Next.js logo

SHOGUN OMAKASE

Updated

Phone: (917) 513-3988

Address: 295 MADISON AVENUE 10017

TLDR

Premium Omakase & Sushi. Chef-curated multi-course journey. Highlights include exquisite sushi, sashimi, & unagi.

Reddit Sentiment for SHOGUN OMAKASE(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

29% Positive29% Neutral29% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

japanese 8omakase 6sushi 5View All

Neighborhoods

Murray Hill

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

Embark on a culinary journey at this Japanese establishment, where the chef meticulously crafts a multi-course omakase experience. From delicate sushi and sashimi to expertly prepared grilled eel and other traditional preparations, each dish is a testament to authentic Japanese cuisine. While the omakase is generally well-received, some find the value proposition to be a bit high for the specific fish selections included.

Food Overview

This Japanese restaurant specializes in an authentic omakase experience, featuring a chef's choice multi-course menu. Highlights include sushi, sashimi, and grilled eel (unagi). While many enjoy the crab claws, salmon, tuna, and other nigiri pieces, some patrons feel that for the price, more premium fish like toro should be included, and items like spicy tuna on rice might not meet elite expectations.

Highlights / Recommended

"The unagi (eel), particularly the unagi don, is highly recommended and described as a dish to 'dream about'. The crab claws in a buttery broth and salmon/tuna sashimi are also noted as enjoyable parts of the omakase."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally find the omakase experience to be good with pleasant portion sizes. However, some feel the price point is a bit high considering the specific fish selections and the inclusion of less premium items.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SHOGUN OMAKASE

A detailed review of the omakase experience, noting good portion sizes but questioning the value due to specific fish selections. It mentions crab claws, salmon/tuna sashimi, tuna avocado roll, spicy tuna on rice, grilled eel, and 8 pieces of nigiri.
This highlight points out the restaurant's excellent omakase and specifically recommends the unagi (eel), noting the unagi don as a dish to dream about.
A commenter found the omakase experience to be borderline worth the cost, comparing it unfavorably to other dining options.
This commentary suggests that for $68, better value for sushi and omakase can be found at other NYC establishments, even though Shogun offers more fish and rice.
Another user agreed with the previous sentiment, finding Shogun Omakase not to be worth the $68 price point when compared to alternatives.
A user found the omakase experience to be solid and a good option for those in the Midtown area, though not their absolute top choice.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Omakase For Me Eats Raw Fish And Wife Doesnt Eat

"This restaurant has great omakase and also offers unagi (eel), which is recommended if your partner likes it."

Positive
Apr 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Omakase Shihou Midtown

"This user found Shogun Omakase to be solid, particularly suitable for when one is in Midtown for errands, though it wasn't their absolute favorite."

Neutral
Feb 6, 2026View Comment →

From post: Shogun Omakase Midtown East

"This user expressed complete agreement with the previous comment, indicating that they also found Shogun Omakase to be not worth the $68 price point when compared to other options."

Negative
Oct 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: Shogun Omakase Midtown East

"For $68, the commenter believes Shogun Omakase is difficult to justify compared to other high-quality options like Noz Market's box, although Shogun offers more fish and rice. They suggest better value can be found at places like Sushi West 35, Sugarfish, or Kazunori in NYC."

Negative
Oct 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: Shogun Omakase Midtown East

"This commenter found the Shogun Omakase experience to be borderline worth the cost, comparing it to getting a combo with soup and salad for a lower price versus a substantial dinner."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Shogun Omakase Midtown East

"The user found the omakase experience to be good with nice portion sizes, but felt the price point was a bit high given the specific fish selections and the inclusion of some less premium items like spicy tuna on rice. They suggested that adding a piece of toro would elevate the experience to a more elite level."

Negative
Oct 10, 2025View Comment →