TLDR
Best cannoli in NYC? Freshly filled delights & amazing Italian cookies. A must-try Bushwick spot!
Reddit Sentiment for CIRCO PASTRY SHOP(based on 10 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Bushwick bakery is celebrated for its Italian pastries, particularly its cannoli, which are often praised for their freshness and filling [1], [5]. Customers also rave about their cookies, with specific mentions of fig-filled, almond paste with orange peel, and rainbow cookies [2], [7]. While generally well-regarded, one reviewer noted a slight cinnamon flavor in the cannoli compared to other styles [4].
Food Overview
The bakery is renowned for its Italian pastries, with cannoli being a standout item, often filled to order [1], [5]. Their cookie selection is also highly praised, featuring varieties like fig-filled, almond paste with orange peel, and rainbow cookies [2], [7]. While most feedback is positive, one comment suggested a cinnamon note in the cannoli that detracted for some palates [4]. Other customers appreciate the ability to mix and match cookies by weight [6].
The cannoli and various cookies, including fig-filled, almond paste with orange peel, and rainbow cookies, are highly recommended by patrons.
Caveats
One reviewer noted that the cannoli at Circo's Pastry Shop might have a cinnamon flavor that detracts from the overall taste for some, especially when compared to Boston-style cannoli [4], [5]. Another commenter found their rainbow cookie to be less chocolatey than preferred and prone to falling apart [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CIRCO PASTRY SHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Rainbow Cookie Crawl 14 Bakeries Queens Manhattan
"Circo's rainbow cookie is recommended for those who prefer less chocolate, as it was noted to be lacking in that area. The cookie easily fell apart and lost points due to the minimal chocolate."
NeutralFrom post: Food Itinerary Etiquette And Opinions
"Circo's is mentioned as having excellent cannolis, which are filled in front of the customer to perfection. It is located in Bushwick and suggested as an alternative to Manhattan options."
PositiveFrom post: Rainbow Cookie Project Update Queens Is Complete
"Circo's can be hit or miss, but was pleasantly surprised by their offering recently."
NeutralFrom post: Rainbow Cookie Project Update Queens Is Complete
"Circo's rainbow cookies are considered very good."
PositiveFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter noted that if cookies have the same price per pound, they can be mixed and matched, and customers don't need to buy a full pound. They mentioned getting just three rainbow cookies from Court Street Bakery and that other bakeries like Circo's and Monteleone allow custom assortments by weight."
Neutral