Next.js logo

D'AMICO COFFEE

Updated

Phone: (718) 875-5403

Address: 309 COURT STREET 11231

View on Google Maps

TLDR

In-house roasted beans, vast selection. Many Brooklyn coffee shops use their beans. Traditional vibe.

Reddit Sentiment for D'AMICO COFFEE(based on 5 Reddit opinions)

100% Positive

Neighborhoods

Carroll Gardens

Details

This Brooklyn coffee institution is renowned for its in-house roasting of a vast selection of coffee beans, a practice that has earned it significant praise. Many other esteemed coffee shops in the borough are noted to source their beans from this establishment. The atmosphere is described as having a traditional, older Italian customer base, contributing to its authentic charm.

Food Overview

The primary focus is on high-quality coffee beans, which are roasted on-premises, offering an extensive variety. This dedication to the craft has led to recognition, with many other local coffee shops utilizing their beans. The ambiance is noted as having a traditional feel, often frequented by an older Italian clientele.

Highlights / Recommended

"The primary recommendation is for their coffee beans, especially given their on-site roasting and extensive selection."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality and selection of coffee beans, with many highlighting the on-site roasting. There's a general sentiment that this establishment is a highly regarded, albeit perhaps under-recognized, gem in the Brooklyn coffee scene.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About D'AMICO COFFEE

Bring home coffee beans-best coffee roaster in the city?
This post highly recommends D'Amico for its extensive selection of coffee beans and on-site roasting. It also notes that many other excellent Brooklyn coffee spots source their beans from here, indicating its high quality and reputation within the coffee community.
best store for whole coffee beans in NYC?
A user specifically recommends D'Amico in Carroll Gardens, emphasizing their on-premises roasting and the wide variety of beans available. This comment highlights the core strengths of the establishment.
Bring home coffee beans-best coffee roaster in the city?
This discussion highlights D'Amico as an amazing establishment whose beans are used by many reputable coffee spots in Brooklyn. It expresses a sentiment that the roaster deserves more recognition.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Bring Home Coffee Beansbest Coffee Roaster In The

"D'Amico is praised as wonderful, with the user noting that many good spots in Brooklyn use their beans."

Positive
Nov 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Bring Home Coffee Beansbest Coffee Roaster In The

"The user expresses frustration that D'Amico isn't receiving more recognition compared to other Brooklyn coffee spots."

Positive
Nov 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Bring Home Coffee Beansbest Coffee Roaster In The

"D'Amico is stated to be amazing, and the user notes that many good Brooklyn coffee spots use their beans."

Positive
Nov 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Bring Home Coffee Beansbest Coffee Roaster In The

"D'Amico coffee in Cobble Hill/Carroll Gardens is recommended for its extensive selection of beans and on-site roasting, suggesting it might be better than other mentioned roasters. It's noted as a place with older Italian customers."

Positive
Nov 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Store For Whole Coffee Beans In Nyc

"Author recommends D’Amico in Carroll Gardens, highlighting that they roast their own beans on premises and have a large selection."

Positive
Apr 17, 2025View Comment →

More in Carroll Gardens

See all