Old-school Queens pizza slice joint. Unhyped, classic neighborhood spot.
A classic Queens spot, this pizzeria is a hidden gem offering a taste of old-school New York. Praised for its unpretentious atmosphere and consistently good pizza, it's a go-to for locals seeking authentic flavor without the hype. From classic slices to unique Italian ices, it delivers a satisfying experience that keeps customers coming back.
This pizzeria is celebrated for its classic Italian-American pizza. Customers often recommend it as an excellent neighborhood spot, with some comparing it favorably to more famous establishments. It's also noted for offering Gino's Italian Ices, including unique flavors like cannoli.
"Customers frequently recommend the pizza slices. The cannoli flavored Italian ice from Gino's is also a notable mention."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, often praising it as a great, unhyped neighborhood spot with consistently good pizza.
Important Note
One user found a separate Lucia Pizza location in Soho to be overrated. There is also some discussion and potential confusion regarding the affiliation of different Lucia Pizza locations.
"Lucia's in Flushing was recommended."
Neutral"The commenter states that the Sheepshead Bay location of Lucia is better than the one in SoHo and is relatively close to JFK airport."
Positive"The commenter believes Lucia's is a notable omission from the original list of pizza places to try."
Neutral"The commenter confirms that the Flushing location has been operating since 1962 and provides a link to the restaurant's website."
Neutral"The commenter clarifies that Lucia of Soho is an outpost of Lucia of X in Brooklyn, and lists the three locations on their website, suggesting the Queens location might not be affiliated."
Neutral"This Flushing location is recommended as it's conveniently located off the 7 train, especially if one is also visiting Philomena's."
Positive"The user simply confirmed Lucia Pizza in Flushing as a location where Gino's Italian Ices can still be found."
Neutral"The user recommended Lucia Pizza in Flushing as a place that still sells Gino's Italian Ices, specifically mentioning their cannoli flavor."
Positive"Lucia's in Flushing is recommended as a pizza option."
Neutral"This user gives a shout-out to Lucia Pizza in Flushing, agreeing with the recommendation."
Positive"This user recommends a separate Lucia Pizza location in Flushing."
Positive"The user included Lucia Pizza in a long list of recommended classic Queens spots."
Neutral"A commenter recommended Lucia Pizza in Flushing, highlighting its central location and continued strong operation."
Positive"Recommends getting a slice of pizza at Lucia Pizza."
Positive"Recommends Lucia for pizza in Queens."
Positive"A commenter recounted influencers comparing Lucia of Flushing favorably to Lucali and John's of Bleecker, noting it's a simple, old-school slice shop."
Positive"Contrasting hyped places like Lucali, a commenter mentioned Lucia as an example of a great neighborhood spot, referencing Lucia of Flushing specifically."
Positive"This user found Lucia Pizza in Soho to be overrated."
Negative"This commenter prefers Jonny's, Lucia, or Mama's Too over the overrated Prince Street Pizza."
Positive"This commenter suggests Lucia Pizza in Flushing is underrated and Amore Pizza in Whitestone is overrated."
Positive
