TLDR
Upscale steakhouse known for its 'NYC happy meal' & exceptional steak dishes. Great bar scene & accommodating management.
Instagram Posts References
This post highlights American Cut as a destination for evening dining in Tribeca. The image focuses on a table setting with wine glasses and crisp white napkins, conveying an elegant and inviting atmosphere.
American Cut is highlighted for its happy hour, featuring a special 'NYC Happy Meal' that includes a Caesar salad, fries, and a martini for $24.
Details
American Cut, a steakhouse in Manhattan, has garnered positive attention for its upscale dining experience and unique offerings. It's noted for its 'NYC happy meal' special, which includes a Caesar salad, fries, and a martini [1]. The restaurant also boasts a highly praised steak dish with exceptional preparations of mushrooms and brussel sprouts, even for those who typically dislike the vegetable [2]. Beyond its acclaimed food, American Cut offers a lively bar scene and is recognized for its accommodating management and ability to host gatherings [3].
Food Overview
American Cut is a steakhouse that offers a variety of well-regarded dishes. The 'NYC Happy Meal' is a popular happy hour option, featuring a Caesar salad, fries, and a martini [1]. The steak dishes are frequently highlighted, with one detailed review praising the steak, maitake mushroom, and various brussel sprout preparations as exceptional [2]. The restaurant also offers a notable tuna tartar served on a tater tot and a terrific seafood tower [3]. While known for steak, options beyond raw fish and a raw bar are limited.
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'NYC Happy Meal' is a popular happy hour choice, including a salad, fries, and a martini [1]. The steak dish is highly praised, featuring exceptional preparations of mushrooms and brussel sprouts [2]. Additionally, the tuna tartar on a tater tot and the seafood tower are recommended [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally have a positive view of American Cut, with many praising the quality of the steak and the unique 'NYC happy meal' offering. However, one diner reported getting sick twice, though still considered the restaurant generally good [1].
Caveats
One user reported getting sick twice from dining at American Cut, though they still considered the restaurant to be generally good and preferred another establishment [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About AMERICAN CUT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Stated that even if not ordering steak, American Cut has a terrific seafood tower and a solid bar scene."
PositiveFrom post: Im Staying At The Roxy In Tribeca Im Looking For
"Recommended American Cut for good steaks, noting it has a solid bar scene."
PositiveFrom post: Soon To Be First Time In Nyc As An Irish Person
"American Cut is mentioned as a highly-rated, less classic steakhouse option that the commenter likes because it's near their house."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Weekend Happy Hours
"The commenter suggests American Cut in TriBeCa, a steakhouse, for its happy hour from 5-7pm daily. They specifically praise the $14 smoked old fashioned cocktail, noting the bartenders put on a show."
PositiveFrom post: Fine Dining With Shared Couch Image Attachedvery
"While dining at American Cut in Tribeca, the commenter and their date were seated in a "cove" with a shared banquette, which allowed for an intimate experience. They even interacted with Keegan Michael Key and his wife who were at a nearby table."
PositiveFrom post: Can Someone Recommend A Seafood Restaurant Near
"American Cut is recommended as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Dirty Martini Recs
"The commenter stated that American Cut is good, but preferred the Lobby Bar at Hotel Chelsea, mentioning they got sick from American Cut twice."
NegativeFrom post: Seeking Dirty Martini Recs
"This commenter expressed love for everything at American Cut, building on a previous comment about the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Dirty Martini Recs
"The commenter believes American Cut makes a great dirty martini, prepared to the customer's preference. They also noted a good past happy hour."
PositiveFrom post: 5 Nights In New York Lots Of Tasty Adventures
"A commenter thanked the original poster for the detailed description of the steak dish at American Cut, expressing how amazing it sounded."
PositiveFrom post: 5 Nights In New York Lots Of Tasty Adventures
"The author detailed the steak dish from American Cut, which included grilled maitake mushroom, creamed brussel sprouts, brussel sprout purée, mushroom & balsamic reduction, grated horseradish, and horseradish cream sauce. They noted that this dish was exceptional, even for someone who dislikes brussel sprouts."
PositiveFrom post: 5 Nights In New York Lots Of Tasty Adventures
"A commenter inquired about the components of the steak dish at American Cut."
NeutralFrom post: 5 Nights In New York Lots Of Tasty Adventures
"The author tried the NYC happy meal from American Cut, rating it 7/10."
NeutralFrom post: Budget Hacks
"American Cut in Tribeca provides an "adult happy meal" special including fries, salad, and wine or a martini."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Restaurant For Birthday Celebration
"The user had a positive experience at American Cut in Tribeca and notes it is not frequently mentioned in recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Very Specific Restaurant
"American Cut was mentioned as having tuna tartar on a tater tot and several great potato sides, but limited raw fish options beyond that and a raw bar."
NeutralFrom post: Venue Recs For 2030 Person Gathering Good Drinks
"This user suggested American Cut in Tribeca as a venue for a gathering, noting they have a large connected dining room that could work for the described needs."
PositiveFrom post: Best Caesar Fries In Soho
"This user suggested American Cut in Tribeca, noting they have an NYC happy meal special which includes a martini."
NeutralFrom post: Best Dry Aged Ribeye In City
"American Cut was listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Girl Dinner With A Dirty Martini
"This place is recommended for the specific 'girl dinner' vibe, especially since it's located in the West Village, aligning with the original request."
Positive