TLDR
Incredible fried chicken and spicy chicken sandwiches that some call the best in the city. Standout duck fat chili oil chicken, but some find quality varies.
Details
Pecking House has garnered a reputation as a go-to spot for outstanding fried chicken, with many hailing it as the best in NYC. The duck fat chili oil chicken and the crispy spicy chicken sandwich are frequently cited as highlights. Fans describe the chicken as 'insanely good' and have even gone so far as to cancel other plans to return for another taste. The restaurant's unique Sichuan-inspired American cuisine has made a significant impact, with some patrons considering it a top-tier dining experience. While most reviews are glowing, a few customers have reported less satisfying experiences, noting dry chicken or a lack of expected flavor. The closure of their Brooklyn (Park Slope) location due to landlord issues has also been a point of sadness for many dedicated fans, though some suggest the Chinatown branch remains a strong option.
Food Overview
The restaurant is highly acclaimed for its American and Chinese-American fusion cuisine, particularly its fried chicken. Dishes like the duck fat chili oil chicken and the crispy spicy chicken sandwich receive consistent praise for their flavor and quality. However, some patrons have found the chicken to be dry or lacking in expected Sichuan flavors. There's a noted distinction in quality between locations, with the Brooklyn (Park Slope) branch generally favored over the Chinatown one. Despite some criticisms, the majority of feedback centers on the exceptional chicken, making it a standout item.
Highlights / Recommended
"The duck fat chili oil chicken and the crispy spicy chicken sandwich are highly recommended. The 'xtra hot chicken' is also noted as a standout dish."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chicken(3)
- •fried chicken(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its exceptional fried chicken, with many declaring it some of the best in the city. The duck fat chili oil chicken and the crispy spicy chicken sandwich are frequently highlighted as must-try dishes. Some users consider it a top-tier spot, even prompting return visits and canceled plans. However, there are a few dissenting opinions, with some finding the chicken dry or lacking expected flavor, and one user reported food poisoning. There's also mention of the Park Slope location closing due to landlord issues, leading to some disappointment among regulars.
Caveats
The Park Slope, Brooklyn location has closed due to landlord issues. Some customers have reported a decline in quality or found the chicken to be dry and lacking flavor.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PEKING HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Ranks Pecking House as #1."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Found the chicken at the Park Slope location nothing noteworthy."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Finds Pecking House chicken disappointing compared to other places, though they didn't try the sandwich specifically."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Explains the closure of Pecking House's Park Slope location is due to the landlord and future reopening is uncertain."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"States Pecking House is a go-to."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Was disappointed on two visits; the hot chicken sandwich was inedible due to excessive chili oil, and the non-spicy version was bland."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Was super disappointed with the original chicken sandwich from the Brooklyn location, finding it dry and less flavorful than Popeyes, noting a rumored decline in quality."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Expresses extreme disappointment over the Park Slope location closing, calling it a top favorite place in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"States Pecking House is their personal favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Clarifies the Chinatown location of Pecking House is in Manhattan."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Was disappointed with the chili chicken sando, finding it just "fine" and primarily tasting of Szechuan pepper."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Lists Pecking House as a recommendation from a previous discussion."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Implies that Pecking House's price of $15 for the sandwich is too high for the value."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Claims quality has dropped and experienced severe food poisoning after eating at Pecking House."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Expresses concern about the Park Slope location closing."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House as top-notch."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Ranks Pecking House's chicken sandwich as a top favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Clarifies the initial recommendation for the Chinatown location was due to the Park Slope closure."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"States the Park Slope location of Pecking House is closing."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Sandwich In Nyc
"Highly recommends Pecking House, specifically the Chinatown location."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author expressed strong disappointment about the Pecking House (Brooklyn) closure, highlighting that its veggie options and broth are exceptionally good."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"Considering the price point of Pecking House (Brooklyn), the author was not surprised by the news of its closure."
NeutralFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author considered Pecking House (Brooklyn) the best, especially after being disappointed by Rowdy Rooster's recent menu changes."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author stated that Pecking House's Brooklyn location was consistently great, especially when compared to a negative experience at the Chinatown branch."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author really likes the chicken at Pecking House (Brooklyn) but observed it didn't attract much business, unlike nearby competitors. They also mentioned the food might not be for everyone."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author reminisced that Pecking House (Brooklyn) was amazing during its initial pandemic delivery phase and when the physical location first opened, implying a contrast with recent quality."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"Despite hearing great reviews, the author was underwhelmed by a recent visit to Pecking House Brooklyn, finding the chicken dry and lacking the expected Sichuan flavor."
NegativeFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"Having tried Pecking House (Brooklyn) last month and loved it, the author expressed dismay at its closure."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author believes Pecking House (Brooklyn) serves the best chicken sandwich in the city and is hopeful that its closure, possibly due to building issues, might not be permanent."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author, while sad about Pecking House Brooklyn's closure, noted that its quality had significantly declined in recent months."
NegativeFrom post: What Brooklyn Restaurant Wowd You Recently
"User praised Pecking House for its stellar fried chicken, which has been great since day one, despite disliking the new logo."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author expresses a preference for Pecking House's original Brooklyn location over the Chinatown one, lamenting its impending closure."
PositiveFrom post: Pecking House Brooklyn Closing
"The author finds the chicken at Pecking House (Brooklyn) to be amazing and loves their dirty rice, planning one last order before it closes. They also speculated that the location might have been pricey to maintain."
PositiveFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Confirmed Peking House is in Prospect Heights."
NeutralFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Asked if Peking House is in Prospect Heights."
NeutralFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Agreed that Peking House is incredible."
PositiveFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Clarified the location as being on Flatbush in Prospect Heights/Park Slope border."
NeutralFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Confirmed both Peking House locations are solid, even on their worst day the chili fried chicken is "better than anything else in the universe"."
PositiveFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Said Peking House's chicken was amazing and canceled plans to go to L'Artusi to go back there and eat again."
PositiveFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Said Peking House "lives rent free" in their head."
PositiveFrom post: What I Ate On My Five Day Solo Treck Through The
"Rated Peking House a 10/10 and said the extra hot (not that hot) chicken was amazing and they stopped by twice."
PositiveFrom post: Suggestions For Dairyfree Icons
"Recommends Pecking House for fried chicken."
PositiveFrom post: Danny And Coops Cheesesteak
"The author chose Pecking House over Danny and Coop's yesterday, but later expressed some regret about possibly missing Danny and Coop's."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Recommends either the crispy spicy sandwich from Pecking House or the fried chicken sandwich from Winson."
PositiveFrom post: 50 For Two Chicken Nuggets At Coqodaq
"User mentions trying Pecking House and found the experience just "OK", while asking for alternative fried chicken recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Claims Pecking House (along with Birdbox) has some of the best chicken known to mankind."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Highlights the duck fat chili oil chicken at Pecking House as insanely good."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Agrees with the recommendation for Pecking House."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Recommends Claud (wine bar) and Pecking House."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Recommends both Pecking House and The Fly."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Simply recommends Peking House (Pecking House)."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Recommends Pecking House, though notes it's not suitable for a special occasion."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Chicken Youve Had In Nyc
"Lists Pecking House among many other chicken spots."
NeutralFrom post: Salted Egg Yolk Hot Honey Flavored Chicken
"Pecking House's fried chicken sandwich is recommended as one of the best."
PositiveFrom post: Fried Chicken Crawl
"A user mentions Pecking House has great fried chicken, noting its locations in Chinatown or Prospect Heights."
PositiveFrom post: Spice Bag Recs
"Pecking House on Flatbush is recommended as a place that serves spice bags."
PositiveFrom post: Cheap And Amazing
"Pecking House is a good restaurant in Brooklyn"
Neutral