TLDR
Authentic Hokkaido-style ramen with an exceptionally cozy, no-frills vibe. Famed for their soul-healing spicy miso broth and perfectly crispy karaage.
Details
Highly regarded for its authentic, laid-back atmosphere, this establishment has become a neighborhood staple for those seeking exceptional Japanese ramen [22]. Known for its Hokkaido-style preparations, the menu features standout dishes like spicy miso ramen and crispy karaage [8], [27]. Despite past discussions regarding commercial rent pressures and even a historical health rating, the restaurant remains a top-tier favorite among many Manhattan diners [22], [23], [44], [53].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in Sapporo-style ramen, utilizing noodles sourced directly from Hokkaido [10], [22]. Menu highlights include their signature spicy miso ramen and a variety of tantanmen options, along with excellent vegetarian-friendly miso choices [8], [17], [36], [47]. The karaage is widely praised as an essential side, frequently described as some of the best fried chicken available in the city [27], [39], [40].
Highlights / Recommended
"The spicy miso ramen is frequently cited as a comfort food staple [8], [9]. Additionally, the karaage and vegetarian miso ramen come highly recommended by regulars [27], [36], [40]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •cold ramen(3)
- •karaage(3)
- •ramen(3)
- •curry ramen(3)
- •tan tan men(2)
- •fried chicken(2)
- •tantanmen(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons overwhelmingly consider this a top-tier ramen spot, frequently citing it as their favorite in the city for its genuine, unpretentious atmosphere [22], [25]. While some have noted historical health inspection ratings, the overwhelming consensus highlights the restaurant as a beloved and highly recommended culinary gem [22], [53].
Caveats
Some visitors may find the shop to be quite busy, though many report that dining early or on rainy days helps avoid a wait [3], [4]. A small number of patrons have previously reported negative experiences with food safety, and there have been past discussions regarding its health inspection ratings [41], [42], [53].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MENKOI SAO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Do Not Feed Alligators Has A Cnever Seen A C
"This user considers it their personal favorite restaurant in the city despite its past health rating."
PositiveFrom post: Do Not Feed Alligators Has A Cnever Seen A C
"The user mentioned that this restaurant used to have a C rating."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurant Recommendations For Adventurous 10yo
"Recommended for noodles."
PositiveFrom post: Need Recommendations For Vegetarian Dry Noodles
"The restaurant is listed as a recommendation for noodles."
PositiveFrom post: West Village Takeout For Someone Who Usually Just
"Mentions them as a potential option for ramen."
Neutral