Historic NYC steakhouse famed for its legendary mutton chop and old-school ambiance.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan institution since 1885, offers a unique dining experience celebrated for its signature mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance. The restaurant is renowned for its dry-aged steaks and a cozy, intimate atmosphere enriched by historical artifacts, including thousands of clay pipes. Whether for a special occasion or a casual bar visit, Keens provides a classic establishment feel that impresses patrons.
Keens Steakhouse is celebrated for its legendary mutton chop, which many describe as a must-try. Other highly recommended dishes include the King's Cut prime rib, porterhouse steak, and prime rib hash. Sides like creamed spinach, hash browns, and fries also receive positive mentions. However, some patrons have found the regular steaks to be mediocre or under-seasoned, and one reviewer noted the lobster bisque was not good. The burger has received mixed reviews, with some calling it excellent and others finding it only 'okay' or dry.
"The mutton chop is consistently lauded as a signature dish, with many recommending it as a must-try. Other highly recommended items include the King's Cut prime rib, porterhouse steak, prime rib hash, and various sides like creamed spinach and fries."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Keens Steakhouse for its historic atmosphere and the quality of its signature dishes, particularly the mutton chop and prime rib. While some find the steaks to be only 'okay' or slightly under-seasoned, the overall sentiment leans towards a highly recommended, classic New York dining experience.
Important Note
Some diners have reported that the regular steaks at Keens can be mediocre or under-seasoned, and one review mentioned the lobster bisque was not good. There have also been mixed opinions regarding the impact of new ownership on food quality, though many still find it excellent.
"Keen's is suggested as a restaurant to consider for the anniversary dinner."
Neutral"The commenter suggests going to Keens or Luger's and ordering lavishly for multiple meals or bringing a friend to share."
Neutral"The commenter states that Keen's mutton chop is the best 'steak' they have ever had in NYC."
Positive"The commenter suggests going to Harry's, Keens, or Odeon instead of Wolfgang's."
Negative"The commenter recommends getting the porterhouse at Wolfgang's and also suggests considering Keen's or Luger's for a more old-school vibe."
Positive"The commenter suggests ordering filet mignon at Wolfgang's and also mentions Keen's and Peter Luger's as popular tourist spots."
Negative"In response to a negative review of Delmonico's price, this user stated Delmonico's is expensive and suggested Keen's for its King's cut prime rib ($89) as the best bang for the buck IMO."
Positive"Keen's steakhouse is suggested as a classic option for lunch."
Neutral"The author recommended the mutton chop at Keens."
Positive"Keen's is suggested as a more relaxed option for a group of 10 men celebrating a poker win, and it's noted that they would likely be well under budget."
Positive"The commenter advises avoiding Keens unless one specifically wants mutton, suggesting it's not ideal for steak."
Negative"Keens is recommended as a classic steakhouse option."
Positive"The user recommended Keen's as a steakhouse option for someone with a wheat allergy. This is a general recommendation for a type of cuisine."
Neutral"Keen's was mentioned as a recommendation."
Neutral"Keens was listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"Has recently been a fan of Gallagher's."
Positive"Recommends Keens for the mutton chop, finding the prime rib decent but suggesting better options exist for steak."
Neutral"Suggests ordering a sauce like au poivre or red wine with the steak at Keens, as it greatly enhances the flavor."
Positive"Had an amazing experience at Keens in June, noting the steak was good with sauce and the sides like creamed spinach and fries were super good."
Positive"Found Keens mediocre with underseasoned, dry steak and smelly mutton chops, preferring Gallagher's, Delmonico's, or Strip House."
Negative
