Exceptional pizza with a life-changing spinach slice, praised for perfect crust and sauce. A top NYC spot.
Lucia Pizzeria is a standout destination for pizza lovers, consistently earning rave reviews from diners. Visitors frequently describe the pizza as exceptional, with many hailing it as the best they've had in NYC. The crust and sauce are often cited as perfect, contributing to the overall deliciousness. Standout slices include the pepperoni and hot honey, the vodka slice, and a particularly lauded spinach slice described as 'life-changing.' The Funghi and Papa Leone slices also receive high marks. While the vast majority of feedback is glowing, one patron noted that the crispiness of the slices can occasionally be inconsistent, sometimes leaning towards being overly crispy.
Lucia Pizzeria is highly acclaimed for its pizza, with patrons consistently recommending various slices. The pepperoni and hot honey slice, along with the vodka slice and spinach slice, have received particular praise for their exceptional flavor. The Funghi and Papa Leone slices are also highlighted as excellent. While generally lauded, one customer did mention that slices can sometimes be too crispy, bordering on cracker-like, suggesting a potential for inconsistency.
"Highly recommended are the pepperoni and hot honey slice, the vodka slice, and the spinach slice. The Funghi and Papa Leone slices also receive strong endorsements."
Customers are overwhelmingly positive about Lucia Pizzeria, frequently praising the quality and flavor of their pizza. Many consider it among the best in NYC, with specific commendations for unique slices like the spinach and hot honey options. While most experiences are excellent, one user noted occasional inconsistency in the crispiness of their slices.
Important Note
One customer noted that the slices can occasionally be inconsistent, sometimes being too crispy.
"Mentions Lucia Pizza is located near the Met."
Neutral"When asked for their top 3 spots from the trip, the visitor listed Lucia Pizza among them."
Positive"Visitor responded that they really enjoyed Lucia Pizza and were ultimately glad it made their list."
Positive"Visitor greatly enjoyed Lucia Pizza UES (9.5/10), praising the perfect crust and sauce on the Funghi and Papa Leone slices. The Sicilian Pep slice was also very good but slightly overcooked/charred for their taste."
Positive"Recommended for their pepperoni and hot honey, and vodka slice."
Positive"The pies are good. I’ve found the slices to be inconsistent though. Sometimes theyre crispy to the point of being a hard cracker."
Neutral"I went with Lucia and loved it, great flavor!"
Positive"Poblano funghi slice is incredible and I had the spinach slice."
Positive"Newly opened but firing on all cylinders"
Positive
