Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (310) 509-6269
Address: 454 VAN BRUNT STREET 11231
Authentic TX-style BBQ w/ stellar brisket & turkey club. Lively atmosphere & live music make it a go-to, though some fusion dishes are missable.
Will Hartman reviews Hometown Bar-B-Que in Red Hook, calling it the best BBQ spot in the city and a perfect place to spend a sunny day, praising its brisket and turkey club.
This Brooklyn-based BBQ joint is a must-visit, drawing in crowds with its authentic Texas-style smoked meats and lively atmosphere, especially on sunny days. While the brisket and turkey club are consistently praised, some fusion dishes like the pulled pork may not live up to expectations. The restaurant offers a vibrant dining experience with live music, making it a great spot for groups.
Hometown BBQ is celebrated for its authentic Texas-style barbecue, particularly its brisket, which is lauded for its perfect seasoning and smoky flavor. The turkey club sandwich is another highly recommended item. While the majority of reviews are positive, some customers have found dishes like the pulled pork to be bland or gummy, and the restaurant can be on the pricier side.
"The brisket and turkey club sandwich are highly recommended. The beef rib and potato salad also receive specific praise. For dessert, the blueberry buttermilk donut and key lime pie from nearby Steve's Authentic are suggested."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic Texas-style BBQ, with specific callouts for the brisket and turkey club. However, some find it pricey, and a few negative experiences mention slow service or disappointment with certain dishes.
Important Note
The Red Hook location can be a significant trek to get to. Some reviews indicate that while it's considered the best BBQ in NYC, it can be pricey, and some dishes may not meet the highest expectations.
"Hometown BBQ in Red Hook is recommended, accessible via the free IKEA ferry."
Positive"The user recommended ordering a platter from Hometown BBQ."
Positive"The commenter recommended Hometown BBQ as part of a food crawl in Red Hook, suggesting it as a great daytime spot."
Positive"This commenter believes that no NYC barbecue is worth the price, viewing the establishments as imitations of Texas or Kansas City styles."
Negative"Hometown BBQ is considered the best in the city, but might be too much of a scene for an 82-year-old, and the commenter questions if it's true BBQ if Virgil's is considered the benchmark."
Neutral"In defense of Hometown BBQ's pricing, this user explains the high overhead costs of operating a BBQ joint in NYC, including labor, smokers, space, and meat prices, arguing it's one of the few places that rivals top Southern BBQ."
Positive"This commenter believes Hometown BBQ is overrated and unnecessarily expensive, stating there's no real BBQ in NYC."
Negative"The Red Hook location of Hometown BBQ is considered better than the Industry City location."
Positive"The commenter reiterates that Hometown BBQ is overpriced and overrated, and that NYC BBQ spots are merely 'cosplaying' as authentic."
Negative"Hometown BBQ is considered NYC's best barbecue and potentially mind-blowing for a BBQ lover, though pricey. The commenter also notes that Virgil's is not a good benchmark for NYC BBQ."
Positive"Hometown BBQ is recommended and considered worth the journey."
Positive"Hometown BBQ in Red Hook is suggested for BBQ enthusiasts, but be prepared for potential Uber costs and lines, as it's not cheap."
Positive"Hometown BBQ in Brooklyn is recommended as an impressive option if the person has never tried it."
Positive"Hometown BBQ was mentioned as an option for someone new to the US, though the commenter noted that NY doesn't excel at BBQ compared to other US regions."
Neutral"This user recommends Steve's Authentic in Red Hook for Key Lime Pie, suggesting it as a good dessert option after eating at nearby Red Hook Tavern or Hometown BBQ."
Positive"This BBQ restaurant is listed as a place that might offer a birthday freebie, such as a free meal for the birthday person. It was part of a general list of potential birthday perk locations."
Neutral"This user recommended Fette Sau and Hometown BBQ for BBQ, placing Hometown after Fette Sau. They also clarified that the original picture depicted soul food, not BBQ."
Neutral"This user confirmed that Hometown BBQ would likely be even more expensive than Pig Beach."
Neutral"This user questioned the price of a plate at Pig Beach, suggesting it might still be expensive."
Neutral"This user expressed surprise that Hometown BBQ was highly recommended when Royal Rib House was also mentioned."
Neutral
