Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (718) 372-8606
Address: 1524 NEPTUNE AVENUE 11224
Iconic Brooklyn pizza spot; legendary pies, a must-visit for pizza lovers.
A beloved Brooklyn institution, this pizzeria is a strong contender in the New York pizza scene, frequently appearing in discussions about top pizza spots. Patrons often express intense cravings, particularly associating the pizza with enjoyable experiences like a day at the beach. While there's some debate about its inclusion on certain lists and a note about its current operating model (primarily takeout), the quality of the pizza is consistently praised. One customer even highlighted the enjoyment of eating the pizza outdoors, appreciating its taste even in that setting, and indicated a desire to repeat the experience. The pizzeria is recognized for its Italian and New York Style Pizza.
This establishment is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, with customers frequently mentioning cravings and high satisfaction. The New York-style pizza is a highlight, often discussed in the context of various pizza rankings and discussions. While the primary focus is pizza, there's a customer anecdote about enjoying the pizza eaten outside, suggesting a positive experience even with limited dine-in. The cuisine is described as Italian and New York Style Pizza.
"The primary recommendation is for their pizza, which is consistently praised for its taste and quality."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards this pizzeria, often expressing a strong craving for its pizza and considering it a must-visit, especially after a beach day. While some discussions revolve around its exclusion from popular pizza lists or potential changes in operating hours, the overall feedback indicates a high regard for the quality and taste of the pizza, with a notable mention of enjoying it even when eaten outside due to the lack of dine-in options.
Important Note
The pizzeria may have limited dine-in options and is noted to potentially be open only on weekends.
"The user points out a misspelling of Totonno's in the artist's script name under the drawing."
Neutral"This commenter is inquiring if Totonno's is still open, noting their website only mentions takeout and delivery, and questioning where customers eat their pies if they don't live nearby. They also mention that the website may not always be up-to-date."
Neutral"The user recommends Totono's in Coney Island, but notes it is only open on weekends now."
Neutral"Selected Totonno’s Pizza from the original poster's pizza options."
Positive"A commenter enjoyed eating pizza from the box outside Totonno's because they don't offer dine-in. They found it very tasty and plan to do it again."
Positive"User recalls craving Totonno's, especially after a beach day, contrasting it with visiting Di Fara's out of convenience."
Positive"User feels Di Fara's is a more significant omission from the list than Totonno's."
Neutral"User notes that Totonno's is missing from the list, implying it should be included."
Positive
