Historic NYC steakhouse w/ legendary mutton chop & classic, time-traveling ambiance. A must-visit for steak lovers.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Keens Steakhouse, a historic New York institution since 1885, offers a classic steakhouse experience with a unique, time-traveling ambiance. Renowned for its signature mutton chop, dry-aged steaks, and a collection of historical artifacts including thousands of clay pipes, it provides an intimate and cozy atmosphere. Whether for a special occasion or a casual visit to the bar, Keens delivers a memorable meal.
Keens Steakhouse is celebrated for its "legendary" mutton chop, which is frequently cited as a must-try dish. Reviewers also consistently praise the dry-aged steaks, with the Porterhouse and Prime Rib (especially the King's Cut) being popular choices. Sides like creamed spinach and hash browns receive high marks. While the majority of feedback on the steaks is positive, a minority of opinions suggest inconsistency or a lack of seasoning. Desserts like the hot fudge sundae and carrot cake are also noted as enjoyable.
"The "legendary" mutton chop is the most consistently recommended dish. Other popular choices include the Porterhouse steak, the King's Cut Prime Rib, and various sides such as creamed spinach and hash browns. The "taste of mutton" appetizer is also a good way to try this signature dish."
Customers largely have a positive view of Keens, praising its historic atmosphere, excellent service, and particularly its signature mutton chop. While most reviews are glowing, a few mention that the steak itself can be inconsistent or under-seasoned.
Important Note
Some recent reviews suggest inconsistency in steak quality, with a few diners finding it under-seasoned or mediocre. There's also a mention of potential political implications due to recent ownership changes, which may affect some diners' experiences.
"This user recommends Keens Steakhouse for dessert and drinks, highlighting that steakhouses often have great dessert options."
Positive"For a classic steakhouse vibe, Keen's is recommended as a suitable option for a birthday celebration."
Positive"Keen's was listed as one of several steakhouse options for a birthday dinner in NYC."
Neutral"This user simply stated they like the key lime pie at Keens."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse is recommended as an upscale dining option."
Positive"Keens is mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"Keens is a classic NYC steakhouse located near Grand Central that is highly recommended, especially for lunch sets."
Positive"Keens is mentioned as the best option if looking for a classic NYC steakhouse."
Positive"Keens is recommended."
Positive"Keens is recommended."
Positive"Keens was mentioned as a restaurant recommendation."
Positive"Keens is mentioned as a steak restaurant option."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse is suggested as a potential dining choice."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse is recommended as a dining option."
Positive"Keens is suggested as an option for a birthday steak dinner, alongside Hawksmoor."
Positive"Keens is especially recommended for visitors, noting its rich NYC history and steakhouse experience."
Positive"Keens Steakhouse was listed as a recommendation for a cool steakhouse with great food, similar to Au Cheval."
Positive"The new owner of Keens reportedly bought it to maintain its existing character."
Neutral"Keens had good vibes when visited last month."
Positive"Keens bar is mentioned as a good option, though it can get very crowded."
Positive
