Italian dining near the Beacon Theatre w/ spacious ambiance & creative classics. Highly recommended for its value & standout dishes like house-made rigatoni.
Sempre Oggi, an Italian gem on the Upper West Side, offers a unique dining experience that consistently exceeds expectations. Its surprisingly spacious and contemporary interior, adorned with striking gold busts, sets it apart from the usual New York City hustle. Just a block away from the Beacon Theatre, it's a perfect pre-show or special occasion destination. The menu features authentic Italian cuisine with delightful creative touches. Don't miss the fresh calamari, the highly acclaimed house-made rigatoni with guanciale, or their perfectly executed tiramisu. Other customer favorites include the whipped sheep's milk ricotta, the outstanding little gem Caesar salad, and the flavorful cappelletti. With its great value and Michelin recognition, Sempre Oggi has quickly become a new favorite for many.
This Italian restaurant offers an authentic culinary experience with creative twists on classic Italian fare. Standout dishes include fresh calamari with herbs and crème fraîche, house-made rigatoni with crispy guanciale and roasted tomato sauce, and an expertly prepared, light tiramisu. Other highly recommended items are the whipped sheep's milk ricotta, little gem Caesar salad, and cappelletti, all described as outstanding.
"Highly recommended dishes include the whipped sheep's milk ricotta, the outstanding little gem Caesar salad, and the flavorful cappelletti."
Customers express strong positive sentiment towards this Italian restaurant, frequently recommending it for its fantastic, spacious atmosphere, great value, and consistent quality. It's noted as being conveniently located near the Beacon Theatre. Several reviewers highlighted specific dishes as outstanding and particularly enjoyed the overall dining experience, with some even calling it a new favorite. The restaurant's Michelin recognition (though clarified as recognized, not starred) adds to its appeal.
Important Note
While recognized by Michelin, it is not starred.
"Sempre Oggi is highly recommended as a new favorite, offering a great meal, lovely dining room, and delicious, elevated dining choices, having recently been added to the Michelin guide. It's conveniently located a block from The Beacon."
Positive"Author mentions Sempre Oggi, a restaurant that recently received a Michelin Star, as a promising dining option located a bit further than Felice. They noted that reservations were easy to get a week prior to the comment, though this might change."
Positive"The author recommends Sempre Oggi as a dining option."
Positive"Expresses personal preference for Sempre Oggi but is unsure of availability."
Positive"Corrects that Sempre Oggi is Michelin recognized, not starred."
Neutral"Recommends Sempre Oggi, highlighting its Michelin recognition, availability, and Italian-leaning menu with pancakes."
Positive"The author suggests Sempre Oggi on 75th for dinner, followed by Wallace Lounge for piano and drinks, as a recommendation for a special night out."
Neutral"Highly recommends Sempre Oggi, noting it's fantastic, spacious, great value, and just a block from the Beacon Theatre. Food and service consistently exceed expectations."
Positive"Suggests Sempre Oggi as an Italian option near Beacon Theatre."
Neutral
