TLDR
Highly immersive, secret-code entry omakase offering a deep-dive into late 19th-century history. A polarizing blend of theatrical charm and varying opinions on culinary consistency.
Reddit Sentiment for THE OFFICE OF MR. MOTO(based on 19 Reddit opinions)
Details
This immersive, themed destination transports diners to the late 1800s, greeting guests with a secret code for entry into a fictional explorer's office [1]. While some praise the high-end, authentic atmosphere and quality fish [2], [3], others remain skeptical about the balance between theatrical marketing and actual food execution [4], [5]. Ultimately, the experience serves as a polarizing choice for those seeking a unique, story-driven omakase [6].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide variety of fish like black throat sea perch and shima aji [1]. Experiences vary significantly, ranging from those who enjoy the premium nigiri and fish quality [8], [9] to reports of underwhelming chirashi, stale sashimi, or undercooked rice in delivery orders [7], [10], [11].
Caveats
Diners should be aware of inconsistent quality control, particularly regarding delivery orders, which have been described by some as inedible [7], [11]. Additionally, the theatrical 'gimmick' of the restaurant may not appeal to those seeking a purely traditional culinary focus [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE OFFICE OF MR. MOTO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Takeout Sushi In Williamsburggreenpoint With High
"Recommended as a high-quality sushi option."
PositiveFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"This user provided a brief negative opinion, stating 'Moto is mid'."
NegativeFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"After ordering delivery, this user found the sushi to be inedible, despite the attractive packaging and presentation. They expressed strong disappointment and vowed never to order from or visit the establishment again."
NegativeFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"This user found the chirashi overpriced and not as depicted on the website, noting the absence of uni and the quality of salmon and tuna cuts. They also mentioned bin toro."
NegativeFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"A coworker received sashimi from this restaurant that appeared to have aged too long. The user inferred the restaurant prioritizes aesthetics over olfactory quality."
NegativeFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"This user had a positive experience, finding both the chirashi and their premium nigiri set to be great. They were responding to a comment about undercooked rice and great fish."
PositiveFrom post: Premium Chirashi Don The Parcels Of Mr Moto 38
"This user reported that some of the rice was undercooked in their recent delivery order, but found the fish to be great."
NeutralFrom post: Japanese Restaurant Ichibantai Vs Ootoya
"The Office of Mr. Moto was suggested as a place that feels like a fancy restaurant in Japan."
PositiveFrom post: Noz 17 Vs Nakazawa Vs Any Others
"This user lists Office of Mr. Moto as a mid-range sushi place they liked, though it's still a step down from Tokyo's mid-range offerings. They note it's better than Nakazawa."
PositiveFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user found The Office of Mr Moto to be a good omakase with a fair sake pairing, but noted the rice temperature was too cool."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user suggested that The Office of Mr Moto gets lumped in with other 'secret' and potentially bad restaurants."
NegativeFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user asked for clarification on why The Office of Mr Moto received negative feedback, stating they thought the fish quality and ingredients were excellent."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user commented on having varied experiences with different omakase spots."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user stated they had a good experience at The Office of Mr Moto with a nice sake pairing, enjoying the fish quality and dishes, despite finding the story gimmicky."
PositiveFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user expressed confusion about the negative downvotes on the previous comment about The Office of Mr Moto, stating they found the place to be 'such BS'."
NegativeFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This commenter suggested The Office of Mr Moto, implying it's a poor choice."
NegativeFrom post: Recommendations
"The commenter states they would never recommend Office of Mr. Moto because it served cod milt."
NegativeFrom post: Up To 500head Where Would You Go
"The Office of Mr. Moto is listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Omakase Nyc For Date Night
"The original poster was considering a reservation for The Office of Mr Moto's Modernity Menu but had read reviews suggesting the experience and marketing were better than the actual food."
Neutral