Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (718) 207-3686
Address: 215 COLUMBIA STREET 11231
Brooklyn gem serving NYC's best burgers & outstanding seafood, with a debate on fries.
Swoony's Bar & Grill in Brooklyn is making waves in the New York City food scene, particularly for its highly praised burger, often cited as one of the best in the city. Reviewers rave about the double patty, the special sauce, and the distinctive English muffin-style bun that elevates this classic dish. Beyond the burger, Swoony's impresses with its seafood offerings, with the Lobster Orzo and Dorade being highlighted for their outstanding and memorable preparation. The restaurant also serves up well-executed comfort classics with a modern flair, including a satisfying iceberg wedge salad and well-loved deviled eggs. While the majority of feedback leans positive, a recurring point of criticism involves the french fries, which some diners found to be disappointingly frozen. Pricing has also sparked debate, though many feel the quality justifies the cost, especially in its desirable Brooklyn location.
Swoony's offers American comfort food with some innovative twists. The star of the menu appears to be the burger, frequently lauded for its double patty, special sauce, and unique English muffin-style bun, with many considering it a top-tier option in NYC. Seafood dishes, like the Lobster Orzo and Dorade, are also highly recommended for their excellent preparation. On the other hand, the french fries have drawn significant criticism, with multiple mentions of them being frozen and of poor quality, leading to some negative sentiment. Other dishes like the kale caesar salad and short rib au poivre also have positive mentions.
"The burger at Swoony's is highly recommended and considered by many to be one of the best in the city. Additionally, the Lobster Orzo and Dorade are praised for their exceptional preparation."
Customers generally have a positive view of Swoony's, with particular praise for its exceptional burger, which some consider among the city's best. The Lobster Orzo and Dorade also receive high marks for their outstanding seafood preparation. However, there are notable dissenting opinions, especially regarding the fries, which some describe as frozen and disappointing. The pricing has also been a point of contention, with some finding it to be overpriced for the location and quality, while others defend it as reasonable for the high caliber of the dishes.
Important Note
There are conflicting opinions on the french fries, with some users stating they are frozen and of poor quality. The pricing has also been a point of contention for some diners.
"Swoonys was recommended for having a good lobster orzo. However, the restaurant was later deemed unsuitable due to the user's date having a shellfish allergy."
Neutral"The commenter suggests the OP (who loved the Gramercy Tavern burger) should try the burger at Swoony's, implying it is a comparable or noteworthy option."
Positive"User recommended Swoony’s, Roman’s, Defonte’s, and Wayward Fare as restaurants that recently 'wow'd' them."
Positive"Recommends Swoonys in Cobble Hill for burgers."
Positive"User strongly dislikes Swoony’s burger, stating it 'sucks so bad.'"
Negative"User believes Swoony’s has a better burger than Red Hook Tavern."
Positive"This commenter considered Swoony's burger good but overpriced, describing it as a larger 7th Street Burger on an English muffin for triple the cost."
Neutral"This commenter believes Swoony's, along with Cafe Spaghetti and Popina, has overpriced menus for their location near Columbia and Union."
Negative"This commenter repeats the criticism that Swoony's serves frozen french fries, unfavorably comparing it to McDonald's."
Negative"The commenter criticizes Swoony's for serving frozen french fries."
Negative"A commenter thinks Swoony's gets too much criticism and specifically praises the kale caesar salad and short rib au poivre as great dishes."
Positive"The commenter finds the burger at Swoony's to be excellent, comparing it favorably to the best burgers in the city."
Positive"This commenter agrees Swoony's is overrated, criticizes its frozen fries, and suggests the owning restaurant group is just exploiting a lack of options in the area."
Negative"The commenter expressed strong disappointment with Swoony's burger, calling it 'downright shit'."
Negative"In response to price criticism, this commenter defends Swoony's pricing as reasonable for the quality and the expensive neighborhood."
Positive"The commenter felt Swoony's was significantly overrated. They also thought appreciating that no dish costs more than $37 was unreasonable, implying $37 is already too high."
Negative"The original poster highly praises Swoony's cooking, especially the Lobster Orzo and Dorade, considering them among the city's best seafood dishes. They also found the pricing reasonable, with no dish over $37."
Positive"Swoony's is a good restaurant in Brooklyn"
Neutral
