Exceptional French-inspired seafood & a top-tier wine list; a must-visit for raw bar lovers.
PENNY SP LLC, located in Manhattan's East 10th Street, is making waves in the culinary scene as a top-tier seafood destination. Praised for its minimalist yet chic atmosphere, the restaurant excels in its refined approach to French-inspired seafood. The menu is a celebration of freshness, with stand-out raw bar offerings like oysters, clams, and mussels, as well as an exceptional crudo selection. The wine list is frequently cited as one of the best in the city, perfectly complementing the delicate flavors of the seafood. Dishes such as stuffed squid and Dover sole in bordelaise showcase the chef's skill in enhancing natural tastes through precise preparation. While one reviewer noted a sterile ambiance, the general consensus points to a vibrant and sophisticated dining experience, making it a recommended spot for everything from solo dinners to special birthday celebrations.
Penny is a highly-regarded seafood restaurant with a strong emphasis on fresh, expertly prepared dishes. Customers rave about the raw bar selections, including oysters, clams, mussels, scallops, and shrimp, often served in impressive 'ice box trays.' The crudo is also a standout, with one mention of a particularly refined tuna carpaccio. The cuisine is described as minimalist and French-inspired, with a focus on enhancing the natural flavors of the seafood through precise cooking techniques. Other notable dishes include stuffed squid and a Dover sole in bordelaise. A must-try dessert is the chocolate cake from the downstairs establishment, Claud.
"The raw bar selections, particularly the ice box trays featuring oysters, clams, mussels, scallops, and shrimp, are highly recommended. The crudo, especially the tuna carpaccio, is also a standout dish."
Overall, customers have a very positive view of Penny. Multiple sources highlight its exceptional seafood, particularly the raw bar selections and crudo. The wine list is frequently praised as one of the best in NYC. There's also mention of a sophisticated yet minimalist approach to French-inspired seafood dishes. While the atmosphere is described as potentially sterile by one user, others find it chic and vibrant. It's also noted as a great spot for solo dining and birthday dinners.
Important Note
One user described the atmosphere as potentially sterile, although others found it chic and vibrant. Most seating is reserved for walk-ins, so arriving early is recommended.
"Penny/Claud is mentioned as a unique wine bar to consider, especially if there are waits at other places."
Neutral"This user believes Penny is the best choice for the birthday dinner, citing its perfect vibes for the described criteria."
Positive"Penny is recommended as a top pick for a birthday dinner, particularly for its bar-only seating and excellent crudo."
Positive"Penny is described as a French restaurant that has become hyped since being featured in the NYT Top Restaurants list. Despite a sterile atmosphere, the food is outstanding, and it offers bar-only seating with great service."
Positive"Penny is recommended alongside Quique Crudo for its excellent food, with the user highlighting its great crudo."
Positive"This user simply mentioned "Penny" as a recommendation for a birthday dinner."
Neutral"Highlighted as Claud's awesome, seafood-focused sister restaurant."
Positive"Recommended, especially if the visitors love seafood."
Positive
