Iconic NYC steakhouse w/ historic ambiance & legendary mutton chop [1]. Known for dry-aged steaks & cozy vibe.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan institution since 1885, offers a unique dining experience with its time-traveling ambiance and renowned dishes like the signature mutton chop and dry-aged steaks. The restaurant is praised for its classic American cuisine, with highlights including the porterhouse steak, prime rib hash, and a decadent hot fudge sundae. Its interior, adorned with historical artifacts and thousands of clay pipes, creates an intimate and cozy atmosphere, making it suitable for both special occasions and casual visits to the bar. While some find it expensive, the overall experience is often described as worthwhile, with excellent service complementing the food and ambiance [1].
Keens Steakhouse is celebrated for its dry-aged steaks and chops, with the signature mutton chop being a standout, described as a "fatty, flavorful beauty" [1]. Other recommended dishes include the prime porterhouse, prime rib hash, and a well-executed burger. Sides like hash browns and creamed spinach also receive positive mentions. For dessert, the hot fudge sundae is a popular choice [1]. However, some users have noted inconsistency in steak quality and found the vegetable sides to be particularly expensive.
"The signature mutton chop is highly recommended, described as a must-try and a "fatty, flavorful beauty" [1]. Other popular choices include the prime porterhouse steak, prime rib hash, and the hot fudge sundae."
Diners frequently praise Keens for its classic NYC steakhouse vibe, historic ambiance, and signature mutton chop. While some mention recent ownership changes and a potential for inconsistent steak quality, the overall sentiment leans positive, with many recommending it for special occasions or a taste of old New York [1].
Important Note
Some users have expressed concerns about the steak's quality and consistency, with a few mentioning potential issues after recent ownership changes. Additionally, the vegetable side dishes are noted as being quite expensive.
"A suggestion was made to visit Keens Steakhouse in July, noting it's halfway to the holidays."
Neutral"Keens Steakhouse was recommended as a steakhouse option, noting that $250 would go far there and it offers good value, especially for the prime rib."
Positive"The prime rib at Keens was praised for its value."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse was recommended, suggesting the $250 gift card would allow for multiple visits, especially if not ordering large steaks or many cocktails."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse is a classic choice near Times Square for steak. Reservations are recommended as it can get very busy."
Positive"This user critically stated that Keens Steakhouse, along with Gramercy Tavern and Odeon, are classics rather than 'hotspots' and can be found in one's hometown."
Negative"This user recommended Keens Steakhouse as a classic NYC dining option."
Positive"The original poster thanked the commenter for the recommendations."
Positive"Keens was recommended as a high-end steakhouse option for a nice room and ambiance without experimental food, suitable for a romantic dinner."
Positive"This commenter suggested having lunch at Keens Steakhouse in the bar for a small steak and fries, along with a Keens ale or ginger ale, describing it as the real NYC experience."
Positive"For steak, having lunch at Keens in the bar is recommended for a small steak and fries, along with a drink, as the true NYC experience."
Positive"Another user enthusiastically agreed that Keens is the best steakhouse."
Positive"Keens is mentioned as a favorite steakhouse, with a recommendation to try it for lunch in the bar for a small steak and fries, calling it a real NYC experience."
Positive"A commenter recommended Keens Steakhouse, noting its unique mutton dish and novelty, suggesting it for a worthwhile NYC steakhouse experience."
Positive"A commenter found Keens to be good but unspectacular food-wise, highlighting the fun atmosphere and historical vibe as the main draw, suggesting sitting in the Bull Moose Room."
Neutral"Keen's was suggested as a restaurant for the group."
Positive"The commenter suggests Keens Steakhouse as a place they would miss if they moved away from NYC, implying it's a classic NYC establishment."
Positive"Keens is mentioned as a place the commenter would miss if they moved from NYC, suggesting it's a notable establishment."
Positive"This is one of many restaurants listed by the commenter from the NYTimes list."
Neutral"The bar at Keens is listed as a favorite spot for bar dining."
Positive
