TLDR
An iconic 1885 institution famous for its legendary mutton chop and historic, pipe-lined atmosphere. A must-visit classic for authentic New York steakhouse vibes.
Reddit Sentiment for KEENS STEAKHOUSE(based on 499 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Keen's English Chop House is a legendary steakhouse in New York City, established in 1889. It is renowned for its high-quality prime steaks, particularly its signature Mutton Chop. The restaurant boasts a rich history and a classic, upscale ambiance, complete with a collection of antique pipes displayed on its walls. In addition to steaks, Keen's offers a selection of appetizers, seafood, and sides, including roasted vegetables and mashed potatoes. The establishment also has an impressive bar with a wide array of whiskeys and cocktails, contributing to its status as a quintessential New York dining experience.
Keen's Steakhouse is presented as an upscale dining establishment, with an image showcasing a beautifully prepared steak, accompanied by French fries and various sauces. The presentation suggests a high-quality dining experience, ideal for steak enthusiasts.
Keens Steakhouse is a celebrated Midtown institution famous for its signature mutton chop. It also boasts a unique and extensive collection of 130-year-old pipes, adding to its historic charm.
A true New York City institution since 1885, Keens is renowned for its dry-aged steaks and historic atmosphere. It is a must-visit for its famous mutton chop, a favorite of Anthony Bourdain, and its impressive collection of pipes.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Keens Steakhouse, a historic Midtown Manhattan restaurant known for its legendary mutton chop and time-traveling ambiance, praising its classic dishes and cozy atmosphere.
Details
A historic Midtown institution serving classic American fare since 1885, this steakhouse is renowned for its time-traveling atmosphere and expansive collection of antique pipes [1]. While recently acquired by a new hospitality group, the restaurant continues to draw crowds for its signature, generously portioned mutton chop [2] and its well-regarded prime rib [3]. The cozy, wood-paneled dining rooms and lively bar provide a quintessentially New York dining experience perfect for special occasions or a classic, hearty meal [4].
Food Overview
The restaurant is famous for its signature mutton chop, which is often described as tender, fatty, and flavor-forward [4]. While the prime rib and various steak cuts are popular recommendations [3], customer feedback on steak quality can be inconsistent [5]. Many also praise the hot fudge sundae [4], prime rib hash [1], and the restaurant's ability to accommodate guests with severe allergies [6].
Highlights / Recommended
"The signature 26-ounce mutton chop is the most frequently recommended dish [1], [3], followed by the prime rib [3] and the hot fudge sundae [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •mutton chop(41)
- •mutton(36)
- •steak(23)
- •prime rib(22)
- •creamed spinach(11)
- •mutton chops(11)
- •sundae(10)
- •burger(10)
- •carrot cake(8)
- •porterhouse(8)
- •lobster bisque(7)
- •ribeye(7)
- •steaks(7)
- •king's cut prime rib(6)
- •fries(6)
- •taste of mutton(5)
- •prime rib hash(5)
- •bacon(5)
- •lamb chops(4)
- •butterscotch sundae(3)
- •ice cream sundae(3)
- •lamb(3)
- •hash(3)
- •porterhouse for two(3)
- •bananas foster(3)
- •creme brûlée(3)
- •kings cut prime rib(2)
- •shrimp cocktail(2)
- •turkey schnitzel(2)
- •steak salad(2)
- •scotch(2)
- •hash browns(2)
- •hash brown(2)
- •caesar salad(2)
- •filet(2)
- •coffee cantata(2)
- •mint jelly(2)
Caveats
Some visitors report inconsistencies in food quality, specifically regarding steak texture, and note that the vegetable sides can be quite expensive [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About KEENS STEAKHOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Whats The Best Gingerforward Food Or Drink Youve
"Notes the surprising amount of ginger flavor in the ginger ale at Keens, describing it as fresh ginger in seltzer and very refreshing."
PositiveFrom post: Team Dinner Near 30th And Broadway 10 People For
"This commenter suggested Keens, possibly for steak, alongside Korean BBQ."
PositiveFrom post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended Keens' Mutton Chop and Escarole."
PositiveFrom post: Team Dinner Near 30th And Broadway 10 People For
"This user simply recommended Keens."
PositiveFrom post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended Keens' mutton chop and escarole."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"Responding to a negative review of Keens, this user asked if the criticism was specifically about the King Cut Prime Rib. They stated that their experience with the prime rib has been great over many visits, though they prefer other places for ribeye or other cuts."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"This commenter stated that Keens' meat quality is terrible, despite acknowledging it has a great atmosphere. They believe the food quality needs significant improvement to be considered world-class."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"The original poster clarified they do enjoy Keens but want to try other places. They also praised the coconut dessert and mutton there."
PositiveFrom post: Dinner Near Penn Station Looking For More High
"Keens is listed as a solid restaurant option near Penn Station, considered among the best available in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"This user asked if the original poster disliked Keens or was simply seeking variety. They recommended 4 Charles as their top choice for prime rib."
NeutralFrom post: Dinner Near Penn Station Looking For More High
"Keens Steakhouse is suggested as a good dining option near Penn Station."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"The original poster mentioned Keens, and the replier inquired if they disliked the Prime Rib or were just looking for alternatives. This replier also noted that fancy steakhouses often offer to redo orders if not executed well."
NeutralFrom post: Need An Amazing Steak Sandwich Under 30 Doesnt
"The top sirloin sandwich from the pub area at Keens is recommended for lunch."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendation For Celebratory Dinner 800 Omakase
"Keane's was suggested as a potential spot for the user's celebration."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Trip Allergenfriendly Dining Report Egg
"This commenter found Keens Steakhouse promising for their son who has multiple severe allergies (milk, egg, nut, peanut) and is cautious about cross-contamination. They note that many steak places use butter for finishing, making Keens' ability to accommodate particularly valuable."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Trip Allergenfriendly Dining Report Egg
"The staff was very knowledgeable and helpful with allergies. They were able to prepare steak without dairy, and the fries are cooked in a dedicated fryer. The dining experience was great overall."
PositiveFrom post: Great Places For Carnivore Husband And My Dairy
"Keen's was mentioned as a steakhouse that is often recommended in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Need Help Selecting A Location For A Work Team
"This commenter suggested Keens, highlighting its multiple private rooms suitable for various group sizes and its ability to balance a casual drinking vibe with a nice dinner experience, also noting good shareable entrees and appetizers."
PositiveFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This commenter agrees that Keens is mediocre and overrated within the NYC dining scene."
NegativeFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This user fully agrees with negative sentiments expressed about Keens."
Negative