TLDR
Authentic Irish bakery famous for buttery, must-try scones and traditional soda bread. A highly-rated East Village gem that consistently draws a crowd.
Reddit Sentiment for MARY O'S IRISH SODA BREAD SHOP(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
A scone from Mary O's Irish Soda Bread Shop is featured, with the author calling it the 'perfect scone' and noting the staff is 'ridiculously nice'. Despite the $6 price point, the quality and experience are highly rated.
Mary O's Irish Soda Bread Shop is ranked as the 5th best bakery in NYC by Beli, celebrated for its authentic Irish baked goods. The shop is particularly well-regarded for its traditional Irish soda bread and delicious scones, especially those served with blackberry.
This restaurant is featured for its Irish Soda Bread Scones, noted as one of the top 12 bites of the year.
Details
Renowned for its authentic Irish baked goods, this East Village shop is celebrated for its traditional soda bread and exceptional scones [1]. While some patrons find the soda bread texture underwhelming [2], the establishment has garnered significant acclaim, even being ranked as one of the top bakeries in NYC [1]. Enthusiastic diners consistently highlight the buttery quality of the pastries, often recommending them as a must-try treat [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Irish treats, with the scones frequently cited as a standout, buttery favorite [3], [4]. Other offerings like fish pie and shepherd's pie are also recommended [5], while the accompaniments like jam are noted as fantastic [6]. While most enjoy the pastries, the soda bread has received mixed reviews concerning its texture [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARY O'S IRISH SODA BREAD SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: My Unorthodox Request For The Best Jams
"The user praises the jam that accompanied the baked goods at this establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Best Buttery Pastry Eg Croissants Scones Quiche
"This user seconded the recommendation for Mary O's scones, describing them as excellent and very buttery, especially with the addition of butter and jam."
PositiveFrom post: Best Buttery Pastry Eg Croissants Scones Quiche
"This user recommended Mary O's for excellent scones, noting that getting there earlier might be necessary to avoid lines."
PositiveFrom post: Local Ny Birthday Food Crawl East Village And
"Mary O's Irish Soda Bread was recommended, with a specific mention of their scones."
PositiveFrom post: Best Shepherds Pie In Manhattan Points For
"This user recommended Mary O's in the East Village, noting it's run by the 'scone lady' and also serves excellent fish pie."
PositiveFrom post: 4 Days What Not To Miss
"The original poster is considering Mary O’s Irish Soda Bread."
NeutralFrom post: 7 Days In Nyc How Did I Do
"The original poster found Mary O's to be average and recommended the chocolate chip scone from Clinton St. Baking Co. instead."
NegativeFrom post: 7 Days In Nyc How Did I Do
"This user asked for the original poster's opinion on Mary O's, expressing interest in visiting but uncertainty about the hype."
NeutralFrom post: 7 Days In Nyc How Did I Do
"The author mentioned trying the scone with jam at Mary O's Irish Soda Bread."
NeutralFrom post: 10 East Village Bakeries In 25 Days
"The reviewer expected a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth texture for the soda bread but found the texture a letdown, with the jam and butter doing most of the work. They also felt the 20-minute wait was too long."
Negative