Iconic diner, known for its "best burger in the US" claim & buzzy atmosphere. A prime spot for a rich, satisfying meal, especially for burger lovers.
This popular American diner is a must-visit for burger aficionados, boasting a "4Charles replica burger" that draws crowds. While some find the food rich and heavy, the overall consensus points to an excellent dining experience with a buzzy atmosphere. It's a go-to spot for those seeking a top-tier burger, though some diners note a recent shift in quality.
Primarily known for its highly-rated American-style burgers, often compared to those at 4 Charles. Other popular dishes include the prime rib sandwich, French dip, and mac and cheese. Some reviews note the food can be very rich or heavy, and there are differing opinions on whether the burger lives up to the hype, with some finding it too salty or bland, while others praise its quality.
"The burger, particularly with bacon and egg, is consistently recommended. Other highly-praised dishes include the French dip, prime rib sandwich, mac and cheese, and beef tartare. Some users also suggest the Korean fried chicken and chocolate pie."
Customers generally rave about the burgers and the lively atmosphere, with many considering it a top-tier dining experience. However, some find the food overly rich or the prices, particularly for fries, to be too high.
Important Note
Some users report that the restaurant has a reservation fee that does not go towards the bill, and that the food can be quite rich or heavy. There are also differing opinions on whether the burger lives up to its highly-hyped reputation.
"Au Cheval was mentioned as a possible option that could work, though it can get loud and is less likely on a Monday."
Neutral"The French Dip from Monkey Bar (which shares owners with Au Cheval) is recommended as a good beef option."
Positive"In response to the Au Cheval ribeye suggestion, the user agrees that it's better than a filet, but prefers a long braised dish like a stew or meat sauce over pure meat for a first-time experience."
Neutral"Suggests trying the ten-ounce ribeye at Au Cheval for a first beef experience, considering it a better choice than a filet mignon."
Positive"Recommending against maximalist burgers like Au Cheval for a first beef experience, suggesting a lean filet mignon from a reputable steakhouse instead to avoid heavy fat intake."
Negative"While considering burgers, the commenter notes that Au Cheval's burgers are smash-style and not juicy internally. They suggest Red Hook Tavern for a juicy burger or Hometown BBQ for brisket."
Neutral"A commenter recommends burgers as the ultimate form of beef, accessible and perfect, but advises against 7th Ave Burgers."
Positive"The commenter was considering Au Cheval before reading the post and also mentions Al Pastor tacos from Los Tacos. They express hesitation about a large steak for a first-time beef eater."
Neutral"The user had a positive experience with Au Cheval's burger, finding it phenomenal, but highlights Dhamaka's Beef Pepper Fry as a must-try."
Positive"This commenter suggested Au Cheval for its burger and atmosphere, contrasting it with Crane Club for those who want to dress up."
Positive"This commenter suggested Au Cheval for its burger and atmosphere, contrasting it with Crane Club for those who want to dress up."
Positive"This user identified Au Cheval as their favorite for burgers and also highlighted good service."
Positive"This user identified Au Cheval as their favorite for burgers and also highlighted good service."
Positive"This commenter preferred Au Cheval over Delmonico's, noting it has a refined pub feel and a good burger. They also mentioned it as a decent option compared to Crane Club."
Positive"This commenter preferred Au Cheval over Delmonico's, noting it has a refined pub feel and a good burger. They also mentioned it as a decent option compared to Crane Club."
Positive"This user recommended sharing the bologna sandwich."
Positive"The user stated that the French dip at Au Cheval might be the best they've ever had, but found the burger to be too busy."
Positive"This user found the burger overrated, suggesting most other dishes were better. They specifically praised the steak tartare."
Neutral"This user enthusiastically recommended Au Cheval, describing it as divine. They also advised to judge the restaurant fairly without over-hyping it."
Positive"This user stated that Au Cheval is 'so worth it'."
Positive
