TLDR
A 24-hour Midtown hub for gourmet lunch buffets and affordable, personal thin-crust pizzas available at any time.
Instagram Posts References
Bagizza is a 24-hour spot in Manhattan offering a gourmet buffet during lunch and personal pizzas and bagel creations at all other times. The buffet features a wide selection of hot food, including turkey lasagna, shrimp gumbo, soy-glazed salmon, cauliflower coconut curry, chimichurri steak, short ribs, pork belly, mushroom pasta, and tuna poke, alongside various sides and vegetables. They are particularly known for their pizza and bagel options, with pizzas available in classic, vodka pesto, Nonna's meatball parm, and spicy vodka pepperoni varieties, and bagels loaded with various fillings. The reviewer highlights the restaurant-quality food at deli prices and the convenience of having pizza and bagels available 24/7.
Will Hartman reviews Bagizza, a Midtown spot that combines bagel dough and pizza toppings, finding the concept to be a textural and flavor mistake.
Details
This 24-hour Manhattan destination offers a versatile mix of a gourmet lunch buffet and personal pizzas or loaded bagel creations available at any time [1]. While some appreciate the convenience and variety—ranging from short ribs to soy-glazed salmon—the concept of their signature fusion items has faced criticism regarding dough texture and flavor balance [1]. Nevertheless, the spot remains a popular, budget-friendly choice for quick bites in Midtown [2], [3].
Food Overview
The menu spans a massive gourmet lunch buffet with hot items like chimichurri steak, pork belly, and mushroom pasta, alongside personal-sized thin-crust pizzas and loaded bagel creations [1]. Many customers favor the affordable $5–$6 thin-crust pizzas [2], [3], [4], though professional reviewers have noted that the signature fusion dough can suffer from uneven texture and clashing flavors [1].
Caveats
The signature fusion concept may not appeal to all, as some critiques mention that the dough can be raw in the center and the flavor combinations, such as sweet tomato sauce on sweet bagel dough, can be unappealing [1]. Some budget-friendly pricing options may be exclusive to cash payments [2], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BAGIZZA BAGELS & PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Decently Priced Lunch Options Around Rockefeller
"Affordable pizza option if paying with cash."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap But Healthy Eats Near Times Square
"The commenter mentioned Bagizza for its inexpensive $6 thin crust pizzas, which are approximately 10 inches in size."
PositiveFrom post: Super Thin Style Pizza
"Described Bagizza as a place that offers thin crust pizza with a chewy texture, though not made from actual bagels."
PositiveFrom post: Finding The Best Slop Bowls In Nyc
"This user suggested Bagizza as a 'slop box' option, also mentioning the availability of a cheap bagel pizza."
Positive