Iconic, century-old pizza joint serving legendary pies in Coney Island. A must-try for pizza aficionados.
A true New York classic, this pizzeria has been serving up delicious pies for over a century. While it may be a bit of a journey to Coney Island, the experience of enjoying their traditional pizzas, especially after a day at the beach, is highly recommended. The ambiance, even if it's just takeout, is part of the unique charm of this historic establishment.
This pizzeria is renowned for its classic New York-style pizzas, with some users claiming it invented the white pizza. While many rave about the traditional margherita and other pies, a few recent reviews mention a decline in quality and value, particularly post-pandemic. The pizza is exclusively sold as whole pies.
"While specific dishes are not heavily detailed, the classic New York-style pizzas, particularly the margherita and white pizza, are consistently praised. The garlic topping is also recommended."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards this pizzeria, praising its classic, old-school New York-style pizzas and its historical significance. However, some note recent concerns about inconsistent quality, price, and limited operating hours.
Important Note
The restaurant operates with limited weekend hours and is takeout-only, with no dine-in options currently available. The location in Coney Island can also be inconvenient for some visitors.
"The user noted that Totonno's was on their radar but Coney Island is far, and they would be in Brooklyn on a weekday, making it an inconvenient option."
Neutral"Totonno's in Coney Island is highly recommended, with the same family making pizza there for 100 years. They are only open on weekends and do not offer dine-in anymore, but the pizza is considered worth it."
Positive"The commenter shared a negative experience at a restaurant promoted by Rob Martinez, noting that the establishment was overwhelmed by new customers, leading to long waits and strain on the staff. This raised concerns about the ecosystem of food creators and their impact on small businesses."
Negative"The owners of Totonno's are reportedly looking to retire, raising questions about its future."
Neutral"It is suggested that Totonno's may not be worth traveling to Coney Island solely for the pizza."
Negative"Totonno's operates as takeout only and has limited weekend hours, which is important to consider if you are not local."
Neutral"Totonno's can be inconsistent and is considered very pricey."
Negative"Responding to criticism about Totonno's, Rob Martinez (the channel owner) explained the limited hours are due to the owner's age and family circumstances, and that the business is seeking a buyer. He also clarified his content monetization practices."
Neutral"This user critiqued Rob Martinez's video about Totonno's, finding the narrative disingenuous due to limited hours and service issues mentioned in other reviews. They also noted the restaurant was struggling and looking for a buyer."
Negative"This commenter fondly remembers Totonno's Pizza as a special treat in the 90s and hopes they can stay open, suggesting it as a good option for tailgating before a Cyclones game."
Positive"The commenter visited Totonno's Pizza in 2014 and found it to be great."
Positive"This commenter notes the recent closure of Ciccio's and a pork store, expressing sadness about South Brooklyn losing its Italian establishments, including Totonno's."
Negative"This visitor describes going to Totonno's Pizza in the summer, noting they were only open on weekends and that indoor dining was not allowed due to roof damage. Despite the circumstances and cost, they found the pizza fantastic, eaten by the ocean."
Positive"This commenter finds Totonno's Pizza expensive for its size but considers it their favorite pizza in NYC and recommends trying it while possible, highlighting the garlic topping."
Positive"This commenter laments the decline in quality and increase in prices at Totonno's Pizza after the pandemic and a fire, stating it used to be a contender for the best pizza in NYC."
Negative"Following up on the previous comment, this user expresses confusion about family businesses that do not have long-term managers as a succession option besides family members or selling the business."
Neutral"In response to learning Totonno's Pizza invented white pizza, this commenter expresses excitement as white pizza is their favorite slice."
Positive"This commenter reminisces about eating Totonno's pizza pies after going to the beach in the 90s, eating them hot off the car hood."
Positive"This commenter suggests that $60 for a pizza with four toppings is average pricing and that the original commenter might be complaining about the cost of typical premium toppings."
Neutral"The commenter expresses sadness about Totonno's Pizza potentially closing, calling it another NYC institution lost."
Negative
