Authentic Italian bakery delights! Famous pignoli cookies, plus mondula, rainbow cookies, & pasticciotti. A true taste of tradition.
This Brooklyn bakery is a beloved spot for traditional Italian pastries and cookies. Known for its excellent pignoli cookies, it also offers a delightful array of other treats, including mondula, rainbow cookies, and pasticciotti. While some find the cannoli to have a hint of cinnamon, many consider this charming family business a go-to for authentic Italian baked goods.
This Italian bakery is highly recommended for its traditional pastries and cookies, with pignoli cookies being a standout favorite. Other popular items include mondula (almond paste cookies with orange zest), rainbow cookies, and pasticciotti. Some customers note a distinctive cinnamon flavor in the cannoli, which might not appeal to everyone, but the overall consensus leans towards high satisfaction with the baked goods.
"The pignoli cookies, mondula (almond paste cookies with orange zest), rainbow cookies, and pasticciotti are highly recommended."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, praising the authentic Italian pastries and cookies. While a few mention a divisive cinnamon note in the cannoli, the overall feedback highlights the quality and traditional charm of the bakery.
Important Note
One commenter noted a cinnamon flavor in the cannoli that detracted from the taste compared to other options.
"Circo's can be hit or miss, but was pleasantly surprised by their offering recently."
Neutral"Circo's rainbow cookies are considered very good."
Positive"The commenter noted that if cookies have the same price per pound, they can be mixed and matched, and customers don't need to buy a full pound. They mentioned getting just three rainbow cookies from Court Street Bakery and that other bakeries like Circo's and Monteleone allow custom assortments by weight."
Neutral"Clarifies they tried Circo's in Bushwick and some Little Italy spots, noting a cinnamon presence that detracted from the cannoli compared to Boston options."
Negative"Praises Circo's for their cookies, specifically mentioning fig-filled and almond paste with orange peel as outstanding."
Positive"Finds that cannoli from Circo's in Bushwick and some Little Italy spots have a detracting cinnamon flavor compared to Boston options."
Negative"Considers Circo's Pastry Shop in Bushwick their favorite for cannoli after searching for the best in NYC."
Positive"Recommends Circo's Pastry Shop in Bushwick as great."
Positive"This user suggested Circos in Brooklyn as a place that might sell the "chocolate cigars" the original poster was looking for."
Neutral"This user expressed love for Circo's and recommended their mondula (almond paste cookies with orange zest), rainbow cookies, and pasticciotti (pie crust pastries filled with custard and candied orange)."
Positive"The user decided to skip Circo's despite initially planning to visit, stating they are not a big fan of Italian bakeries and it was a bit out of the way, though they appreciated its status as a cute family business."
Negative"Circo is listed as a top recommendation for sumptuously delicious pignoli cookies, along with Fortunato Brothers and Pasticceria Monteleone."
Positive"Circo's is identified as being located in Bushwick, affirming its presence and relevance to the discussion about pignoli cookies."
Positive
