Underrated neighborhood pizza joint, praised as a go-to for classic, no-frills slices that rival hyped spots. Simple, old-school perfection.
For an authentic taste of New York pizza, Lucia Pizza stands out as a beloved neighborhood gem. Often compared favorably to more hyped establishments, this spot is praised for its classic, no-frills approach to pizza-making. It's a place where quality ingredients and traditional techniques shine, offering a reliable and delicious option for pizza lovers.
Lucia Pizza is celebrated for its traditional New York-style pizza, with many customers recommending it as an outstanding, underrated option. It's frequently mentioned as a more authentic choice compared to some of the city's more heavily promoted pizza places.
"The classic pizza slice is frequently recommended. Additionally, Lucia Pizza in Flushing is noted for carrying Gino's Italian Ices, including a unique cannoli flavor."
Customers consistently praise Lucia Pizza for its excellent, classic New York-style pizza, often highlighting it as a superior, unhyped alternative to more famous pizzerias.
Important Note
One Reddit user noted that a Lucia Pizza location in Soho was overrated, but this appears to be a different branch than the highly recommended Queens location.
"This user recommends Lucia Pizza for a slice."
Positive"This user recommends Lucia Pizza for a pizza slice."
Positive"Lucia's in Flushing was recommended."
Neutral"The commenter states that the Sheepshead Bay location of Lucia is better than the one in SoHo and is relatively close to JFK airport."
Positive"The commenter believes Lucia's is a notable omission from the original list of pizza places to try."
Neutral"The commenter confirms that the Flushing location has been operating since 1962 and provides a link to the restaurant's website."
Neutral"The commenter clarifies that Lucia of Soho is an outpost of Lucia of X in Brooklyn, and lists the three locations on their website, suggesting the Queens location might not be affiliated."
Neutral"This Flushing location is recommended as it's conveniently located off the 7 train, especially if one is also visiting Philomena's."
Positive"The user simply confirmed Lucia Pizza in Flushing as a location where Gino's Italian Ices can still be found."
Neutral"The user recommended Lucia Pizza in Flushing as a place that still sells Gino's Italian Ices, specifically mentioning their cannoli flavor."
Positive"Lucia's in Flushing is recommended as a pizza option."
Neutral"This user gives a shout-out to Lucia Pizza in Flushing, agreeing with the recommendation."
Positive"This user recommends a separate Lucia Pizza location in Flushing."
Positive
