TLDR
Artisanal LES staple known for house-milled flour and a signature thin, charred crust. A polarizing local favorite for both classic and specialty slices.
Instagram Posts References
While primarily known for pizza, Scarr's is mentioned in the context of NYC's food scene, suggesting a diverse culinary offering. Although not explicitly detailed for Taiwanese Beef Noodle Soup, its inclusion implies a potential for quality diverse dishes.
Scarr's Pizza was the second stop, where the creator tried both a plain cheese slice and one with pepperoni and jalapeños. While she noted the pizza was "really greasy," she also praised the "really tasty" sauce, ultimately giving a mixed review by calling the experience "mid" despite her attempt to be positive.
Scarr's Pizza is celebrated for its 'best kick', specifically the 'hot boi, no pepperoni' pizza. This pizza includes jalapeños and a 'mike's hot honey'. The author advises ordering the whole pie as they may not make it without pepperoni by the slice.
Scarr's Pizza on the Lower East Side is renowned for its quality slices, with owner Scarr Pimentel meticulously milling grains for his exceptional thin-crust pizzas.
Details
A pioneer of the 'new school' slice shop, this Lower East Side destination is renowned for its commitment to quality, notably milling its own grains in-house to craft a superior thin crust [1], [2], [3]. While often hailed as a top-tier option for a classic New York slice, the restaurant has faced recent scrutiny regarding consistency and quality following its move to a larger location [2], [3]. Despite being a fixture on many must-visit lists, public opinion remains split between those who cherish its artisanal approach and others who find it overhyped [2], [3].
Food Overview
The menu features a mix of traditional and innovative pies, with the 'Hotboi'—topped with jalapeños, pepperoni, and hot honey—being a standout favorite [1], [2], [3]. Customers frequently highlight the high-quality ingredients and house-milled flour crust [1], [3], though some critics complain that slices can be overly greasy, thin, or stale depending on the visit [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SCARR'S PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Dad Daughter Food Recommendations In
"A go-to spot for a proper, high-quality New York slice."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Still Get Great Knots Slice Joints
"Brief recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Still Get Great Knots Slice Joints
"Brief recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"The commenter notes that while popular, they find it overrated compared to Pop's."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"States the pizza is very bad."
NegativeFrom post: Reigning Pizza Slice Downtown Manhattan Lindustrie
"A former employee who believes the pizza is not worthy of the hype."
NegativeFrom post: Reigning Pizza Slice Downtown Manhattan Lindustrie
"Notes that the restaurant rarely serves the margherita slice and that the service experience is frustrating."
NegativeFrom post: Reigning Pizza Slice Downtown Manhattan Lindustrie
"Claims the slices are often old, stale, and reheated, contrasting it negatively with Jonny's."
NegativeFrom post: Anyone Wanna Split A Cheese Pie At Ceres Today
"The author experienced a bad batch where the pizza structure failed, leading to a disappointing experience."
NegativeFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter recommends Scarr's for a great slice of pizza but doesn't believe the specific pizza in the post can be identified."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter provides a link to a picture of a slice from Scarr's Pizza that looks similar to the one in the original post, noting it is on brown plates."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Scarr's."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Day Nyc Need Food Recommendations Updated With
"Scarr's Pizza is mentioned as a pizza place that the commenter likes."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Pizza Places That Use
"This user suggests Scarr's Pizza as a top choice because they mill their own flour, implying a focus on ingredient quality."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go In The Les If It Was Your
"A caution is given regarding Scarr's Pizza, stating that the quality can be inconsistent; sometimes it's excellent, other times average."
NeutralFrom post: Where Would You Go In The Les If It Was Your
"Scarr's Pizza is recommended for a casual slice, beer, or cocktail, offering a strong LES vibe before heading home."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"This user agrees that Scarr's quality has declined, noting the place has been dead and the slice quality has suffered."
NegativeFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"This user observed that Scarr's new location lacks the same vibe and that the pizza quality has noticeably decreased."
NegativeFrom post: Local Ny Birthday Food Crawl East Village And
"The commenter stated that Scarr's Pizza falls within the route and that omitting pizza from a New York food itinerary would be an insult to the city's culinary heritage."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"This user believes the owner of Scarr's has shifted focus to merchandise like t-shirts and shoes, leading to a decline in pizza quality."
Negative