TLDR
Retro slice shop vibes with a side of vintage gaming. Famous for sesame-crusted squares and a laid-back, community-focused atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for PAULIE GEE'S SLICE SHOP(based on 16 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This is the first stop for the NYC Slice + Pint Passport, which offers a slice of pizza and a pint of Three's In the Fold Pilsner. The passport costs $20 and includes participation from eight different pizza shops, with 10% of beer sales benefiting Slice Out Hunger. The event aims to provide a delicious experience while supporting a charitable cause.
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop was the very first culinary stop for the poster upon their return to NYC. Both the 'Hellboy' and 'Hellboy square' slices are consistently excellent and are noted as reliable, delicious choices.
Paulie Gee's is featured as one of the top 15 best pizza places in New York City, celebrated for its creative wood-fired pizzas.
Arden Shore reviews Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, a charming Brooklyn spot with a casual vibe perfect for pizza lovers, highlighting its unique "Freddie Prinze" slice and lively atmosphere.
Details
Embodying the spirit of a retro suburban pizza parlor, this establishment serves as a casual neighborhood hub complete with vintage video games and sports on TV [1], [3]. While recognized as a valuable local spot, opinions on the quality have shifted, with some patrons noting a potential decline since its initial opening [1]. The menu features a variety of New York-style and square slices, including several vegan options, to cater to a broad audience [1], [2], [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic New York-style round slices and Sicilian-style squares, though some diners find the standard cheese slice to be unremarkable [1]. The shop is well-regarded for its creative toppings and diverse vegan options, though some visitors have felt specific specialty pies, like the vegan pepperoni, were only decent [1], [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PAULIE GEE'S SLICE SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Some Highlights From Five Days Of Eating In New
"The visitor found the pizza solid but preferred more cheese; a commenter asks if it's worth traveling for, noting the restaurant currently has a 'C' health inspection grade."
NeutralFrom post: Do Not Feed Alligators Has A Cnever Seen A C
"The commenter avoided their usual slice here due to the C rating and chose tacos elsewhere instead."
NegativeFrom post: Do Not Feed Alligators Has A Cnever Seen A C
"The user mentions Paulie Gee's in Greenpoint has a C rating."
NeutralFrom post: Mamas Too In Nyc Has Some Of My Favorite Slices
"The user was blown away by the pepperoni square slice with a sesame crust."
PositiveFrom post: From Scratch Salumi
"This commenter mentioned 'g's' in Brooklyn as a place for cured meats."
Positive