A legendary NYC tavern with a classic vibe, famed for its unforgettable burgers & bone marrow.
Sonal Shah reviews Minetta Tavern, a Greenwich Village institution praised for its burgers, classic French fare, and lively atmosphere, highlighting its transformation and enduring appeal.
Minetta Tavern is a historic Greenwich Village establishment that masterfully blends classic French bistro charm with a quintessential New York vibe. Renowned for its iconic burgers, like the Black Label and Minetta Burger, the restaurant also excels with dishes such as French onion soup and roasted bone marrow. The ambiance, characterized by its intimate dining room and lively bar, contributes to an overall exceptional dining experience, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors.
Minetta Tavern is celebrated for its classic French-American cuisine, with a strong emphasis on burgers and steaks. The Black Label Burger and the classic Minetta Burger are frequently recommended and highly praised, though some find them expensive. Other popular dishes include the French onion soup, roasted bone marrow, and the French dip sandwich. While most reviews are positive, a few mention specific dishes like steak frites being disappointing, and the vegetarian options are noted as present but not a focus.
"The Black Label Burger and the classic Minetta Burger are highly recommended. Other popular dishes include the French onion soup, roasted bone marrow, and the French dip sandwich."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Minetta Tavern, praising its classic atmosphere, excellent service, and standout dishes, particularly the burgers and French onion soup. While some find it expensive or not worth the hype, the majority view it as a quintessential New York dining experience.
Important Note
Some users found the restaurant expensive or certain dishes (like steak frites) to be subpar. Reservations can be difficult to secure, especially on weekends.
"This user explains the appeal of the Black Label Burger lies in its dry-aged rib eye blend, which provides a unique flavor. They feel it predates newer burgers but is distinct from places like Five Napkin Burger."
Positive"This user suggests that the burgers at Lords and Rolo's are better than Minetta Tavern's standard burger."
Neutral"This user tried the Black Label Burger for the first time and found it to be one of the best they've ever had."
Positive"This user recommends ordering the bone marrow at Minetta Tavern."
Positive"This user mentions Fillmore's Tavern in Queens for a good burger with steak fries at a lower price point."
Neutral"This user prefers Red Hook Tavern but insists that the Black Label Burger is a must-try for any cheeseburger lover, despite its price."
Positive"This commenter suggests that the original poster should have tried Minetta Tavern's regular burger, which they found fantastic, instead of the Black Label Burger."
Positive"In response to a discussion about burger prices, the author states that plenty of great burgers can be found for under $20 in NYC and that those costing more are not worth it. They mention having had excellent burgers for $14."
Neutral"This commenter strongly disagrees with negative opinions on the Black Label Burger, stating they crave it and it never disappoints. They prefer it over the current smash burger trend."
Positive"This user directly states that the original poster's opinion on the Black Label Burger is incorrect."
Positive"This user asks the original poster to name other burgers they prefer."
Neutral"This user expresses enjoyment of the Black Label Burger."
Positive"The author found the Black Label Burger overpriced and not worth the cost, stating they've had better burgers at half the price. They advise others not to consider it a must-try."
Negative"The author mentions that the chocolate soufflé was insanely good and advises ordering it."
Positive"The commenter suggests that Minetta Tavern would be a good alternative to a Michelin-starred restaurant for a picky eater. They believe that Michelin restaurants often don't cater to such preferences."
Neutral"The user enjoyed Minetta Tavern, noting it was great and contributed to a good overall experience due to the restaurant's vibe. They would visit Hamburger America more casually."
Positive"Minetta Tavern appears to be the best choice for the user's needs, as Monkey Bar had a conflicting event."
Positive"Minetta Tavern is listed as a potential option for a classic NYC dining experience."
Positive"Minetta Tavern is recommended, with the possibility of securing a bar seat by waiting. The burger is also highlighted as incredible, and the service is impeccable."
Positive"This user seconded the recommendation for Minetta Tavern, stating it's lovely and the food is wonderful, advising to make a reservation."
Positive
