Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (516) 849-6039
Address: 196 WEST 108 STREET 10025
Neapolitan pizzas w/ charred crusts & unique salty sauce. Great tiramisu & housemade sausage pie.
Sonal Shah praises Super Nice Pizza for its throwback vibes and authentic Neapolitan pies, highlighting its charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty rather than sweet.
This Upper West Side spot offers a throwback dining experience with authentic Neapolitan pizzas. Praised for its charred crusts and a unique salty sauce, the pizzas are a must-try, especially the one featuring housemade sausage. Complement your meal with their fantastic tiramisu for a truly satisfying experience.
Customers rave about the pizzas, noting the good, airy dough and quality ingredients. The sausage pie is frequently recommended, though some suggest trying a different white pie next time. The tiramisu is also a highly praised dessert. Some diners have also reported surprisingly excellent fried calamari and a standout potato pizza with smoked mozzarella. The only noted downside is uncomfortable seating in some areas.
"The sausage pie and tiramisu are consistently recommended. The potato pizza with smoked mozzarella and the chocolate cake slice are also highlighted as excellent choices."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, praising the authentic Neapolitan pizzas, particularly the sausage pie and tiramisu, although some found the seating uncomfortable.
Important Note
The restaurant seating, specifically the stools being very low, has been noted as uncomfortable by at least one customer.
"Super Nice Pizza is noted for having an incredible potato pizza that includes smoked mozzarella."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza surprisingly served what a user considered the best fried calamari they’d ever had."
Positive"The user highly recommended the chocolate cake at Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side, noting its excellent quality and large portion size."
Positive"The author throws in an 'unknown rec' for Super Nice Pizza, located high up on the UWS, stating they have a great and huge chocolate cake slice."
Positive"i ve been to the one on amsterdam and 108 countless times and have never found them greasy."
Neutral"The sausage pie, white zucchini pie, and tiramisu were all great."
Positive"Dough on the pizza was good and airy. Ingredients were great."
Positive"I’d probably try a different white pie next time, but the sausage was fantastic."
Positive"Also drank a glass of Lambrusco and a Paper Crane that were great."
Positive"Nice ambiance in the spot"
Positive"only complaint is my chair was a stool super low to the ground. My back is still killing me. Has to be the most uncomfortable restaurant seating I’ve ever experienced."
Negative
