TLDR
Farm-to-table Italian on the UWS, known for seasonal specials, housemade pastas, and a gorgeous, upscale-casual vibe.
Details
Sempre Oggi, a hyper-seasonal Sicilian restaurant on the Upper West Side, is celebrated for its elevated Italian cuisine with unique touches and a focus on fresh, market-driven ingredients [1]. The menu, which changes almost daily, highlights housemade pastas, perfectly cooked porchetta with crispy skin, and exceptional vegetable dishes [1]. Diners also praise the restaurant for its beautiful interior, contemporary ambiance, attentive service, and its accessibility for classic desserts like tiramisu [2], [3], [4].
Food Overview
Sempre Oggi offers a hyper-seasonal Sicilian and Italian menu, with a strong emphasis on vegetables, housemade pastas, and porchetta [1]. Dishes are elevated with unique touches like fresh herbs and crème fraîche [1]. While generally praised, one user noted that a half-chicken dish included dark meat, not breast meat [5]. The tiramisu is also highlighted as a reliably delicious classic dessert [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended dishes include the amazing bruschetta, delicious pasta dishes, and the classic tiramisu [2], [1]. Generous portions of ravioli have also been noted [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Customers highly recommend Sempre Oggi, praising its attentive service, contemporary ambiance, and delicious, fresh, seasonal food [3]. The restaurant is noted for its authenticity and beautiful interior, making it a strong choice for various occasions.
Caveats
While excellent value is possible, staying within a strict $50 per person budget may require limiting drinks, sharing appetizers, and splitting dessert. The restaurant is considered a good Italian option on the Upper West Side but not necessarily worth a long trip for everyone.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SEMPRE OGGI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Seeking Rec For Pretheater Dinner Near Lincoln
"This user recommends Sempre Oggi as a good option for a nice dinner around Lincoln Center."
PositiveFrom post: Who Makes The Best Chicken Breast In Nyc Juicy
"The user suggested Sempre Oggi, noting that it's a half-chicken dish which includes dark meat, when asked about the best chicken breast in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Any True Farmtotable Nearish Bryant Park Or On
"This user recommended Sempre Oggi on the UWS for its great farm-to-table, contemporary Italian food."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Spots For Taking Out Visiting Parents In
"Sempre Oggi is described as a perfect option for parents."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Pasta Spot In Manhattan For Euro
"Sempre Oggi on the UWS is described as a more modern/upscale Italian option."
PositiveFrom post: Nice Dinner Date Around Central Park
"The user expressed interest in trying Sempre Oggi after it was recommended, noting their enjoyment of Italian food."
PositiveFrom post: Nice Dinner Date Around Central Park
"The user recommended Sempre Oggi as a lovely Italian farm-to-table option with a calm and elevated vibe, located just a block from Central Park on the Upper West Side."
PositiveFrom post: Spots Where Bar Seated Meal Is Great
"The commenter listed Sempre oggi as a restaurant where dining at the bar is enjoyable."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Out Of Town Guest Uws Or West
"This commenter mentioned hearing good things about Sempre Oggi."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get More Than 4 Or 5 Raviolis
"The user reported getting at least 10 ravioli at Sempre Oggi on the Upper West Side recently."
PositiveFrom post: Best Tiramisu In Manhattan
"Sempre Oggi on the UWS is a more accessible option for tiramisu compared to places like Don Angie's."
PositiveFrom post: Why Are Nearly All Of The Highly Recommended Food
"Sempre Oggi was listed as a good Italian restaurant on the Upper West Side, but not considered worth a long trip."
NeutralFrom post: Italian Dinner Recommendations
"This commenter mentioned having a great experience at Sempre Oggi on the Upper West Side."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Date Spot Near Beacon Theatre
"Siempre Oggi is listed as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Celebratory Work Dinner Spots
"This user highly recommended Sempre Oggi on the Upper West Side (UWS), stating it was 'SO good' and had 'potentially the best service' they'd ever had at a restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pastaitalian Nyc
"Sempre Oggi is highly recommended for its attentive service, contemporary ambiance, and delicious, fresh, market-driven, and seasonal food. The commenter prefers it over Osteria Nonnino, Torrisi, and Lucciola, citing Torrisi as potentially being too 'scene-y'."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurant To Feel Classy On A Budget
"Sempre Oggi is a favorite, particularly the bar area which is quiet and cozy, allowing for good conversation. The food is elevated with Michelin bib gourmand status, and while staying within a $50 pp budget is difficult, it's possible by limiting drinks, sharing appetizers (like the amazing bruschetta), and splitting dessert. The pasta dishes are delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurant To Feel Classy On A Budget
"Sempre Oggi on the Upper West Side is noted for its beautiful interior and reasonable pricing, depending on the order."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Some Authentic Italian Recommendations
"This user expressed doubt that NYC food can match the authenticity of Italy but recommended Semprenyc as being pretty legit and having a gorgeous mosaic at the bar."
NeutralFrom post: Best Italian Spot On The Uws
"This user recommended Sempre Oggi on 75th street."
Positive