TLDR
A Tribeca spot serving a standout BLT w/ generous bacon [1]. Also known for its controversial Cincinnati Night chili - some love it, some don't [2], [3].
Details
Edward's in Tribeca is a restaurant that has garnered attention for its unique menu items. One standout recommendation is their BLT, noted for its generous bacon portion [1]. The restaurant also features special 'Cincinnati Nights' where they serve Skyline chili, a dish that has sparked varied opinions among diners. While some find it delicious with fun flavors and a good balance, others suggest approaching it as a new type of food rather than conventional chili [2], [3]. The use of canned Skyline chili in their preparation has also been noted [4].
Food Overview
Edward's offers a diverse menu, with its BLT being a highly recommended item for its abundant bacon [1]. The restaurant also hosts 'Cincinnati Nights,' featuring Skyline chili, which has been met with mixed reviews. Some patrons found the chili delicious and well-balanced, while others critiqued its unconventional taste and presentation, with some even suggesting it's better to view it as a novel dish rather than traditional chili [2], [3], [6], [7], [8]. The use of canned Skyline chili has been confirmed [4], [9], and opinions vary on the cheese topping and overall value [5], [10].
Caveats
The Cincinnati chili served at Edward's uses canned Skyline chili, which may affect authenticity for some patrons. Opinions are divided on its taste and presentation, and some found the pricing, particularly for the cheese topping, to be excessive [4], [5], [9], [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EDWARD'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Mentioned Edward's as being across the street from The Odeon."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"A brief negative opinion on the food."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter visited Edward's and was disappointed with the taste, stating they will not return."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter finds the cheese topping unacceptable because it is not shredded finely enough, stating that the thick pieces are unappetizing."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter inquired if Edward's offers the small oyster crackers often served with Skyline chili hot sauce, and was pleased to learn they do."
PositiveFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter dislikes the appearance of the food, calling it 'gross'."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter argues that Cincinnati chili, which they describe as a sauce with Greek/Mediterranean spices, is a bad dish and not charming despite being a local tradition. They feel it's unappealing and would not be improved by adding cheese."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter describes Cincinnati chili as similar to a 'spaghetti with some weird bolognese' and, despite initial thoughts of it sounding revolting, has enjoyed it twice."
PositiveFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter enjoyed the Cincinnati Night at Edward's, finding the Skyline chili delicious with fun flavors and a good balance, and appreciated that it wasn't overly sweet. They would return for another Cincinnati Night, preferring coneys over the plated four-way."
PositiveFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter suggests approaching Cincinnati chili as an entirely new type of food rather than conventional chili to improve the perception, noting that even with this approach, it might not appeal to everyone."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"Having family in Cincinnati, the commenter found the price of the chili at Edward's to be the worst aspect, as Cincinnati chili is traditionally considered cheap food."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This comment confirms that Edward's uses canned Skyline chili, referencing a New Yorker article from 2009 as evidence."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter discovered that Wegmans at Astor Place sells cans of Skyline chili, expressing surprise at the availability."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter notes that Edward's uses canned Skyline chili, a fact confirmed by Edward himself years ago, suggesting it's a practical choice as replicating the unique taste is difficult for his cooks."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter expresses shock at the price, finding $19 for the amount of cheese served to be excessive."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter, who grew up with Cincinnati chili, felt that while Edward's version scratched the itch, they preferred the processed cheese and potentially different hot dog from back home, suggesting actual Skyline or Gold Star in the Ohio/Kentucky area for the authentic experience."
NeutralFrom post: Best Blts In The City
"Edward’s in Tribeca was recommended as a 'sleeper' spot for its BLT, specifically noting the generous amount of bacon."
Positive