Reddit Sentiment for DOMINICK'S BAR & RESTAURANT(based on 15 Reddit opinions)
Details
Dominick's Bar & Restaurant on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx offers a unique, old-school Italian dining experience where the menu is often a surprise, as staff prepare food based on customer requests [1]. It's highly recommended for its authentic atmosphere and is often suggested as part of a trip including local attractions [2]. Visitors should be prepared for a family-style dining experience and note that it may still be a cash-only establishment [3].
Food Overview
Dominick's offers a traditional Italian, family-style dining experience where the menu is often dictated by the kitchen based on customer requests rather than a printed list. The stuffed pork chop is a highlighted recommended dish [1], and Linguini mixed seafood Marechiara is also noted [2]. While generally praised, one commenter noted inconsistent experiences [3].
Caveats
It is recommended to bring cash, as the restaurant may still be cash-only. Additionally, one commenter advised against wearing Mets gear.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DOMINICK'S BAR & RESTAURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Is Your Favorite Seafood Pasta Youve Had In
"Dominick's in the Bronx is mentioned as a place that serves Linguini mixed seafood Marechiara."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations
"This user mentioned that old-school Italian places are hard to find and gatekept, suggesting Arthur Ave is the closest a tourist can get to the past experience."
NeutralFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Dominick's on Arthur Ave is preferred by this commenter's family among other good spots on the avenue for red sauce Italian."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"This commenter notes that traveling to Arthur Ave from midtown can be time-consuming and the vibe might be depressing in bad weather, suggesting it's best for train enthusiasts."
NeutralFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Arthur Ave, including Dominick's, is a must-visit for its food, and the Holiday Train show at the Bronx Zoo is also mentioned as an option."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"The original poster is mapping out a trip to Arthur Ave that includes the Holiday Train Show, noting it could be an incredible evening."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Arthur Ave in the Bronx is highly recommended for its authentic Italian and Sicilian atmosphere, with Dominick's being a standout. The commenter shares a personal anecdote about the neighborhood's distinct character."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Dominick's on Arthur Ave is described as old-school and fitting the desired vibe, though it might still be cash only."
PositiveFrom post: Red Sauce Italian
"Dominick's on Arthur Ave in the Bronx is highly recommended for its excellent food and is suggested as part of a trip that includes the Holiday Train Show at the NY Botanical Gardens."
PositiveFrom post: Unpopular Opinions Fall 2025 Edition
"Dominick's is mentioned as a good Italian restaurant, though the commenter has had inconsistent experiences."
NeutralFrom post: Bayridge Or Arthur Ave For Old School Italian Red
"The user who is coming from Midtown finds Dominick's on Arthur Ave to be a worthwhile experience, suggesting it might be worth a longer drive if Bay Ridge is not significantly closer."
PositiveFrom post: Bayridge Or Arthur Ave For Old School Italian Red
"This user suggests Dominick's on Arthur Ave and highlights the stuffed pork chop as a recommended dish."
PositiveFrom post: Best Arthur Ave Option For A Good Time
"This long-time patron of Dominic's has never seen a menu, as the staff prepares food based on customer requests, and advises against wearing Mets gear."
PositiveFrom post: Best Arthur Ave Option For A Good Time
"The family-style dining at Dominic's makes for a fun evening, according to this commenter."
PositiveFrom post: Best Arthur Ave Option For A Good Time
"Dominic's is a good option. It's recommended to bring cash as the dining experience is family-style."
Positive