TLDR
Zhuzhed-up Cantonese American w/ Italian swagger. Perfect for casual group dinners, standouts include hot & sour soup & crystal shrimp dumplings.
Willa Moore reviews Sal Tang's, a Cobble Hill Chinese restaurant offering a unique blend of Cantonese American cuisine and Italian swagger, perfect for casual group meals.
Details
This Cobble Hill establishment offers a zhuzhed-up Cantonese American experience, blending traditional flavors with a touch of Italian swagger in its ambiance. It's a spot perfect for casual group meals, with reviewers praising starters like the thick, tangy hot and sour soup and crystal shrimp dumplings. While some mains received mixed reviews, the overall sentiment leans positive, especially for its dim sum and elevated casual dishes.
Food Overview
The cuisine is Cantonese American, with some reviewers finding it average and overpriced, particularly the Chinese and American Chinese dishes. However, specific items like the hot and sour soup, crystal shrimp dumplings, and vegetable fried rice have been praised for their flavor and presentation. There's a noted mention of a lychee cocktail and wonton chips being available.
Caveats
Some customers feel the restaurant is overpriced for the quality of food, and there are criticisms regarding its authenticity and flavor profiles compared to other Chinese dining options.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAL TANG'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Iso Chinatown Restaurant That Gives Out Fried
"This user stated that Sal Tang's in Brooklyn serves the desired wonton chips."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Has A New 3 Star Restaraunt
"This user reiterates their disappointment with Sal Tang's, calling it 'dressed up mediocrity' and contrasting it with the strengths of Cafe Spaghetti and Swoony's."
NegativeFrom post: Nyc Has A New 3 Star Restaraunt
"This user found Sal Tang's to be 'fine' but not compelling enough to return, especially when compared to the user's preferred restaurants in the neighborhood."
NeutralFrom post: New Bib Gourmand Awards 2025
"This user confirmed that Sal Tang's refers to itself as Chinese-American and is described as such in articles, suggesting the prior criticism was unfounded."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Has A New 3 Star Restaraunt
"This user expresses strong disappointment with Sal Tang's, finding it bland and only suitable for guests who cannot handle strong flavors."
NegativeFrom post: New Bib Gourmand Awards 2025
"This user questioned the criticism of Sal Tang's menu, stating it appeared to be Chinese-American and wondered if the critic's issue was its lack of a 'run down' appearance."
NeutralFrom post: New Bib Gourmand Awards 2025
"This user commented on the criticism of Sal Tang's, acknowledging it as decent but noting its menu has Chinese-American and some mainland influences, and suggested fellow Chinese individuals should be more supportive."
NeutralFrom post: New Bib Gourmand Awards 2025
"This user strongly disagreed with the positive assessment of Sal Tang's, criticizing the frozen dumplings and lack of authentic Cantonese elements, despite its Chinese-American billing."
NegativeFrom post: New Bib Gourmand Awards 2025
"This user expressed positive sentiment towards Sal Tang's, stating they loved the restaurant and its great vibe."
PositiveFrom post: The Newest Additions To The Michelin Guide New
"This commenter noted that Sal Tang's serves the same Chinese and American Chinese food at a higher price point, also mentioning a lychee cocktail."
NegativeFrom post: The Newest Additions To The Michelin Guide New
"The commenter found Sal Tang's to be extremely average and unremarkable."
Negative