crown Shy
"The Noortwyck was loved by the commenter, while Frenchette and Crown Shy were good but not memorable. They would return to Frenchette before Crown Shy."
PositiveFrom post: Help Narrowing Down A Couple Choices Or Identify
"The user has had good meals at The Noortwyck previously and is looking for restaurants in a similar vein in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: West Village Realistic Reservations
"This user also recommended The Noortwyck, calling it potentially one of the most parent-friendly restaurants in the city."
NeutralFrom post: West Village Realistic Reservations
"The Noortwyck was suggested as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Had My Birthday At Nowon Damn That Was The Most
"This commenter had a disappointing experience at The Noortwyck, finding the bread and oysters decent, but the mains and service underwhelming. They specifically mentioned the steak was not great quality and served with a hash brown, which they felt they could make better at home for the price."
NegativeFrom post: Outdoor Late Lunch Options In Villagewest Village
"The Noortwyck was suggested as an outdoor dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Places That Take Reservations For Solo Outdoor
"The Noortwyck is mentioned as a restaurant where solo diners can book outdoor tables without restrictions."
Neutral