Hearty Italian-American fare with family-style portions, great for celebrations.
ARTHUR & SONS NY ITALIAN is a popular choice for those seeking hearty Italian-American fare. It's frequently recommended for its family-style portions and is considered a great spot for special occasions like birthdays. While many users on Reddit have selected it as a preferred option for Italian dining, citing its value and enjoyable atmosphere, a notable dissenting opinion arose from a food festival experience where the rigatoni alla vodka was criticized for being bland, undercooked, and overpriced.
The restaurant offers Italian-American cuisine, with pasta dishes like rigatoni alla vodka being mentioned. While some customers enjoyed the food and found it suitable for family-style dining, one specific negative review at a food festival described the rigatoni as not spicy, undercooked, and overpriced.
"Pasta dishes, particularly rigatoni alla vodka, are mentioned, though one reviewer had a negative experience with it."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the restaurant, with many recommending it for its Italian-American cuisine, family-style portions, and suitability for celebrations. However, one specific negative experience at a food festival noted that the rigatoni alla vodka was not spicy, undercooked, and overpriced.
Important Note
One user reported a negative experience at a food festival where the rigatoni alla vodka was not spicy, undercooked, and overpriced.
"The commenter observed two nearly uneaten portions of rigatoni from Arthur and Sons on a nearby bench at the festival, suggesting others also found the dish unsatisfactory."
Negative"Arthur and Sons' "spicy" rigatoni alla vodka at the festival was not spicy, undercooked, and overpriced at $15 for a small, meatless portion in a paper saucer."
Negative"A user advises the original poster to try booking a different restaurant for dinner, implicitly suggesting a negative opinion of Arthur & Sons."
Negative"The user has a reservation at Arthur & Sons for Father's Day dinner and is asking for opinions on whether it is a good choice, as they have never been there before and are looking for Italian food."
Neutral"Selects Arthur & Sons, noting that Carbone (another option) is very hard to get into."
Positive"Selected Arthur & Sons from the original poster's list."
Positive"Selected Arthur & Sons (shortened to 'Arthur') from the original poster's list."
Positive"Recommends Arthur & Sons for its shareable portions and enjoyable Italian-American food, estimating $50-$100 per person, making it a good fit for the budget."
Positive"Selected Arthur & Sons from the original poster's list of choices."
Positive"Selected Arthur & Sons from the original poster's list."
Positive"Selected Arthur & Sons from the Italian restaurant options, while also suggesting alternatives like Torrisi or Via Carota."
Positive"Suggests Arthur and Sons as a place to celebrate."
Positive"Suggests Arthur & Sons as a potential option for pasta."
Neutral
