TLDR
Elevated whole-pie pizza with premium ingredients and a cult-like reservation process. A high-end experience that divides opinion on value and effort.
Instagram Posts References
The user includes an image of the exterior of Ceres, a pizzeria, and a pizza box with the restaurant's logo. A sign in the window indicates that only whole pies are sold, not slices. This suggests the user may have purchased a whole pizza from this establishment.
Bryan Kim reviews Ceres Pizza, a NYC spot famous for its thin and chewy slices, and notes that the 'nduja pie with burrata and balsamic is worth the hassle.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Ceres, an innovative, high-end pizzeria run by Eleven Madison Park alumni that focuses on technical pizza science.
Details
Known for its fine-dining approach to pizza, this destination offers exceptionally thin, crispy pies featuring premium ingredients [2]. While many enthusiasts praise the quality of specialty options like the mushroom and nduja pizzas [1], [7], the experience is polarized by its high price point and demanding ordering process [1], [5]. Due to its popularity and small-scale operation, securing a pie often requires advance reservation or significant wait times [1], [2].
The mushroom pie and the nduja pie with burrata and balsamic are frequently recommended as standout, high-quality options [1], [5], [7].
Customer sentiment is highly divided, with patrons either hailing the pizza as an exceptional, high-quality treat or dismissing it as an overpriced, overhyped experience [1], [5]. Frequent complaints center on the significant time commitment and the high cost of whole pies [1], [5], [6].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01mushroom pie36 mentionsThe mushroom pie is consistently praised as outstanding and a mus...
- 02pizza28 mentionsThe pizza at Ceres is generally described as high-quality and del...
- 03nduja pizza20 mentionsThe 'nduja pizza is frequently hailed as spectacular and a top re...
- 04cheese pizza20 mentionsThe cheese pizza receives mixed reviews, with some finding it goo...
- 05tomato pie7 mentionsReviews for the tomato pie are varied, with some finding it just ...
- 06regular pie6 mentionsThe 'regular' options are described as decent or good but not exc...
Caveats
Pies are sold only as whole units and can be quite expensive, with prices reaching up to $75 [4], [6]. The ordering process can be restrictive, and the restaurant is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays [1], [5], [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CERES
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Based On Taste Alone Which Of These Food Options
"The restaurant is described as specializing only in pies, and the user warns that it is expensive at $63 per pie and may not be ideal for small groups."
NeutralFrom post: Just Paid 75 Bucks For A Ceres Pie But Damn Its
"The user lists specific prices for cheese and nduja pies."
NeutralFrom post: Just Paid 75 Bucks For A Ceres Pie But Damn Its
"The user notes the founders came from Eleven Madison Park and that while the pizza is good, it is hard to justify the price."
NeutralFrom post: Red Hook Tavern Burger Overhyped Steak Tartare
"Mentioned as an overhyped pizza spot."
NegativeFrom post: Just Paid 75 Bucks For A Ceres Pie But Damn Its
"The user disliked the experience due to cold staff and a crust that tasted like whole wheat bread."
Negative