NYC's go-to for house-milled flour pizza slices.
Scarr's Pizza on the Lower East Side is renowned for its quality slices, with owner Scarr Pimentel meticulously milling grains for his exceptional thin-crust pizzas.
Scarr's Pizza is a standout establishment in NYC, known for its dedication to quality with a unique in-house flour milling process. This commitment translates to exceptional thin-crust pizzas, with popular choices like the classic cheese slice and the spicy-sweet 'Hotboi'. While many rave about the distinct flavors and crust, some patrons have noted occasional service speed issues or perceived inconsistencies in quality over time.
Scarr's Pizza is celebrated for its high-quality pizza slices, with a particular emphasis on the crust made from house-milled grains. Popular recommendations include the plain cheese slice, the 'Hotboi' with hot honey, and Grandma slices. While many praise the pizza, some reviews mention a decline in quality or inconsistencies, and occasional criticisms of the pizza being too dry, overcooked, or not living up to the hype.
"The 'Hotboi' slice, known for its combination of jalapenos, pepperoni, and hot honey, is frequently recommended. Classic plain cheese slices and Grandma slices are also highlighted as popular and well-loved options."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Scarr's Pizza, often praising the quality of their slices and the unique aspect of milling their own flour. However, there are mixed opinions regarding consistency and service speed, with some finding the quality has declined over time or that the service can be slow.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the quality and service at Scarr's Pizza have become inconsistent, with some experiencing slow service or a decline in pizza quality compared to previous years or other establishments.
"This user suggests Scarr's should add a white slice option for those who avoid tomato sauce."
Neutral"This commenter finds Mama's Too cheese slice solid and notes you can get it quickly even when busy."
Positive"This user recommends Uncle Sam's."
Positive"This commenter advises against going to Scarr's at night, as their pizza was stiff, thin, and burnt."
Negative"This user believes Scarr's pizza quality has declined, citing burnt slices over the last few years."
Negative"This user asks about a new similar pizza place and is provided with information about S&Q Pizza Parlor in Brooklyn."
Neutral"This user recommends John's of Bleecker, calling it the best pie in the city and suggesting the Sasso."
Positive"This user's part of Brooklyn lacks good pizza places, and they note that areas like Williamsburg and Greenpoint have good options."
Neutral"This user tried Lucia and liked it but doesn't think it's the greatest in the city, asking if the commenter has tried Mama's Too."
Neutral"This user plans to check out John's of Bleecker, noting it had a long line."
Neutral"This user finds Lucia consistently solid, while Scarr's is only good sometimes."
Neutral"This user suggests Famous Ben's Pizza of SoHo, noting it's not in the LES."
Neutral"This user calls Scarr's way overhyped."
Negative"This commenter found Scarr's pizza tasted exactly like Costco pizza, a disappointing experience compared to their positive memories of the original location."
Negative"This user found Scarr's solid but not comparable to John's of Bleecker, which they highly recommend."
Negative"This commenter finds Scarr's overpriced and mediocre, similar to many other places now."
Negative"This user believes Scarr's was better at its original location before becoming famous, and still might be the best due to limited good pizza options in the LES."
Neutral"This commenter believes Scarr's is extremely overrated and wasn't noteworthy even at its original location."
Negative"This user recommends Cuts & Slices on Houston for unconventional but good pizza."
Positive"This user states that the quality at Scarr's has significantly dropped since moving locations."
Negative
