TLDR
BYOB Chinatown legend famous for expert tableside-carved Peking duck. A long-standing staple perfect for group gatherings and authentic specialty dishes.
Reddit Sentiment for PEKING DUCK HOUSE(based on 18 Reddit opinions)
Details
A seasoned Chinatown stalwart operating since 1978, this destination is celebrated for its authentic tableside-carved Peking duck [1]. Beyond the signature roast, the kitchen excels in refined specialties like braised sea cucumber and Peking-style lamb chops [2]. It remains a beloved choice for group gatherings, bolstered by a welcoming BYOB policy that encourages bringing your own wine [3].
Food Overview
The menu centers on expertly roasted Peking duck featuring crisp skin and juicy meat, traditionally served tableside with bao [1, 2]. Customers frequently recommend this signature dish [9, 11], though opinions on the precision of the duck carving can vary [10]. Beyond the duck, the restaurant garners praise for specialized offerings such as braised sea cucumber with shrimp roe, shredded pork with salted cabbage and yuba, and spicy Málà scallops [2, 3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The signature Peking duck, served tableside with fluffy white bao, is the must-order dish [1, 3]. Guests also enjoy the unique specialty menu items, particularly the braised sea cucumber and Peking-style lamb chops [2, 3]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •peking duck(3)
- •braised sea cucumber with shrimp roe(3)
- •peking-style lamb chops(3)
- •shredded pork with salted cabbage, beans, and yuba(2)
- •scallops with málà seasoning(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently praise the venue as a top-tier choice for group gatherings and festive meals [4, 5], with many highlighting the convenience of its BYOB policy [6, 7]. While the signature duck is a crowd favorite [8, 9], experiences are largely positive, though some diners suggest variation in preparation standards [10].
Caveats
Some diners have noted that the preparation of the duck, specifically the carving technique, may not always meet traditional expectations of thinness [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PEKING DUCK HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Favorite Chinatown Spot That Has Alcoholdrinks On
"It's suggested to bring your own wine to Peking Duck House and have fun, especially if considering Chinese Tuxedo for a more expensive option."
PositiveFrom post: Real Peking Duck
"This user recommended Peking Duck House on Mott Street, but another user disagreed, stating it was 'very much not Peking Duck House'."
NegativeFrom post: Real Peking Duck
"The commenter explained that Hutong originates from Hong Kong, suggesting its Peking Duck might be a Hong Kong/Cantonese interpretation, similar to Peking Duck House. This is in response to another user finding a difference compared to duck in mainland China."
NeutralFrom post: Large Group Chinese Restaurant Recommendations
"This user mentioned that their family has enjoyed gatherings at Peking Duck House over the years, noting it has many tables for large parties, though they haven't been recently."
PositiveFrom post: Large Group Chinese Restaurant Recommendations
"If Wu's Wonton King is unavailable, this user suggests the downtown Peking Duck House as a delicious alternative that is also BYOB."
PositiveFrom post: Large Group Chinese Restaurant Recommendations
"This user recommended Ping's in Chinatown for authentic Chinese food and mentioned that Peking Duck House is a place their family has enjoyed for gatherings, though noted it's been a while since their last visit."
PositiveFrom post: Christmas Day Lunch Recs
"The user suggested Peking Duck House as a good option for Christmas Day lunch in Chinatown, NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Best Peking Duck In Chinatown
"This user agreed with the recommendation for Peking Duck House."
PositiveFrom post: Best Peking Duck In Chinatown
"This user recommended Peking Duck House for peking duck."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pekking Duck In Manhattan
"The user expresses dissatisfaction with Peking Duck House's Peking duck based on photos, noting the cuts appear too thick compared to the traditional 108 cuts. They feel it would be a maximum of a 7/10 if not cut correctly."
NegativeFrom post: Best Pekking Duck In Manhattan
"The user has never been anywhere that was clearly better than Peking Duck House for Peking duck, although they mention other options like Decoy and Tse Yang."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pekking Duck In Manhattan
"The user enjoyed the Peking duck at Peking Duck House in Chinatown and notes it's a preferred spot for friends who have tried many places."
PositiveFrom post: Alternative To A Steak House For A Guys Dinner
"Mentions that Peking Duck House offers free corkage, adding to its appeal for group dinners."
PositiveFrom post: Alternative To A Steak House For A Guys Dinner
"Recommends Peking Duck House in Chinatown as an alternative to a steakhouse for a group dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Not The Best Restaurant
"Peking Duck House is recommended for its Peking duck, with the user stating it's definitely not 'The Best' but they love it regardless, also noting its BYOB policy."
Positive