TLDR
A Tribeca sleeper spot serving classic American fare and occasional regional specialties like Cincinnati-style chili.
Details
Known for its unique regional offerings, this establishment has gained a reputation for hosting special events like Cincinnati Night, where they serve classic dishes like Skyline chili [1]. While some patrons appreciate the flavors as a nostalgic treat, others find the pricing high for what is traditionally considered inexpensive comfort food [2]. The kitchen relies on canned ingredients for their regional specialties to maintain consistency [3], leading to a range of opinions on quality and authenticity.
Food Overview
The menu features American standards, including a well-regarded BLT with generous bacon [4]. During specific events, the restaurant serves Cincinnati-style chili, though feedback varies significantly; some diners find the dish delicious and fun, while others dislike the texture of the cheese topping or find the execution lacking compared to traditional roots [1], [5], [6].
The BLT is a standout favorite among visitors [4]. For those attending Cincinnati Night, the cheese coney is a popular choice [1].
Diners are split on their experiences; while some enjoy the novelty and taste of specialty events, others express frustration over pricing and inconsistencies in dish preparation compared to their expectations [1], [2].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01skyline chili4 mentions
- 02burger2 mentions
Caveats
Dishes like the regional chili are considered pricey by many guests who expect such items to be inexpensive [2]. Additionally, some diners find the cheese topping on specific dishes to be too thick or unappealing [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EDWARD'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Expats And Transplants Of Nyc What Is Your
"An establishment in Tribeca that served Skyline Chili, though opinions on the authenticity of the preparation vary."
NeutralFrom post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Mentioned Edward's as being across the street from The Odeon."
NeutralFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"A brief negative opinion on the food."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"This commenter visited Edward's and was disappointed with the taste, stating they will not return."
NegativeFrom post: Cincinnati Night At Edwards In Tribeca My First
"The commenter finds the cheese topping unacceptable because it is not shredded finely enough, stating that the thick pieces are unappetizing."
Negative