TLDR
Century-old, family-run legend serving iconic coal-oven pizza in Coney Island. Limited weekend hours, takeout only, and a must-visit for classic NYC slice enthusiasts.
Reddit Sentiment for TOTONNO'S PIZZERIA(based on 39 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana is highlighted as one of New York City's most legendary pizzerias, having been family-owned and operated since 1924. The business has been actively seeking a buyer or investor for the past few years, as the current family members are aging and there is no one to take over, causing a strain. The pizzeria boasts a rare coal oven, which is a significant selling point in New York. The family's desire is for a buyer who will maintain their traditional methods, focusing on full pies and avoiding unconventional menu items like pineapple pizza. The listed asking price includes the one-story wood-frame building, but it is noted that there are no air rights included in the sale. Current operating hours are Saturday and Sunday from 12 PM to 5:30 PM.
Details
A historic Coney Island landmark, this family-owned pizzeria has been serving legendary coal-oven pies since 1924 [1]. Despite its status as an iconic institution, the restaurant faces an uncertain future as the owners seek a buyer [1], [2]. While many patrons cherish the classic, thin-crust experience, others have noted inconsistencies in quality and high price points in recent years [3], [4].
Food Overview
Known for its thin, robust crust and distinct smoky aroma from a rare coal oven, the pizza features a signature balance of cheese and sweet-tart, garlicky tomato sauce [6]. While traditionalists praise the classic margherita and white pies, some recent visitors have found the food to be average given the cost [3], [6].
Customer Sentiment
Customer reception is highly polarized, ranging from deep nostalgia for its century-old legacy to frustration over recent price hikes and inconsistent quality [3], [4]. Devoted fans vehemently defend its status as the best in its genre, while others find the limited weekend-only hours and takeout-only format inconvenient [2], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TOTONNO'S PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Quality has gone downhill and only offers whole pies."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Notes it is only open on Saturdays and that visitors should bring cash."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Included in a list of recommended pizza spots."
PositiveFrom post: Why Would Anyone Trust Dave Portnoy About Pizza
"The commenter labels the negative assessment of the restaurant as criminal, citing it as some of the best pizza in that genre."
NegativeFrom post: Why Would Anyone Trust Dave Portnoy About Pizza
"The commenter believes this is the best pizza they have ever eaten and found Portnoy's review of it to be unfairly mediocre."
Negative