Late-night cookie cravings met, but quality varies. Recent health concerns cast a shadow.
This establishment specializes in cookies, offering a variety of flavors. While some customers find nostalgia in their classic chocolate chip cookies, particularly when warm, others have noted a decline in quality over time. There are significant concerns regarding recent health inspection reports.
Primarily known for cookies, with the chocolate chip cookie being a common mention. Some customers find them enjoyable, especially when fresh and warm, citing a sense of nostalgia. However, others feel the quality has diminished and compare them unfavorably to other establishments. A major concern is a recent 'C' health grade, with specific violations noted including pest control issues.
"The chocolate chip cookie is frequently mentioned, with some recommending it when fresh and warm. However, other feedback suggests a decline in quality."
Customer feedback is mixed, with some nostalgic affection for the classic cookies, while others report a decline in quality. Significant concerns have been raised regarding recent health inspection results.
Important Note
The restaurant received a 'C' grade on its last inspection over a year ago, with significant violations noted including pest control issues and evidence of mice. Some locations have 'A' grades, suggesting this specific location has management issues. There are also concerns about the building itself being known for rodent infestation.
"Insomnia Cookies is recommended, with a touch of humorous confession."
Positive"A negative comment implying the cookies are of poor quality."
Negative"Provides a direct link to the 311 portal for filing complaints about restaurant violations."
Neutral"Confirms that the discussed Insomnia Cookies location is indeed on 79th street."
Neutral"The commenter, a former employee, advises against supporting Insomnia Cookies, stating that the owner was unpleasant."
Negative"A dismissive comment implying a minor mistake was made."
Neutral"The commenter asks if the discussion is about the Insomnia Cookies location on 79th street."
Neutral"The commenter provides the health department's findings for this specific Insomnia Cookies location, noting that other Manhattan locations have 'A' grades, suggesting poor management at this particular store."
Negative"Expresses surprise that a cookie-making establishment could receive a 'C' grade."
Negative"Compares the restaurant's action to hiding mess under a bed, suggesting a lack of transparency."
Neutral"The commenter criticizes the tendency for people to claim they aren't 'snitches' while then proceeding to report others, calling the behavior 'whack'."
Neutral"Suggests the restaurant needs to rest and clean their cookie business."
Negative"The commenter, who has food service experience, states that it takes significant failure to receive anything below an 'A' grade, implying a 'C' is a severe issue."
Negative"The commenter believes that attempting to hide an inspection grade is a clear violation and that the restaurant should face further penalties."
Negative"The commenter suggests that people's tolerance for restaurant cleanliness varies, and they only avoid 'Grade Pending' signs unless it's a very good small business."
Neutral"A playful comment relating the grade 'C' to cookies."
Neutral"The commenter expresses regret for frequently ordering from Insomnia Cookies in the past, given the negative information about their hygiene."
Negative"The commenter states that Insomnia Cookies are disgusting and personally found hair strands in an order from their East Village location, urging others to avoid them."
Negative"The commenter criticizes the restaurant's attempt to hide its grade as not clever and suggests a more creative way they could have disguised it."
Negative"The commenter uses an app called 'Grade Pending' to check restaurant ratings and now checks all restaurants before making reservations, though they still grab quick items."
Neutral
