Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (732) 824-8529
Address: 73 GREENWICH AVENUE 10014
Bagels so good they might be the best in NYC. Fluffy, flavorful, and worth the hype for unique combos like salmon or white fish salad.
This bagel shop is frequently lauded as one of the best in NYC, with many praising its fluffy, airy, and flavorful bagels. Customers rave about specific combinations like the everything bagel with salmon and the white fish salad bagel, noting the attention to detail and quality ingredients. While some debate its place among the city's top bagel contenders, the consensus points to a unique and satisfying bagel experience, possibly with a sourdough twist.
The restaurant specializes in bagels, with many customers calling them the best in NYC. Particular praise is given to the everything bagel with salmon and the white fish salad bagel. Some describe the bagels as having a sourdough quality, which some enjoy while others find it a departure from traditional bagels.
"The everything bagel with salmon and the white fish salad bagel are frequently recommended, with customers praising the quality and flavor combinations."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bagels, describing them as fluffy, airy, and flavorful. Specific toppings and combinations are frequently highlighted as exceptional.
Important Note
Some find the bagels to be a sourdough style, which may not appeal to everyone looking for a traditional bagel. There are also differing opinions on whether the bagels are overhyped or mediocre.
"This commenter elaborates that even as a bread product, Apollo bagels are mediocre."
Negative"This commenter disagrees, stating that Apollo Bagels are not very good."
Negative"This commenter believes Apollo Bagels makes the best bagels in the city by a significant margin."
Positive"The author acknowledges Apollo Bagels' offerings are sourdough bread in a bagel shape, but finds them to be very good sourdough. They are considered tasty, though potentially overhyped, and better than a specific pop-up."
Positive"This user provided the location of Apollo Bagels West Village in response to a query about an onigiri pop-up."
Neutral"Apollo bagel is listed as a recommended restaurant."
Positive"The commenter expresses a preference for Pop Up Bagels over Apollo Bagels."
Neutral"Apollo bagels are characterized as a riff on an LA bagel style, with Utopia on 34th Street suggested as an alternative."
Neutral"The commenter suggests that there are better bagel options available than what was listed."
Negative"Apollo Bagels are described as good, but noted for being a toasted sourdough style, which might be a specific preference."
Neutral"The Apollo Bagel bagel is listed as something the commenter has tried and loved."
Positive"Recommends Apollo for bagels, along with Tompkins."
Positive"Thinks Apollo Bagel is better than Tompkins or Ess-a-Bagel."
Positive"Selected Apollo Bagels as their choice for one of the bagel categories."
Positive"Recommends getting a second bagel from Apollo after choosing one from the original poster's initial options."
Positive"One of the best bagels I have had in a long time; they get the details right - served open face, good ratio of salmon to cream cheese, everything seasoning on both sides of the bagel."
Positive"The original poster says Apollo Bagels was their favorite bagel."
Positive"OP found the bagels amazing - fluffy, airy, and flavorful. The combination of white fish salad, cucumber, and dill was highly praised."
Positive
