Next.js logo

BAGIZZA BAGELS & PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (201) 704-7789

Address: 424 MADISON AVENUE 10017

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Midtown's 24/7 hybrid spot serving ultra-budget thin-crust pizza and experimental bagel-pizza creations.

Reddit Sentiment for BAGIZZA BAGELS & PIZZA(based on 9 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive

Tags

italian 5american 3deli 3pizza 6bagel 2bagels 2View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Bagizza
negative

Will Hartman reviews Bagizza, a Midtown spot that combines bagel dough and pizza toppings, finding the concept to be a textural and flavor mistake.

Will Hartman • May 30, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is mentioned alongside others.

Mentioned In
The 18 best bagels in NYC
positive

Baz Bagel and Restaurant is a trendy bagel shop that uses the traditional boil and bake method. They offer unique creations like tie-dye bagels alongside more standard varieties.

Amber Sutherland-Namako & Morgan Carter • Sep 9, 2024
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
Where to Eat and Drink in Midtown
very negative

Bagizza, a Midtown deli open 24 hours, attempts a bagel-pizza hybrid that the article suggests does not work, despite its round-the-clock availability.

Bryan Kim, Molly Fitzpatrick, Will Hartman, Sonal Shah & Tiffany Yannetta • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Located in Midtown, this 24/7 establishment attempts a unique culinary experiment by merging bagel dough with traditional pizza toppings [1]. While the venue is noted for its round-the-clock availability, professional critics have found the hybrid concept to be a textural and flavor-based failure [1]. Conversely, some local diners view it as a budget-friendly destination for simple, thin-crust pizza options [4], [6].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on a polarizing 'bagizza' concept that features flattened bagel dough topped with pizza ingredients, which has been criticized for being doughy and clashing in flavor [1]. However, regular patrons often recommend the standard thin-crust margarita pizza, which is frequently cited for its impressive value at roughly $5-$6 cash [2], [4], [6].

Highlights / Recommended

"The thin-crust margarita pizza is consistently recommended by diners as a reliable, inexpensive meal option [2], [4], [6]."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is polarized between those who value the extreme affordability of the thin-crust pizza [4], [6] and those who criticize the overall execution of the hybrid menu concept [1].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About BAGIZZA BAGELS & PIZZA

Decently priced lunch options around Rockefeller
This post highlights the establishment as a solid choice for a cheap $6 margherita pizza lunch in the Rockefeller area.
Cheap but healthy eats near Times Square
A user recommends the 10-inch thin crust pizza as a budget-friendly find near Times Square.
Did Urbanspace on W52nd close?
Discussed in the context of declining food hall options, this comment identifies the spot as a reliable source for a $5 cash margarita pizza.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Decently Priced Lunch Options Around Rockefeller

"Affordable pizza option if paying with cash."

Positive
Jul 14, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cheap But Healthy Eats Near Times Square

"The commenter mentioned Bagizza for its inexpensive $6 thin crust pizzas, which are approximately 10 inches in size."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Super Thin Style Pizza

"Described Bagizza as a place that offers thin crust pizza with a chewy texture, though not made from actual bagels."

Positive
Apr 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Finding The Best Slop Bowls In Nyc

"This user suggested Bagizza as a 'slop box' option, also mentioning the availability of a cheap bagel pizza."

Positive
Nov 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: Did Urbanspace On W52nd Close

"This commenter mentioned Bagizza as a place that offers a good thin-crust margarita pizza for $5 cash. They brought this up in the context of discussing the decline of food halls."

Positive
Aug 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nycany Good Meals Under 10

"A bagel with a lot of cream cheese is mentioned as a meal option under $10."

Positive
Aug 2, 2025View Comment →