TLDR
Philly-style cheesesteak joint with authentic flavors and creative twists, though some find it bland. Also discussions on Portuguese steak sandwiches.
Reddit Sentiment for OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW(based on 25 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew is lauded as the top spot for cheesesteaks in New York City, with the owner, a Philadelphia native, bringing authentic Philly-style cheesesteaks to the city. The restaurant offers a diverse menu beyond the classic options. Signature items include the classic Wiz style cheesesteak, which is praised for its abundant, oozing cheese, the Pizza Cheesesteak featuring onions, red sauce, and grilled pepperoni, and the Black Cherry Cheesesteak, made with a cherry pepper spread, fried onions, and black pepper Cooper Sharp American cheese, offering a pleasant kick. Another standout is the Creamy Garlic Cheesesteak, which combines a garlic aioli, grilled tomatoes, sweet peppers, fried onions, and provolone. The restaurant also serves various side dishes like onion rings, cheesesteak egg rolls, and mozzarella sticks, along with a new burger that is also noted as a must-try.
Details
Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew aims to bring authentic Philly-style cheesesteaks to New York City, helmed by a Philadelphia native. The restaurant is lauded for its classic Wiz style cheesesteak, praised for its generous and oozing cheese. Adventurous eaters can explore unique takes such as the Pizza Cheesesteak with red sauce and pepperoni, the Black Cherry Cheesesteak with a cherry pepper spread and black pepper Cooper Sharp, and the Creamy Garlic Cheesesteak with aioli and provolone. For those seeking variety, sides like onion rings and cheesesteak egg rolls are available, and a new burger has also garnered positive attention. Despite the praise for authenticity and unique flavors, some patrons have found the cheesesteaks to be bland and inconsistently prepared, with comments on bread quality and filling. The restaurant has also been part of discussions regarding Portuguese steak sandwiches, with a wide range of feedback on their visual appeal and preparation.
Food Overview
This establishment specializes in American cuisine, with a particular focus on cheesesteaks. The classic Wiz style cheesesteak is a highlight, noted for its generous cheese. Creative options like the Pizza Cheesesteak, Black Cherry Cheesesteak, and Creamy Garlic Cheesesteak are also available, offering distinct flavor profiles. However, some reviews mention blandness and inconsistency in the cheesesteaks. The menu also includes sides like onion rings and cheesesteak egg rolls, and a new burger has been recommended. There is also a Portuguese steak sandwich that has received mixed reviews regarding its visual appeal and preparation.
The classic Wiz Style Cheesesteak is highly praised. Creative options like the Pizza Cheesesteak, Black Cherry Cheesesteak, and Creamy Garlic Cheesesteak are also recommended, along with a newly introduced burger.
Customers have mixed feelings about this restaurant. While some praise the authentic Philly-style cheesesteaks, particularly the classic Wiz style and the unique Black Cherry and Creamy Garlic variations, others have found the cheesesteaks bland and inconsistent, with issues concerning bread toasting and filling. The restaurant also offers a new burger that is recommended. There's also a significant discussion around the visual presentation of a Portuguese steak sandwich, with opinions sharply divided.
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01portuguese steak sandwich13 mentions
- 02prego (portuguese steak sandwich)7 mentions
- 03bifana (portuguese pork sandwich)2 mentions
Caveats
Some customers have reported blandness and inconsistency in the cheesesteaks, particularly when ordering delivery. There's also a notable amount of feedback regarding the visual appeal of a Portuguese steak sandwich, with differing opinions on its preparation and presentation.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Re Portuguese Steak Sandwich Post From Yesterday
"The author described Prego and Bifana sandwiches as 'delightful' and strongly suggested OP include Cachorrinhos (Portuguese hotdogs) in their future NYC shop's menu. They indicated they would travel from the tri-state area for good Cachorrinhos."
PositiveFrom post: Re Portuguese Steak Sandwich Post From Yesterday
"The author found OP's current iteration of the Portuguese steak sandwich 'much more appealing' than a previous one, expressing willingness to 'happily eat this'. This was despite them never having tried such a sandwich before, and was directed at OP's plans for an NYC shop."
PositiveFrom post: Re Portuguese Steak Sandwich Post From Yesterday
"In response to OP's proposed $28 price for their Portuguese steak sandwich, the author suggested this is 'too much for just the sandwich.' They advised that $25 with a side (like fries or salad) would be a better price point for OP's planned NYC shop."
NeutralFrom post: Re Portuguese Steak Sandwich Post From Yesterday
"The author finds the OP's pictured Portuguese steak sandwich to look 'pretty good' and advises the OP, a prospective restaurateur, to consult a culinary photographer for food presentation. They also inquired about the 'Prego' sandwich's availability in Portugal."
PositiveFrom post: Re Portuguese Steak Sandwich Post From Yesterday
"The author observed a 'big improvement' in OP's pictured Portuguese steak sandwich from a previous version, but criticized the steak's uneven cooking and lack of sear. They expressed interest in trying it if it were a garlic butter steak, as OP described for their planned NYC shop."
Neutral