Iconic, century-old pizza joint famed for its classic pies & no-frills, cash-only, whole-pie takeout experience.
This historic Brooklyn pizzeria, a true New York institution, has been serving up classic pies since 1924. While it famously operates on a cash-only, whole-pie basis and offers no dine-in service, many patrons find the experience of enjoying their pizza outdoors, especially after a beach day, to be a unique and cherished tradition. The quality of their pizza, often described as old-school margherita, continues to draw aficionados seeking an authentic taste of New York's pizza heritage.
This legendary pizzeria is renowned for its classic, old-school New York-style pizzas, particularly the margherita. It operates on a cash-only basis and sells whole pies only, with no dine-in options. While many praise the authentic taste and unique outdoor-eating experience, a few recent comments suggest a decline in quality and question its value.
"The primary recommendation is their classic, old-school margherita pizza, often enjoyed as a whole pie."
Customers express a mix of nostalgia and appreciation for the historic, no-frills pizza experience, though some note concerns about recent quality and limited operating hours.
Important Note
This establishment is cash-only and famously does not offer dine-in service, with customers typically eating their whole pies outdoors. Additionally, there are mentions that it may now only be open on weekends.
"Totonno's is mentioned as a place that serves classic old-school margherita pies."
Positive"This commenter feels Totonno's has declined in quality since COVID-19, citing it as overpriced and not good."
Negative"Despite not being open for dine-in, Totonno's still offers excellent pie and an amusing, enjoyable vibe."
Positive"There's uncertainty about whether Totonno's is still open for dine-in, as the family is reportedly trying to sell it."
Neutral"The commenter recommends Totonno's in Coney Island as a tasty and eccentric alternative to John's of Bleeker Street."
Positive"The commenter notes that Totonno's is likely only open for takeout of whole pies on weekend afternoons, making it difficult to include in a pizza crawl due to its location in Coney Island, which is far from other pizzerias."
Neutral"The commenter mentions Totonno's as a nearby drive from L&B Spumoni Gardens. They previously disliked the pizza, describing it as 'sauce on cracker,' but acknowledge it's a landmark with over 100 years of history and that they only sell pies."
Negative"This commenter is inquiring about recent experiences with Totonno's, as they consider it a missing piece in their collection of painted pizzerias."
Neutral"The user points out a misspelling of Totonno's in the artist's script name under the drawing."
Neutral"This commenter is inquiring if Totonno's is still open, noting their website only mentions takeout and delivery, and questioning where customers eat their pies if they don't live nearby. They also mention that the website may not always be up-to-date."
Neutral"The user recommends Totono's in Coney Island, but notes it is only open on weekends now."
Neutral"Selected Totonno’s Pizza from the original poster's pizza options."
Positive"A commenter enjoyed eating pizza from the box outside Totonno's because they don't offer dine-in. They found it very tasty and plan to do it again."
Positive"User recalls craving Totonno's, especially after a beach day, contrasting it with visiting Di Fara's out of convenience."
Positive"User feels Di Fara's is a more significant omission from the list than Totonno's."
Neutral"User notes that Totonno's is missing from the list, implying it should be included."
Positive
