TLDR
A 2 Michelin-star seafood tasting menu lauded for innovative dishes and exceptional ingredients. Known for unique bites and a refined experience.
Instagram Posts References
César New York is lauded as the best fine dining tasting menu in the city, holding 2 Michelin stars. The author expresses deep obsession with the restaurant, particularly noting the value of their supplements, stating they are 'absolutely worth every penny.' The chef's choice of A4 wagyu over A5 is highlighted for its superior flavor. The experience is elevated by thoughtful details like D2 stainless steel knives, which took 10 years to acquire, and a real silverware collection. An impressive bar cart that is brought to the table also contributes to the luxurious atmosphere.
Details
César, a two-Michelin-starred establishment, is celebrated for its exceptional fine dining tasting menu, particularly its focus on high-quality seafood and innovative dishes [1]. While many praise the chef's meticulous execution and unique culinary creations, such as the standout prawn monaka with uni and ikura, some diners find the experience pricey and inconsistent compared to other top-tier restaurants [2], [3]. The restaurant is noted for its engaging atmosphere and attentive service, though concerns about the value of add-ons and overall dining experience have been raised [4].
Food Overview
César offers a highly-regarded tasting menu with a strong emphasis on seafood, earning two Michelin stars. Standout dishes include the Prawn Monaka with Uni and Ikura, and the Quail with Quail Ballotine and Foie Gras, with the squab with foie gras and sausage also being a top favorite [1], [2], [3]. While many praise the quality and execution, some find the food unmemorable or the tasting menu lacking in courses compared to other fine dining establishments [4], [5]. The restaurant also offers supplements and add-ons which can significantly increase the bill [6].
Highlights / Recommended
"Standout dishes include the Prawn Monaka with Uni and Ikura, and the Quail with Quail Ballotine and Foie Gras. The squab with foie gras and sausage has also been highlighted as a top favorite [1], [2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •supplements(2)
- •squab with foie gras and sausage(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer sentiment is largely positive, with frequent praise for standout dishes and attentive service, though some find it pricey and note potential for high add-on costs [1], [2]. There are also mixed opinions, with some finding the food unmemorable and service lacking, while others rank it among the city's best [3].
Caveats
Some diners have expressed concerns about the restaurant's pricing, particularly regarding add-ons and supplements, which can significantly increase the overall cost of the meal [1], [2]. There have also been discussions and allegations surrounding potential discrimination and a past lawsuit, leading some to advise against dining at the establishment [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CESAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended the uni bite from Cesar."
PositiveFrom post: Is Beefbar Worth It Going Friday And Im Wondering
"This user suggests Cesar as a potential option for a tasting menu in Tribeca if one is price-conscious and looking for an alternative to meat-focused restaurants, though it is not primarily a meat restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Single Best Restaurant Dish In Nyc In
"The squab with foie gras and sausage at César was mentioned as a top dish."
PositiveFrom post: Fine Diningspecial Occasion Help Jungsik Aska Or
"This user mentions Cesar as a potential option, implying it offers more interesting culinary experiences."
PositiveFrom post: Making An Impression Introducing Friends To Fine
"Cesar is recommended for its interesting ambiance and fresh takes on cuisine, contrasting with more generic establishments."
PositiveFrom post: Fine Diningspecial Occasion Help Jungsik Aska Or
"This commenter suggests Cesar as doing more interesting things compared to more classic fine dining establishments."
PositiveFrom post: Whats One Fine Dining Restaurant That
"The commenter criticizes Cesar for being cramped, having small plates, lacking hospitality, and being rushed, despite being priced for fine dining."
NegativeFrom post: Whats One Fine Dining Restaurant That
"Cesar is listed as a contemporary fine dining establishment, but the commenter questions its hospitality and suggests it may be overpriced for the experience."
NegativeFrom post: 13 Nyc Spots Made North Americas 50 Best
"Believes César is a justifiable inclusion on the list."
PositiveFrom post: Visited Cesar Tonight Compared To My Ctbf Visit
"This commenter stated that their experience at Cesar was one of their most disappointing Michelin meals."
NegativeFrom post: Visited Cesar Tonight Compared To My Ctbf Visit
"The user visited Cesar and compared it to a previous visit at Chefs Table at Brooklyn Fare. They found Cesar to be a nice meal but were left slightly disappointed and hungry compared to their prior experience. They noted Cesar had fewer courses and a different distribution of fish and meat dishes."
NegativeFrom post: Looking To Treat Ourselves To A High End Dinner
"The commenter listed César as one of their favorites."
PositiveFrom post: Looking To Treat Ourselves To A High End Dinner
"The original poster stated they loved their experience at César."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Dish Youve Had In 2026 And Where
"This user ranked the squab with foie gras and sausage at César as their top favorite dish."
PositiveFrom post: Halal Fine Dining Nyc
"Cesar is a predominantly seafood-focused restaurant that is considered one of the best options for halal-friendly seafood with advance notice to adjust the menu and substitute alcohol-based sauces."
PositiveFrom post: Have 1000 For 2 Where Do I Go
"Considers Cesar a good option, especially if the meal can be expensed."
PositiveFrom post: Have 1000 For 2 Where Do I Go
"Found meals at Cesar frustratingly inconsistent, with both amazing and bad dishes."
NegativeFrom post: The 38 Best Restaurants In New York City
"This user suggested that Cesar is one of the city's joint best restaurants, implying it should have been prioritized over Daniel on a "best of" list."
PositiveFrom post: Best Kitchen View Restaurants In Nyc
"Cesar is listed as a restaurant with counter seating that offers a kitchen view."
Positive