TLDR
Historic steakhouse landmark famous for its signature mutton chop and unparalleled old-school atmosphere. A must-visit for classic NYC vibes and iconic meat-centric fare.
Reddit Sentiment for KEENS STEAKHOUSE(based on 458 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The illustration depicts a dining scene at Keen's Steakhouse, a well-known New York City establishment. The artwork, created by victoria.krylov.illustration, is part of a larger project. The image showcases a group of individuals enjoying a meal, with the restaurant's characteristic decor visible in the background, including a prominent portrait and framed pictures on the walls.
Recommended for those who want to try a "real New York steak."
Keen's English Chop House is a legendary steakhouse in New York City, established in 1889. It is renowned for its high-quality prime steaks, particularly its signature Mutton Chop. The restaurant boasts a rich history and a classic, upscale ambiance, complete with a collection of antique pipes displayed on its walls. In addition to steaks, Keen's offers a selection of appetizers, seafood, and sides, including roasted vegetables and mashed potatoes. The establishment also has an impressive bar with a wide array of whiskeys and cocktails, contributing to its status as a quintessential New York dining experience.
Keen's Steakhouse is presented as an upscale dining establishment, with an image showcasing a beautifully prepared steak, accompanied by French fries and various sauces. The presentation suggests a high-quality dining experience, ideal for steak enthusiasts.
Keens Steakhouse, a historic 140-year-old Midtown institution, remains a top destination for steak lovers, offering classic cocktails and its signature mutton chop in a timeless setting.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Details
Established in 1885, this historic Midtown Manhattan institution is renowned for its time-traveling atmosphere, featuring a famous collection of clay pipes [1]. Diners frequently celebrate its iconic, thick-cut mutton chop [1], [2] and exceptional prime rib [1], solidifying its status as a quintessential New York dining experience. While some critics debate the consistency of the steaks compared to other top-tier establishments [3], many remain loyal to its classic service and nostalgic charm [4].
Food Overview
The cuisine is firmly rooted in traditional American steakhouse fare, with the signature 26-ounce mutton chop being the most frequently recommended dish [1], [2], [6]. Other standout items include the prime rib [1], prime rib hash [1], and creamed spinach [1], [6], while some diners occasionally find specific steak cuts underwhelming or dry [3].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •mutton chop(61)This is Keens' signature dish, highly recommended by many reviewers as a must-or...
- •mutton(48)This is what Keens is known for, with many highly recommending it, even over ste...
- •steak(40)While generally considered good and a staple of the steakhouse experience, revie...
- •prime rib(36)Praised by many as exceptional and superior to other steakhouses, this cut is no...
- •sundae(20)The sundae, particularly the butterscotch and hot fudge varieties, is frequently...
- •porterhouse(15)Considered amazing by long-time patrons and often recommended over other steaks,...
- •creamed spinach(14)This classic steakhouse side is highly recommended by many as amazing and on poi...
- •burger(12)Reviews for the burger are divided; some describe it as the best in the city or ...
- •hash(8)This dish is frequently recommended, with reviewers calling it amazing, a sleepe...
- •bacon(8)The bacon is consistently praised as highly recommended, a favorite appetizer, a...
- •carrot cake(8)This dessert is generally recommended as very good, described as moist, dense, a...
- •lobster bisque(7)Described as divine and excellent, this bisque is considered the best thing some...
- •ribeye(7)
- •lamb chop(6)Lamb chops are mentioned as a decent option, with one reviewer noting their son ...
- •fries(6)The fries receive strong praise, with multiple reviewers calling them amazing, s...
- •martini(5)Highly recommended, particularly at the bar, the martinis are described as very ...
- •hash browns(4)
- •bananas foster(3)
- •creme brûlée(3)
- •mint jelly(3)
- •potatoes(3)
- •lamb(3)
- •scotch(2)
- •Caesar salad(2)
- •turkey schnitzel(2)
- •shrimp cocktail(2)
- •steak salad(2)
- •coffee cantata(2)
- •oysters rockefeller(2)
- •sole(2)
- •sirloin(2)
Customer Sentiment
Most visitors laud the restaurant as a classic, high-quality NYC institution with a unique and transporting atmosphere [1], [5]. However, some diners report inconsistencies in food quality and service, occasionally noting it as overpriced or overrated compared to other elite steakhouses [3], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About KEENS STEAKHOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Manhattan Restaurant That Is Worth The Money And
"Recommended as a steakhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Manhattan Restaurant That Is Worth The Money And
"Highly recommended as a classic steakhouse option."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Some Unusual Things That Restaurants In
"The restaurant is a great experience and is noted for its extraordinary mutton chop."
PositiveFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Recommends the happy hour mutton over the dinner portion, as the larger size can become bland."
NeutralFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Praised for its atmosphere and character, but criticized for having steaks that rank at the bottom of top-tier NYC steakhouses."
NeutralFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Praises the service as otherworldly and recommends the porterhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Recommends visiting to judge for yourself as it is a unique space with top-notch cocktails, sides, and service."
PositiveFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Keep the reservation for the atmosphere and historic interest; the mutton chop and martinis are highly recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Found the experience and hyped items like the mutton chop and creamed spinach disappointing and underseasoned."
NegativeFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Highly recommended, specifically mentioning the potatoes and carrots as sides."
PositiveFrom post: Keens Vs Benjamin Prime Or Another Midtown
"Preferably chooses this location over Benjamin Prime for a porterhouse steak."
PositiveFrom post: Anniversary Weekend In The City Restaurant Reviews
"The dining experience was heavily impacted by extreme noise levels at a neighboring table. Thought the food was good but ultimately mid-tier compared to other steakhouses."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Dine With A Baby Frequent Nyc Traveler
"The commenter used to bring their six-month-old to the bar area, sitting on a wall with stools and keeping the baby in the stroller."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Dine With A Baby Frequent Nyc Traveler
"The commenter had a good lunch experience here with a baby, noting that a small stroller was helpful."
PositiveFrom post: Osteria La Baia Almost Tricked Me With Farmed
"The author mentioned eating here the night before."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant For A Post Wedding
"Mentioned as a potential steakhouse option for a post-wedding dinner."
NeutralFrom post: Delmonicos Worth It Or Try Another Steakhouse
"Thinks Keens was never great and visits primarily for history and ambiance, comparing it to Lugers."
NeutralFrom post: Delmonicos Worth It Or Try Another Steakhouse
"The user personally prefers Keens."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Worth It Or Try Another Steakhouse
"Views Delmonico's as superior to Keens in the post-COVID era."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For A Birthday Meal Couple From
"States it remains solid for a traditional, only-in-NYC experience."
Positive