Next.js logo

EDWARD'S

Updated

Phone: (212) 233-6436

Address: 136 WEST BROADWAY 10013

TLDR

A Tribeca sleeper spot serving classic American fare and occasional regional specialties like Cincinnati-style chili.

Reddit Sentiment for EDWARD'S(based on 17 Reddit opinions)

18% Positive41% Neutral41% Negative

Tags

regional american 15american 3chili 15hot dog 2View All

Neighborhoods

Tribeca

Details

Known for its unique regional offerings, this establishment has gained a reputation for hosting special events like Cincinnati Night, where they serve classic dishes like Skyline chili [1]. While some patrons appreciate the flavors as a nostalgic treat, others find the pricing high for what is traditionally considered inexpensive comfort food [2]. The kitchen relies on canned ingredients for their regional specialties to maintain consistency [3], leading to a range of opinions on quality and authenticity.

Food Overview

The menu features American standards, including a well-regarded BLT with generous bacon [4]. During specific events, the restaurant serves Cincinnati-style chili, though feedback varies significantly; some diners find the dish delicious and fun, while others dislike the texture of the cheese topping or find the execution lacking compared to traditional roots [1], [5], [6].

Highlights / Recommended

The BLT is a standout favorite among visitors [4]. For those attending Cincinnati Night, the cheese coney is a popular choice [1].

Customer Sentiment

Diners are split on their experiences; while some enjoy the novelty and taste of specialty events, others express frustration over pricing and inconsistencies in dish preparation compared to their expectations [1], [2].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    skyline chili
    4 mentions
  • 02
    burger
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About EDWARD'S

A deep dive into the restaurant's Cincinnati Night, covering everything from the taste of the Skyline chili to the debate over the price and authenticity of the cheese used.
This thread highlights the restaurant as a specific spot in Tribeca that attempts to serve regional favorites like Skyline Chili.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Expats And Transplants Of Nyc What Is Your

"An establishment in Tribeca that served Skyline Chili, though opinions on the authenticity of the preparation vary."

Neutral
Aug 26, 2026View Comment →

From post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For

"Mentioned Edward's as being across the street from The Odeon."

Neutral
May 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First

"A brief negative opinion on the food."

Negative
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First

"This commenter visited Edward's and was disappointed with the taste, stating they will not return."

Negative
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First

"The commenter finds the cheese topping unacceptable because it is not shredded finely enough, stating that the thick pieces are unappetizing."

Negative
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

More in Tribeca

See all