TLDR
Nostalgic 1920s pharmacy turned soda fountain. Famous for massive sundaes, classic egg creams, and top-tier milkshakes.
Reddit Sentiment for BROOKLYN FARMACY & SODA FOUNTAIN(based on 22 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain, originally known as Longo's Pharmacy, has been serving its neighborhood since the early 1900s before its transformation. This establishment was famously saved from demolition through a restoration featured on the Discovery Channel, allowing it to reopen as a cherished old-school soda fountain. It is particularly renowned for its handmade egg creams, floats, and sundaes, offering visitors a unique and nostalgic experience of classic Brooklyn soda fountain culture.
Will Hartman reviews Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain, a Carroll Gardens soda fountain famous for its over-the-top ice cream sundaes and egg creams, served in a unique, old-timey apothecary setting.
Details
Step back in time at this meticulously restored 1920s apothecary, which offers a nostalgic atmosphere and authentic soda fountain experience [1], [2]. Visitors flock to the shop for its indulgent, generously portioned sundaes and classic treats like handmade egg creams [1], [3]. It serves as a beloved neighborhood hub that has been famously preserved for future generations to enjoy [3].
Food Overview
The menu specializes in classic American soda fountain fare, featuring velvety ice cream from Adirondack Creamery and housemade caramel [1]. Standout items include their "embarrassingly large" ice cream sundaes and rich milkshakes, alongside unique offerings like the espresso-soaked Affugazi and frozen hot chocolate [1], [3], [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended treats include the classic Black & White milkshake, the Affugazi sundae, and the signature handmade egg creams [1], [3], [4]."
Customer Sentiment
Patrons overwhelmingly praise the establishment as a premier destination for frozen treats, frequently citing the milkshakes and sundaes as the best in the city [3], [4]. While the experience is largely celebrated for its vintage charm, it is primarily viewed as a dedicated dessert-focused destination [3], [5].
Caveats
As a dedicated soda fountain, the menu is strictly focused on desserts and ice cream-based items, which may not suit those seeking a savory meal [3], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN FARMACY & SODA FOUNTAIN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: On The Hunt For Warm And Gooey Desserts With Ice
"They offer a variety of warm desserts like peanut butter brownie sundaes and customizable ice cream options."
PositiveFrom post: Places To Take Kids That Are Young But Cultured
"Suggested as a place for ice cream and sodas."
NeutralFrom post: Anyone Know Where I Can Get An Affogato Like This
"Praised as the best ice cream and sundae place in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Where I Can Get An Affogato Like This
"Recommended their Affugazi, which is an espresso-soaked cake and ice cream sundae."
PositiveFrom post: Food Ideas For My 6 Yr Old Me Mostly In Manhattan
"Suggested as a place to visit if heading to Brooklyn."
Neutral