TLDR
Premier oyster destination in Chelsea Market known for an extensive selection and excellent happy hour deals. A reliable, sit-down seafood experience with traditional restaurant hours.
Reddit Sentiment for CULL & PISTOL (LOBSTER PLACE)(based on 17 Reddit opinions)
Details
Located within Chelsea Market, this seafood destination is highly regarded as one of the premier spots in the city for oysters [1]. It serves as a reliable sit-down dining option that offers consistent service and standard restaurant hours [2]. Guests frequent the venue for high-quality meals, often pairing their selections with the popular happy hour offerings [3].
Caveats
The restaurant is entirely seafood-focused, which may not be suitable for diners with specific dietary restrictions [6]. Additionally, the interior space is relatively small [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CULL & PISTOL (LOBSTER PLACE)
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Any Suggestions For A Manhattan Seafood Lunch
"Recommended for a less casual experience than The Lobster Place."
PositiveFrom post: Any Suggestions For A Manhattan Seafood Lunch
"Notes they have daily specials and an incredible octopus dish, though warn it can get pricey."
PositiveFrom post: I Was The One Who Asked You For Chelsea Market
"There is an oyster place in Chelsea Market that is described as lovely."
PositiveFrom post: Im Going To Chelsea Market This Week Can I Ask
"The commenter questioned why seafood restaurants like Cull & Pistol were recommended, given the OP's restriction."
NegativeFrom post: Im Going To Chelsea Market This Week Can I Ask
"This commenter pointed out that Cull & Pistol serves seafood, which is not suitable for the original poster."
NegativeFrom post: Im Going To Chelsea Market This Week Can I Ask
"This commenter enjoyed the Swordfish Sandwich and oysters at Cull & Pistol as a pre-show meal."
PositiveFrom post: Im Going To Chelsea Market This Week Can I Ask
"This commenter recommended the seasonal oyster platter, noting it's half off during happy hour, but this was before realizing the OP does not eat seafood."
NegativeFrom post: Im Going To Chelsea Market This Week Can I Ask
"In response to a recommendation, this commenter mentioned Cull & Pistol as a seafood restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: What A Good Oyster Restaurant For Graduation
"Cull and Pistol in Chelsea Market is considered one of the two best places in the city for oysters."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user recommended Cull & Pistol as excellent and suggested sitting at the bar."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user suggested The Lobster Place in Chelsea Market, which houses Cull & Pistol."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user suggested Cull & Pistol as a potential replacement for Aquagrill."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user seconded the recommendation for Cull & Pistol, noting their great weekday happy hour with 50% off all oysters and a selection of over 10 varieties, mostly East Coast."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user recommended Cull & Pistol, stating that meals there are always top-tier and mentioning it can be a bit small inside."
PositiveFrom post: Widest Oyster Selection Aquagrill Replacement
"This user listed Cull & Pistol as a place with a significant oyster selection."
PositiveFrom post: Food Halls
"Cull & Pistol by The Lobster Place is a great sit-down option within Chelsea Market that is open later, like normal restaurant hours."
PositiveFrom post: Our Last Trip In Food Pics
"The user had oysters at Cull and Pistol as part of their dining experiences."
Positive