MANGO BAY CARIBBEAN RESTAURANT

Last Updated: 15 days ago

Address: 271 ADELPHI STREET 11205

TLDR

Upscale Afro-Caribbean w/ bold flavors & vibrant cocktails. Standouts: Goat Puff Pastry, Braised Oxtail. A must-try for an elevated island vibe.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 10 Reddit comments)

80% Positive10% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Neighborhoods

Fort Greene

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Recent Articles

Mango Bay

positive

Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Mango Bay, a Fort Greene Caribbean restaurant, highlighting its elegant yet relaxed atmosphere and vibrant dishes like Goat Puff Pastry and Hamachi Crudo. The cocktails are also noted as a strong point.

Molly Fitzpatrick • Jun 10, 2025

Infatuation

Details

This Fort Greene gem offers a modern Afro-Caribbean experience, blending classic flavors with an upscale twist. The vibrant atmosphere complements a menu filled with creative dishes, from a standout Goat Puff Pastry to succulent Braised Oxtail. It's a place that celebrates the diaspora through delicious food and well-crafted cocktails, making it a must-try for an elevated island dining experience.

Food Overview

The menu offers a modern take on Afro-Caribbean cuisine, with many dishes receiving high praise. Standouts include the Goat Puff Pastry, Braised Oxtail, and Ackee & Saltfish Eggrolls. While most dishes are highly recommended, the Pomegranate Glazed Pork Ribs were noted as a less successful dish.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the Goat Puff Pastry, Braised Oxtail, Ackee & Saltfish Eggrolls, Hamachi Crudo, and the Mango Curry Australian King Prawn."

Mentioned Dishes:

goat puff pastry(4)
braised oxtail(4)
hamachi crudo(2)
calypso fashioned(2)
ras & pasta(2)
mango curry australian king prawn(2)
jerk burger(2)
deep fried red snapper(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its delicious and creative Afro-Caribbean cuisine, vibrant atmosphere, and well-crafted cocktails, often describing it as a highly positive and memorable dining experience.

Important Note

The Pomegranate Glazed Pork Ribs were described as dry and slightly burned, though the avocado mousse helped mitigate this.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Better than Tatiana?

A user recommends Mango Bay in Fort Greene, describing it as an upscale Afro-Caribbean restaurant where all dishes tried were delicious, including their food tags of 'afro-caribbean'.

What Brooklyn restaurant wow'd you recently?

A user recommended MangoBay as a restaurant that recently 'wow'd' them, highlighting its Caribbean and Jamaican cuisine.

Better than Tatiana?

The commenter suggests checking out Mango Bay and Mangoseed.

What Brooklyn restaurant wow'd you recently?

Another user also recommended Mango Bay in Brooklyn.

Better than Tatiana?

This commenter states that Mango Bay is delicious.