French brasserie known for oysters & fries with au poivre; fondly remembered but recently closed.
Rue 57, a French brasserie located in Midtown Manhattan, served as a neighborhood fixture for 26 years before its recent closure. Many customers shared nostalgic memories, reminiscing about their early experiences with the restaurant, some dating back to the late '90s and early '00s. While some patrons continued to enjoy its quiet weekend brunch atmosphere and friendly service, others noted a decline in food quality and value in its later years. Despite mixed reviews on its final performance, its closure has evoked a sense of loss among those who frequented it or have fond memories associated with it, with some comparing its former ambiance to that of Redeye Grill.
Rue 57 was a French brasserie that offered a varied menu, with mentions of oysters and a standout dish of fries with au poivre sauce. Some patrons fondly recall specific items like crispy rice. However, feedback also indicates a decline in food quality over time, with some describing it as mediocre and overpriced towards its end. It was considered a decent spot with a generally good menu by some, but others felt its prime had passed.
"The fries with au poivre sauce were specifically praised as delicious, and crispy rice was also a dish that patrons loved."
Overall, customer sentiment towards Rue 57 is mixed, leaning towards nostalgic sadness due to its closure. Many long-time patrons express fond memories of the restaurant, with some noting its decline in quality in recent years. While some found it to be a decent and varied option, others felt it became overpriced and mediocre. The closure has been met with a general sense of loss for the neighborhood.
Important Note
The restaurant has recently closed.
"States that Rue57, a previously recommended French Brasserie, is now closed."
Neutral"Recommends Rue57, a French Brasserie at 57th St and Sixth Ave, for its great menu and location, noting it would fit the price range. However, a subsequent comment indicates it is closed."
Positive"User states Rue 57 was one of their go-to spots and expresses sadness about its closure."
Positive"User feels Rue 57, like Redeye Grill, used to be a good spot after Carnegie Hall shows, but its time has passed."
Neutral"User agrees the early 2010s were the last good years at Rue 57 and specifically notes they loved the crispy rice."
Positive"User visited recently (weekend) and found it to be a nice place with very friendly staff."
Positive"User is sad about the closure but feels the food and drinks were a total ripoff and hopes something better takes its place."
Negative"User fondly recalls going regularly in the early '00s while working nearby and will miss the delicious fries with au poivre sauce."
Positive"User notes the food was decent and considers its closure, along with Bice Cucina's, a big loss for the area."
Neutral"User feels Rue 57 hasn't been the same for a while, finding the food mediocre and overpriced, though still sad about the closure due to its longevity."
Negative"User has fond memories of the restaurant but admits they haven't visited in years."
Neutral"User visited recently (March) after first visiting in 2010 and enjoyed the quiet weekend brunch atmosphere. They are sad about another spot from their past closing."
Positive"User recalls having a very good meal there with their mother last year."
Positive"User had their first legal drink at Rue 57 while interning nearby and expresses sadness about its closure."
Positive"User expresses sadness about the closure, having visited many times as their office was nearby."
Neutral"User comments that the restaurant's quality had been declining and they are not surprised by the closure."
Negative"User expresses sadness about the closure, having frequented it in the late '90s/early '00s when friends worked there. They note its similarities to Redeye Grill."
Positive"Rue 57 has oysters on the menu."
Neutral"Decent with a varied menu and not too expensive."
Neutral
