Last Updated: 6 days ago
Phone: (310) 509-6269
Address: 454 VAN BRUNT STREET 11231
Best BBQ in NYC, known for smoky brisket & amazing sides.
Will Hartman reviews Hometown Bar-B-Que in Red Hook, calling it the best BBQ spot in the city and a perfect place to spend a sunny day, praising its brisket and turkey club.
Hometown Bar-B-Que in Red Hook is a celebrated destination for authentic Texas-style BBQ, drawing praise for its smoky, tender brisket and flavorful sides like mac and cheese and collard greens. Despite being a journey from Manhattan, diners find the experience, often enhanced by live music and a lively atmosphere, well worth it. While most of the menu impresses, some fusion dishes have received mixed reviews, with pulled pork being a notable criticism for its blandness. Overall, it's considered a top-tier BBQ spot in NYC, offering a memorable culinary experience.
Hometown Bar-B-Que is highly acclaimed for its American and Texas-style BBQ. Standout dishes include the brisket, praised for its tenderness, juiciness, and smoky flavor, and the turkey club sandwich. The potato salad is also noted for its unique, smooth texture. While most meats receive high marks, some reviews mention that pulled pork can be bland, and Korean sticky ribs or lamb banh mi might not appeal to everyone. The mac and cheese and cornbread are frequently recommended sides.
"The brisket is consistently praised as a standout, alongside the turkey club sandwich and the unique, smooth potato salad. The beef rib and mac and cheese are also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Hometown Bar-B-Que, with many hailing it as the best BBQ in NYC, comparable to top establishments in Texas. Some note that it can be pricey and a bit of a trek, but generally feel the quality justifies the cost and effort.
Important Note
Some customers find the restaurant pricey and note that the Red Hook location can be challenging to get to.
"Hometown is stated to be the undisputed best BBQ option."
Positive"Hometown is mentioned as a good BBQ option, located within the Time-Out Market."
Positive"Hometown is considered the closest to Central Texas style BBQ in NYC, though expensive. Bark BBQ was disappointing twice. Dinosaur BBQ's happy hour is a good deal, but the food can be inconsistent. Hill Country is okay but uses gas-assisted cooks. Izzy's was surprisingly good but very expensive."
Positive"Responding to a comment about lines being due to tourists, the commenter states that as a business owner, the reason for the line is less important than the fact that people are paying the prices, indicating the pricing is sustainable."
Neutral"Hometown in Red Hook is identified as the best American BBQ option in NYC."
Positive"The commenter posits that the long lines at Hometown are due to tourists and 'bougie influencees' willing to pay the prices for social media content."
Neutral"The commenter, who attended college in Texas, asserts that Hometown is the only acceptable answer for NYC BBQ."
Positive"Hometown is considered among the best BBQ places in NYC for brisket, comparable to Central Texas standards. The commenter emphasizes that brisket quality can vary by the day and piece of meat, and suggests ordering moist brisket when available. They also state ribs and brisket should not require sauce."
Positive"The commenter recommends a 12-15 minute walk from Hometown to Brooklyn French Bakers for a Puff Pastry Brioche or lemon meringue tart for dessert."
Positive"The commenter suggests that the consistent lines at Hometown indicate that their prices are not too high, as demand justifies the cost."
Positive"Dinosaur BBQ served cold food and was considered the worst meal the commenter had paid for, in contrast to Hometown which is much better."
Negative"The commenter compares Hometown's brisket price to Franklin BBQ in Austin, finding it fair. They also note that the restaurant consistently has a line, indicating demand supports the pricing."
Positive"Hometown is praised for its quality, comparable to top BBQ establishments in Texas. The owner's willingness to innovate beyond traditional methods is also appreciated."
Positive"Hometown and Bark BBQ are ranked as the top two choices. Pig Beach, Hill Country, and Mable's Smokehouse are also mentioned as decent options. John Brown's is also popular."
Positive"Hometown is described as delicious but pricey. The commenter also plans to try Dinosaur BBQ."
Positive"Hometown is generally recommended for American BBQ. The commenter also suggests exploring Korean, Szechuan, and other cuisines if the user wants variety."
Positive"Hometown is recommended as a better alternative to John Brown Smokehouse."
Positive"After dining at Hometown, the commenter suggests walking to Valentino Pier for a key lime pie from Steve's."
Positive"From a Texas perspective, Hometown's brisket, cornbread, and beef rib are highly praised. They also offer a significant meatless menu for vegetarians."
Positive"Hometown is recommended for brisket and pastrami. David's Brisket House is also suggested as an alternative."
Positive
