Thick, gooey cookies & other baked delights. A true NYC sweet treat staple.
Levain Bakery is a legendary New York establishment, renowned for its incredibly thick and gooey cookies that are a must-try for any visitor. While cookies are the star, they also offer delicious pastries and bread, making it a versatile spot for a sweet treat or a quality carb fix. The bakery has gained a cult following for its generous portions and consistent quality, solidifying its place in NYC's culinary landscape.
The primary draw is the exceptionally thick, gooey, and substantial cookies, with flavors like chocolate chip walnut and double chocolate chip receiving high marks. While some find them to be the best cookies they've ever had, a few reviewers find them too dense, sweet, or even underbaked, with one person describing them as a 'gross scone-cookie hybrid.' Beyond cookies, they also offer baguettes and cakes which have received positive mentions.
"Levain Bakery is most famous for its thick, gooey cookies, particularly the chocolate chip walnut and double chocolate chip varieties. The oatmeal raisin cookie is also highlighted as a standout by some customers."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the cookies, calling them amazing, incredible, and a must-try NYC experience. While some find them to be the best, a minority consider them overrated or too dense.
Important Note
Some customers find the cookies to be too large, dense, or sweet, and a minority opinion suggests they may be overrated or have declined in quality. One user described them as a 'gross scone-cookie hybrid.'
"The user enjoys getting 'a few' Levain cookies when visiting, acknowledging that one is never enough but it leads to carrying a heavy bag."
Positive"This commenter considers the Levain cookie the real winner of the post, viewing all other items as mere appetizers in comparison."
Positive"The user found the cookie from Levain Bakery to be nice, but ultimately unremarkable, stating 'meh'."
Neutral"The user mentioned Levain Bakery, which is more known for cookies, also has a good baguette."
Positive"The author gave Levain Bakery a positive rating with a thumbs up emoji."
Positive"The commenter, a native New Yorker, enjoys Levain Bakery cookies, preferring them soft and gooey."
Positive"The commenter recommends The Pastry Box in Alphabet City for excellent baked goods."
Positive"The commenter suggests cutting Levain Bakery cookies into smaller portions and freezing them for later enjoyment."
Neutral"The commenter finds Levain Bakery cookies to be too much, even a single cookie being excessive due to their size and sweetness."
Negative"The commenter asks for alternative cookie recommendations in NYC."
Neutral"The commenter states that most New Yorkers do not enjoy Levain Bakery cookies, finding them too dense, thick, and sweet."
Negative"The author did not enjoy the cookies from Levain bakery, finding them too big, hard, and sweet. They felt that the ice cream from Caffe Panna saved the experience."
Negative"This user found Levain's cookies to be disappointingly underbaked, suggesting they were taken out of the oven too early. They preferred cookies from Janine's and Counter Service."
Negative"Levain Bakery offers gift boxes on their website, which can contain cookies, tea, coffee, blankets, or candles."
Neutral"The commenter is not a big fan of Levain cookies, especially when compared to other top chocolate chip cookie options like The Pastry Box, La Mercerie, and Culture Espresso."
Negative"Similar to Katz Deli advice, this opinion suggests that cookies from Levain Bakery are great for taking home, rather than eating on the spot. They can be stored and enjoyed later, possibly frozen."
Neutral"Recommends picking up Levain cookies to take home on the last day, noting they reheat well. This is suggested as a good option for travel compared to other desserts."
Positive"Levain Bakery is considered overrated and not unique to New York by this commenter."
Negative"The user is considering Levain Bakery for cookies and asks for a comparison with Funny Face. This comment suggests Levain's cookies are good, but perhaps better saved for later due to the size of other planned meals."
Neutral"Lists Levain cookies as a potential item to buy and freeze."
Positive
