Reddit Sentiment for PEKING DUCK HOUSE(based on 29 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Chinese restaurant on East 53rd Street is a well-regarded establishment, particularly noted for its stellar Peking duck [1]. It's described as an old-school spot that offers a more upscale dining experience, making it suitable for special occasions or larger groups [2], [3]. While many praise the quality of the duck, some have noted that the skin may not always be crispy and the fat separation can be inconsistent [4].
Food Overview
The primary draw is the Peking duck, which is frequently described as stellar and excellent [1], [2], [5]. Some users have debated whether it's comparable to Cantonese-style duck, with one user suggesting it's not the best choice for that specific preparation [3]. While the duck receives high marks, one diner found the skin not crispy and the fat not separated, and also had a negative experience with the mapo tofu [4]. The restaurant also serves fried chicken and tenders, which have been described as solid and praised by users [6], [7].
Caveats
One diner found the Peking duck's skin not crispy and the fat not separated from the skin, also expressing dissatisfaction with the mapo tofu [1]. There have also been discussions about whether the duck here is truly Cantonese-style or if other establishments are better for that specific preparation [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PEKING DUCK HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Whats Your Favorite Preparation Of Duck In The
"Beijing duck at Trying Duck House was mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: Niche Request Big Circle Tables
"The commenter suggested Peking Duck House as a restaurant that might have large round tables for group dinners."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Dinner Restaurant For 9 People No
"This commenter had a positive experience dining for 9 people at Peking Duck house on E 53rd St, enjoying the round table, good service, excellent duck, and very good other dishes for $65 pp including tip."
PositiveFrom post: Graduating Nyu Need Dinner Recs
"A user recommended Peking Duck House on 53rd street, noting it is a fun and interesting spot suitable for big groups and family-style dining, with potential costs around $40 per person."
PositiveFrom post: Peking Duck On Christmas Night
"This commenter stated that on Christmas, Peking Duck House would be fully booked for weeks, contradicting the idea of walking in."
NeutralFrom post: Peking Duck On Christmas Night
"This commenter simply mentioned 'peking duck house' as an option."
NeutralFrom post: Peking Duck On Christmas Night
"In response to a question about Peking Duck House, this commenter stated that both locations were booked, indicating they had waited too long to make reservations."
NeutralFrom post: Peking Duck On Christmas Night
"This commenter asked if the original poster had tried both the Midtown and Chinatown locations of Peking Duck House."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Rec For Saturday Dinner Les Looking For
"User recommended Peking Duck House as a good option if considering Two Bridges and Chinatown."
NeutralFrom post: Large Party Brunch Recommendations Near China Town
"This user suggested Peking Duck House for a more upscale dining experience."
PositiveFrom post: Family Style Chinese Food Dinner In Midtown Nyc
"Peking Duck House on E. 53rd is suggested as a pricier option but suitable for memorable events."
PositiveFrom post: Need A Cheap Christmas Dinner
"Peking Duck House is suggested as a festive option for Christmas dinner, offering a full duck which could be an affordable way to celebrate."
PositiveFrom post: Need A New Chinese Takeout Spot Midtown Fifties
"This user inquired whether the Peking Duck House located on 53rd Street is comparable to the one in Chinatown."
NeutralFrom post: Need A New Chinese Takeout Spot Midtown Fifties
"The user is looking for an alternative to Peking Duck House, which has been their backup Chinese takeout spot. They are not interested in overly spicy or unusual dishes, preferring classic options like dumplings, wontons, egg drop soup, chicken with cashews, moo shu, spare ribs, fried rice, and sautéed string beans."
NeutralFrom post: Best Midtown Chinese Delivery
"Peking Duck House is mentioned as a restaurant that delivers to the West 50s, where the commenter resides."
PositiveFrom post: Fav Restaurant In Manhattan Chinatown
"This commenter suggests Peking Duck House for a more 'fancy night out'."
PositiveFrom post: Fav Restaurant In Manhattan Chinatown
"This commenter recommends Peking Duck House."
NegativeFrom post: Has Anyone From Sf Found An Equivalent To The
"This user stated that the chili chicken sandwich at Pecking House closely matches the style of The Bird's spicy fried chicken sandwich from SF, and they even prefer Pecking House's version."
PositiveFrom post: Has Anyone From Sf Found An Equivalent To The
"This user commented that while the newer Popeyes chicken sandwich isn't as good as its initial launch, it's still solid. They also mentioned enjoying Peking House's fried chicken and are looking forward to trying Rowdy Rooster due to positive reviews. They also mentioned missing Chinatown Pies and Thighs."
PositiveFrom post: Has Anyone From Sf Found An Equivalent To The
"This user recommended Pecking House for chicken sandwiches, noting menu changes but still finding good options, and specifically praised their tenders."
Positive