Historic NYC steakhouse known for its legendary mutton chop & classic vibe; great for steak lovers but with mixed recent reviews.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan institution, is celebrated for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, offering a truly classic New York steakhouse experience. While many praise its steaks and atmosphere, some recent feedback points to inconsistencies and concerns over new ownership, though the signature mutton and prime rib remain popular highlights.
Keens Steakhouse is renowned for its classic American steakhouse fare, with the legendary mutton chop being a signature dish that receives consistent praise. Other recommended items include dry-aged steaks, particularly the porterhouse and prime rib, along with sides like prime rib hash, creamed spinach, and fries. While the food is generally well-regarded, some recent reviews mention steak inconsistency and under-seasoning, contrasting with the popularity of the mutton and desserts like the hot fudge sundae.
"The legendary mutton chop is consistently highlighted as a must-try signature dish. Other popular recommendations include the porterhouse steak, prime rib, prime rib hash, and various sides like creamed spinach and fries. The desserts, particularly the hot fudge sundae and carrot cake, are also frequently praised."
Customer sentiment is largely positive, with frequent praise for the historic atmosphere, signature mutton chop, and quality steaks. However, some recent feedback notes inconsistency in steak quality and expresses concerns about new ownership.
Important Note
Recent reviews suggest potential inconsistencies in steak quality, with some diners finding the steak mediocre or under-seasoned. Concerns have also been raised about new ownership potentially impacting the restaurant's character.
"Keen's Chop House was suggested as a dining option."
Positive"Recommends dining at the bar at Keens."
Positive"Keens was frequently visited by this user for many lunches."
Positive"For those from cultures that eat lamb, Keen's is suggested as a place to try both mutton and sirloin to compare."
Positive"For those from cultures that eat lamb, Keen's is suggested as a place to try both mutton and sirloin to compare."
Positive"A user simply states that Keen's is the answer for a first beef experience."
Positive"A user simply states that Keen's is the answer for a first beef experience."
Positive"Keen's is suggested as an old-school steakhouse option for experiencing beef."
Positive"Keen's is suggested as an old-school steakhouse option for experiencing beef."
Positive"Keen's is recommended for a first beef experience, particularly for a nice steak."
Positive"Keen's is recommended for a first beef experience, particularly for a nice steak."
Positive"Keen's is recommended as a place to dine at the bar."
Positive"Keen's Steakhouse was mentioned as a potential option for reservations."
Positive"This user agreed with the previous comment that Keen's has a good carrot cake."
Positive"Despite costing $450 for a family of four, the experience at Keens Steakhouse was very worth it, with incredible ambiance, amazing service, delicious food, and generously filled martini glasses."
Positive"When discussing steakhouse options, Keens is suggested as a reliable choice, especially given the perceived decline of other establishments like Wolfgang's."
Positive"This comment recommends Keens Steakhouse and suggests that Tete d'Or is overpriced, implying it doesn't offer good value for the name."
Positive"This user recommended Keens Steakhouse for its unique atmosphere and historical significance, suggesting it's a must-experience for those interested in American history."
Positive"Keens has a good ambiance but is considered to have not great food."
Negative"Keens is ranked higher than Gallagher's. While the ambiance is good, the food has been underwhelming on recent visits, with steaks messed up twice."
Negative
