NUMERO 28 PIZZERIA

Last Updated: ~1 month ago

Address: 2628 CARMINE STREET

TLDR

Authentic Italian pizzas, incl. top-tier margherita & Neapolitan. Unique Roman-style pies w/ great value wine. Cash only.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 7 Reddit comments)

100% Positive

Achievements and Accolades

Details

Experience authentic Italian flavors at this pizzeria, celebrated for its exceptional margherita pizza and Neapolitan-style pies. The restaurant offers a unique dining experience with its signature long, rectangular Roman-style pizzas, providing a generous portion for groups. Beyond the stellar pizza, patrons rave about the excellent value of their Italian wine bottles, making it a standout choice for a delicious and affordable meal.

Food Overview

This Italian pizzeria is renowned for its exceptional pizza, with specific praise for the margherita and Neapolitan styles. They also offer unique, long rectangular Roman-style pizzas. While the food is consistently lauded, it's worth noting that the restaurant operates on a cash-only basis.

Highlights / Recommended

"The margherita pizza is highly praised, and the Neapolitan and Roman-style pizzas are also recommended. The Italian wine bottles are noted for their excellent value."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly recommend this Italian pizzeria, particularly praising its outstanding margherita and Neapolitan pizzas. The value for money, especially with their Italian wine selection, is frequently highlighted.

Important Note

The restaurant is cash-only.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Sit down pizza spot for large groups West?

This post recommends Numero 28 on Carmine Street for its delicious pizza, noting it's served in unique long rectangular shapes (Roman style). The commenter also mentions it's cash only and has affordable wine.

Visiting NYC and bringing wife and daughter for some pizza and possibly other food

A commenter controversially suggests Numero 28 Pizzeria, located near John's, has better pizza. They also note that while it's cash-only and doesn't sell slices, the Italian wine bottles offer excellent value.

Pizza tour spots in Manhattan

Numero 28 on Carmine Street is mentioned as a top spot for the best margherita pizza.

L'Industrie Pizza - West Village

In response to a query about Neapolitan pizza, a commenter recommended Numero 28, stating they enjoyed their Neapolitan pizza.

Where in Lower Manhattan is the stretchy cheese?

A user simply recommends Numero 28 on Carmine.

Outdoor late lunch options in Village/West Village?

Numero 28 was suggested as another viable option for outdoor dining.

Recent Mentions

From post: Sit Down Pizza Spot For Large Groups West

"Numero 28 on Carmine Street is highly recommended for its delicious pizza, which is served in unique long rectangular shapes (Roman style). It's cash only and has affordable wine."

Positive

Jan 18, 2026View Comment →