Next.js logo

GOTHAM PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 989-8858

Address: 144 9 AVENUE 10011

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Straight fire Grandma pie & fluffy Sicilian slices. Unique pizza creations, with some creative sides.

Reddit Sentiment for GOTHAM PIZZA(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

75% Positive25% Neutral

Neighborhoods

Chelsea

Details

Gotham Pizza is a go-to spot for those seeking exceptional pizza, particularly noted for its unique Grandma pie, which has been described as 'straight fire.' The establishment also offers a fluffy, non-crispy Sicilian pizza, perfect for those who prefer a softer crust. While the pizza receives high marks, some reviews humorously suggest their 'chopped cheese' tots are best enjoyed under the influence.

Food Overview

Gotham Pizza is celebrated for its pizza offerings, with the Grandma pie receiving enthusiastic "straight fire" reviews. A fluffy, non-crispy Sicilian pizza is also a standout for those who don't prefer a crispy crust. For a more unconventional bite, their 'chopped cheese' tots are mentioned, though humorously suggested for late-night cravings.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Grandma pie is highly recommended and described as 'straight fire.' Customers also appreciate their fluffy, non-crispy Sicilian pizza."

Customer Sentiment

Customers rave about the pizza, with specific praise for the Grandma pie and a uniquely fluffy Sicilian. While the pizza is a clear hit, some adventurous items like the 'chopped cheese' tots are noted as an acquired taste.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About GOTHAM PIZZA

I asked this sub for the best pizza rec and got Gotham Pizza!
A user enthusiastically shared a recommendation for Gotham Pizza's Grandma pie, calling it 'straight fire,' indicating a strong positive reception for this particular dish.
Where can I find this type of pizza?
This post highlights Gotham Pizza for its non-traditional Sicilian pizza, described as super fluffy and not crispy when ordered fresh, catering to a specific preference for pizza crust.
Where in Lower Manhattan is the stretchy cheese?
Gotham Pizza is listed as one of the places that offers good cheese on their pizza, specifically mentioning it as a place with good cheese.
Anywhere to get Korean-style Angry Fries like this?
Gotham Pizza is mentioned for offering 'chopped cheese' tots, with a humorous note that they are best enjoyed under the influence.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where Can I Find This Type Of Pizza

"Commenter suggested Gotham Pizza for a non-traditional Sicilian pizza that is super fluffy and not crispy when ordered as a fresh pie, fitting the description."

Positive
Mar 25, 2026View Comment →

From post: I Asked This Sub For The Best Pizza Rec And Got

"The user praised Gotham Pizza's Grandma pie as 'straight fire'."

Positive
Nov 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anywhere To Get Koreanstyle Angry Fries Like This

"Gotham is mentioned as a place that offers 'chopped cheese' tots, described as only good when intoxicated."

Neutral
Aug 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where In Lower Manhattan Is The Stretchy Cheese

"Includes Gotham Pizza in a list of pizza places with good cheese."

Positive
Apr 18, 2025View Comment →