FiDi's bagel haven offering large, fluffy, and 'really good' bagels. A top choice for a classic NYC bite.
Step into Liberty Bagels in the Financial District and prepare for a bagel experience that many New Yorkers rave about. This spot is frequently cited as a go-to for those seeking a truly satisfying bagel, often described as large, fluffy, and just right. While the bagel scene in NYC is competitive, with spots like Best Bagel and Popup Bagels also getting nods, Liberty Bagels holds its own, offering a reliable and delicious option. Whether you're grabbing a classic bagel or a breakfast sandwich, Liberty Bagels provides a taste of classic New York that's worth the trip, even from afar.
Liberty Bagels is known for its bagels, with many customers describing them as 'really good' and a 'much better option' for bagels in the Financial District. They are noted for being large and fluffy. One customer, however, found the bagel in a sausage and egg sandwich to be too light and the filling potentially dry. Despite this, the general consensus leans towards a positive food experience, especially for the bagels themselves.
"Customers frequently praise the bagels themselves. The Sausage & Egg Bagel was mentioned, though with mixed feedback on the bagel's texture and filling."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Liberty Bagels, often praising the quality and size of their bagels. While many find them to be a great option, some comparison points arise, with occasional mentions of alternative bagel spots in the vicinity.
Important Note
One customer found the bagel in a breakfast sandwich to be too light and the filling potentially dry, though this seems to be an outlier opinion.
"A Redditor had a very positive experience at Liberty Bagels in the Financial District (fidi), describing it as 'really good'."
Positive"A Redditor mentioned Liberty Bagels as a recommendation for bagels."
Neutral"Author recommended Liberty Bagels in Fidi, suggesting it as one of several 'much better options' for bagels, worth an early trip from Times Square."
Positive"Recommended as an alternative to Apollo Bakery for bagels, especially if you prefer them big and fluffy."
Positive"The just right for me is Liberty."
Positive"FiDi now officially bagel heaven."
Positive"User suggests Best Bagel, located across the street from Liberty Bagels, implying it's better."
Negative"Original poster explains choosing Liberty Bagels out of convenience near their hotel, finding it good but expressing a desire to have tried Popup Bagels instead."
Positive"User comments on the appearance of the Liberty Bagel breakfast sandwich, finding the bagel too light and the sausage/egg filling potentially dry."
Negative
