Next.js logo

LEGACY RECORDS LOCATED INSIDE HENRY HALL

Last Updated: 9 days ago

Phone: (602) 568-5403

Address: 517 WEST 38 STREET 10018

TLDR

Italian fare with a sterile vibe, mixed reviews on service and reservations.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 18 Reddit comments)

17% Positive44% Neutral39% Negative

Neighborhoods

Hell's Kitchen

Details

Legacy Records offers an Italian dining experience within Henry Hall, noted for its good food, though some find the prices steep. While recommended by some for work dinners, others have experienced a sterile atmosphere and encountered difficulties with reservations or contacting the establishment. The service has been described as green by some, adding to a mixed customer perception.

Food Overview

The Italian cuisine at Legacy Records receives some positive remarks, with one user recommending it for a work dinner. However, other feedback suggests the prices can be high, and some patrons have found the overall vibe to be a bit sterile or even hostile, impacting the dining experience.

Customer Sentiment

Customers have mixed feelings about Legacy Records. While some praise the food and find it a great spot for work dinners, others describe a sterile atmosphere, inconsistent service, and difficulties with reservations or contacting the restaurant.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This restaurant was suggested as a good dinner option for a work dinner in the Hudson Yards area.
One user strongly recommends Legacy Records, indicating a positive experience with its upscale yet fun and vibey atmosphere.
While the food was considered good, the prices were noted as being quite high. The atmosphere was described as sterile, like a nice airport lounge, and there were discussions about the restaurant's gratuity policy and its impact on server earnings.
There are multiple comments indicating difficulty in contacting the restaurant for reservations, with one user questioning if the restaurant is still open due to this issue and a generally mediocre experience.
A commenter mentioned that the restaurant was struggling and had issues with servers not making comparable money to similar restaurants.
One review mentioned a weird vibe and a slightly hostile maître d' and bartender, although the waiter was described as sweet but inexperienced.

Recent Mentions

From post: Trying To Book A Room At Legacy Records

"This commenter felt the restaurant might not be actively seeking customers due to the difficulty in contacting them. They also noted that their experience there was mediocre and they rarely see much business, questioning if the restaurant is still open."

Negative
Aug 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Trying To Book A Room At Legacy Records

"One commenter suggested that if booking a private room is this difficult, it might be better to choose a different venue."

Negative
Aug 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Trying To Book A Room At Legacy Records

"This commenter provided the restaurant's address within Henry Hall and suggested potentially contacting the building or its wine store. They also expressed surprise that Legacy Records is still open."

Negative
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Trying To Book A Room At Legacy Records

"The original poster mentioned trying to contact the restaurant's parent company and other associated restaurants without success, but planned to try the other mentioned restaurants."

Neutral
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Trying To Book A Room At Legacy Records

"The original poster expressed difficulty in contacting the restaurant and mentioned that attempts through Instagram were unsuccessful."

Neutral
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Duck In The City

"Legacy Records is recommended with a thumbs up emoji."

Positive
Jun 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Upscale But Still Fun Vibey Restaurant In Midtown

"A user strongly recommends Legacy Records."

Positive
Jun 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Work Dinner Near Hudson Yards

"This restaurant was suggested as a dinner option for a work dinner near Hudson Yards."

Neutral
Jun 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: High End Lunch Spot In Hudson Yards

"It was noted that Legacy Records opens at 11:30 am."

Neutral
Apr 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: High End Lunch Spot In Hudson Yards

"Legacy Records opens at 11:30am."

Neutral
Apr 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"There was indeed a weird vibe…slightly hostile maitre d’ and bar tender."

Negative
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"The waiter was sweet but seemed very green."

Neutral
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"They were taking away the gratuity included policy the week I trailed because the servers weren't making money that was comparable with similar restaurants."

Negative
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"They had a weird vibe and I didn't take the job, very glad I stayed where I was. Legacy Records has struggled for years."

Negative
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"The prices currently on their website are not indicative of a "hospitality included" policy."

Neutral
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"A great deal to try it is available through inKind."

Positive
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"The food was really good, but the prices were a bit insane."

Neutral
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tipping Policy At Legacy Records

"It felt a little sterile, like a nice airport lounge."

Negative
Mar 2, 2025View Comment →