Historic NYC steakhouse, legendary mutton chop, classic ambiance.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Keens Steakhouse is a historic New York institution renowned for its classic ambiance and its signature "legendary" mutton chop. Established in 1885, the restaurant offers a unique, old-school New York experience, complete with a collection of historic pipes and artifacts. Diners often praise the prime rib and porterhouse steaks, alongside traditional sides, contributing to its reputation as a top steakhouse destination.
Keen's is highly regarded for its signature "legendary" mutton chop, which many consider a must-try. Other popular dishes include the prime rib, porterhouse steak, and various sides like creamed spinach and hash browns. While many praise the overall quality of the meat and the traditional steakhouse fare, a few reviews mention inconsistency or under-seasoning with the steaks themselves.
"The "legendary" mutton chop is the most frequently recommended dish, with many also suggesting the prime rib, porterhouse steak, hash browns, creamed spinach, and bacon."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Keen's, praising its classic New York steakhouse atmosphere and many of its dishes, though some find the steaks themselves to be just
Important Note
Some diners have reported inconsistencies with steak seasoning and quality, and one user had a negative experience with cold food.
"A commenter recommended Keens for a birthday celebration, specifically highlighting the King's Cut prime rib as a great value."
Positive"Keens was mentioned as a potential location for a birthday dinner. The user is looking for a nice sit-down experience in NYC and is not limited by cuisine."
Neutral"This comment simply suggests Keen's as a dining option."
Neutral"This steakhouse is located at 36th and 6th and offers food that is not typically found in suburban areas."
Positive"This steakhouse is suggested as the best option near Chelsea for visitors looking for a steakhouse."
Positive"This user acknowledges that they missed the 'no sit-down' preference, agreeing that Keen's might not be suitable."
Neutral"This user reiterates that Keen's is not a sit-down option, suggesting something quick and cheap is better for solo travel."
Negative"This user defends Keen's as a possibility for the 90-minute window, noting it can be done during lunchtime."
Neutral"This user points out that Keen's is not a quick bite option, contradicting the original poster's request."
Negative"This steakhouse is mentioned as a dining option."
Positive"Keen's is listed among several restaurants, but is noted as not being a quick bite."
Neutral"This steakhouse provides a classic New York experience with excellent food, cocktails, and martinis. Their steaks are notably seasoned with salt and peppercorns."
Positive"The restaurant has a very classic NYC atmosphere and is known for its mutton chops and steaks. It was also featured on an Anthony Bourdain show."
Positive"This steakhouse is very old, located on West 35th St, and features authentic pipes owned by famous New Yorkers. It is recommended to reserve for the main dining room and highlights their great steaks and mutton chops."
Positive"This restaurant offers a classic New York vibe and has a bar where patrons can eat."
Positive"This steakhouse is mentioned as having a good vibe at the bar for solo diners. The commenter suggests it as an alternative to French restaurants for steak."
Positive"The commenter clarified that Keens offers a specific Thanksgiving menu, and if one prefers steak or mutton, it might be better to visit on another occasion. They also recalled possibly having steak and mutton on the Thanksgiving menu last year."
Neutral"The commenter expressed that Keens is on their wish list and would be a solid option for Thanksgiving."
Positive"Keens is suggested as a Thanksgiving option, with the commenter noting that reservations typically open in early October and the price was around $155 last year."
Positive"The mutton chop at Keens Steakhouse was mentioned by a commenter as a dish they would go back for."
Positive
