Next.js logo

JOE'S PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (646) 559-4878

Address: 1435 BROADWAY 10018

TLDR

A definitive, no-frills New York slice that defines the quintessential city pizza experience. Reliably consistent and widely accessible for a quick, classic bite.

Reddit Sentiment for JOE'S PIZZA(based on 339 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive29% Neutral20% Negative

Reddit Sentiment Over Time

Unique Posts Over Time

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 167american 88italian-american 27pizza 224slice 59beef patty 12View All

Neighborhoods

Theater District

Instagram Posts References

The video highlights Joe's Pizza, a famous New York pizzeria, with a shot of its iconic signage. A large slice of pizza, generously topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and red onions, is shown before a person enthusiastically takes a bite. It receives a positive rating of 9/10.

Joe's Pizza is included in the top 15 best pizza spots in New York City, an iconic destination known for its classic New York-style slices.

Joe's Pizza is highlighted as one of the top spots for authentic New York style pizza, praised for being 'worth the hype'. It's a classic choice for a quintessential NYC pizza experience.

This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its classic New York-style pizza.

Joe's Pizza is acknowledged for its continued popularity, despite receiving mixed reviews. The slices are noted for being the biggest of the day. The creator specifically tried the Margherita and Pepperoni slices, providing detailed feedback on the cheese, tomatoes, and pepperoni texture.

Joe's Pizza is presented as a fundamental 'crash course in New York Pizza', highlighting its essential status for experiencing traditional NYC pizza.

Jo.New York is praised for offering three distinct and highly enjoyed dishes: mehikari, a saba sandwich, and saba sushi, all listed as favorites.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
What Are You Looking For?

New York MagazineDate unknown
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
What are you looking for?

Around since the 1960s, Joe & John’s gives you everything you want from an NYC slice shop, plus a little bit more.

Bryan Kim, Neha Talreja, Willa Moore & Will HartmanDate unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

A quintessential destination for a classic New York-style slice, often regarded as the benchmark for a no-fuss, traditional experience [1][2]. While many patrons celebrate its consistency and historical significance as a reliable NYC staple [3][4], others argue it has become overrated or inconsistent compared to emerging artisan alternatives [5][6]. Opinions often vary based on location, with the original Carmine Street shop frequently receiving higher praise than the Times Square branch [7][8].

Food Overview

Known for its quintessential New York-style round cheese and pepperoni slices characterized by a foldable crust and classic tomato-sauce profile [1][2]. While many enjoy this traditional style, some diners have expressed dissatisfaction with a perceived overly sweet sauce [3][4] or issues with slice floppiness and freshness depending on the specific location [5][6].

Highlights / Recommended

"The classic cheese slice and the pepperoni slice are the most consistently recommended items for those seeking a standard New York experience [1][2]."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • pizza(6)
  • pizza slice(5)
  • pizza by the slice(5)
  • pepperoni slice(4)
  • cheese slice(3)

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is highly polarized; many locals and visitors consider it a gold-standard staple for a quick, authentic slice [1][2], while critics frequently label it as overhyped, mediocre, or a tourist trap, particularly at high-traffic locations [3][4].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About JOE'S PIZZA

A comprehensive debate where many users defend the restaurant as the gold standard for a New York slice, while others debate whether its fame makes it overrated.
This thread focuses on the Sicilian slice, highlighting its texture and balance while sparking discussion about whether the restaurant is a tourist trap or a classic.
A broad discussion on NYC food trends where the restaurant is frequently brought up as a benchmark for what constitutes a 'classic' versus 'overrated' slice.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"Pizza is universally available and a good late-night option, with St. Marks also having great spots."

Positive
May 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"A $1.50 slice of pizza from a place open late is suggested as a good late-night option."

Positive
May 16, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"Pizza is mentioned as a good option for late-night food."

Positive
May 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"Joe's Pizza is mentioned as a late-night food option."

Positive
May 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"The commenter states that any pizza or the closest bodega is a good option for late-night food."

Positive
May 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of

"Bleecker Street Pizza is mentioned as a past favorite for late-night food."

Positive
May 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This user waited 30 minutes in the cold for Joe's Pizza near Times Square and found the pizza to be 'bullshit mediocre.'"

Negative
May 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This user believes Joe's Pizza is 'pretty trash now' and has been trading on its name for a decade, calling the quality 'so low.'"

Negative
May 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This user inquired about which Joe's Pizza location was being discussed, noting that the Williamsburg location usually has no line."

Neutral
May 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This user prefers BEST Pizza over L'Industrie Pizzeria, particularly enjoying its dough."

Positive
May 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of

"This commenter waited 15 minutes for a slice at Joe's Pizza and found it 'painfully mediocre.'"

Negative
May 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user sarcastically questioned the price of a beef patty, asking "How much could it be Michael? $10.00?""

Neutral
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user believes a beef patty should not cost more than $5 and should come with cheese and coco bread if priced at $5."

Neutral
Apr 29, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"Responding to a high price, this user questioned if the patties were from a place like Whole Foods."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"Clarifying a previous comment, this user confirmed they were discussing Jamaican beef patties."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user reported being charged $4.50 for a beef patty at a pizza shop the previous night and felt they were ripped off."

Negative
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user inquired if "beef patty" referred to a burger or something else."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user reported paying $5.50 for a beef patty and about $10 with cheese at a pizza shop, expressing frustration with the economy."

Negative
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user stated that a beef patty costs 300 JMD."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: How Much Should A Beef Patty Cost At Your Local

"This user commented that a beef patty should cost $3."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2026View Comment →