Next.js logo

LITTLE ITALY PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (201) 686-0976

Address: 167 WEST 48 STREET 10036

TLDR

Thick crust pizza w/ stretchy cheese. A go-to slice near the 9/11 Memorial.

Reddit Sentiment for LITTLE ITALY PIZZA(based on 5 Reddit opinions)

60% Positive40% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 6american 3italian-american 2pizza 8View All

Neighborhoods

Theater District

Details

A classic New York slice joint, this spot offers a thick crust pizza with wonderfully stretchy cheese, a true delight for pizza aficionados. While some may find it a typical establishment, it's a go-to for many locals, especially those seeking a satisfying slice near the 9/11 Memorial. Their offerings include standard condiments and even ranch dressing, catering to a variety of preferences.

Food Overview

The pizza here is characterized by its thick crust and notably stretchy cheese, a highly recommended combination. While some might categorize it as a typical New York slice, it's praised for its quality and appeal to locals. They also offer a range of condiments, including ranch dressing.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Sicilian slice is particularly recommended for its thick and stretchy cheese."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally find the pizza to be good, with a notable mention of its thick crust and stretchy cheese. It's seen as a reliable, typical New York pizza spot that locals frequent.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE ITALY PIZZA

This user recommends Little Italy for a thick crust NYC slice, highlighting the dough as light and airy.
A recommendation for the Sicilian slice, specifically mentioning its thick and stretchy cheese.
This comment suggests the restaurant as a typical New York pizza spot frequented by locals, located near the 9/11 Memorial.
One user notes that places like Little Italy Pizza might be considered a 'yellow flag' due to displaying many pies with chicken toppings, suggesting they cater to a specific clientele, though not necessarily implying bad pizza. Another comment adds that they offer ranch dressing and have typical pizza quality for such an establishment.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc

"The commenter suggested Little Italy for a thick crust NYC slice, describing the dough as light and airy."

Positive
Apr 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Recommendations Please

"This is a recommendation for a pizza place located near the 9/11 Memorial. It's described as a typical New York pizza spot that many locals frequent."

Positive
Aug 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias

"Little Italy Pizza is generally considered good, despite being a type of place that might typically raise yellow flags like having many pies displayed."

Positive
Jun 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias

"Little Italy Pizza, with multiple locations in Manhattan, provides ranch dressing alongside other condiments, and its pizza quality is described as typical for such a place, implying average."

Neutral
Jun 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Yellow And Red Flags For Pizzerias

"The user describes pizzerias in midtown like Little Italy Pizza as a yellow flag due to displaying many pies with chicken toppings in the front window, suggesting they cater to a different crowd, though not necessarily implying bad pizza."

Neutral
Jun 24, 2025View Comment →