Authentic Neapolitan & Roman-style pizza, cash-only, with great value Italian wine bottles. A hidden gem loved by locals.
Numero 28 Pizzeria, a beloved Italian spot, is making waves in the NYC food scene. Known for its exceptional Neapolitan and Roman-style pizzas, this establishment offers a truly authentic Italian dining experience. Beyond the highly praised pizza, diners can expect a curated selection of Italian wines, often at great value, complementing the flavorful dishes. The atmosphere is further enhanced by staff who maintain an authentic Italian presence, adding to the overall charm.
The star of the show at Numero 28 Pizzeria is undoubtedly the pizza, with customers specifically recommending the margherita and Neapolitan styles. Roman-style pizzas are also a highlight, noted for their unique long rectangular shape. The restaurant also offers a selection of Italian wines at excellent prices, with one user highlighting a $40 bottle as a great deal. It's important to note that the restaurant is cash-only.
"The margherita pizza and Neapolitan-style pizzas are highly recommended. Roman-style pizzas, known for their rectangular shape, are also a standout. The Italian wine bottles are noted for their excellent value."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza and the value of the Italian wine selection. The staff's authentic Italian presence is also noted as a positive aspect.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash-only and does not sell pizza by the slice. One commenter noted that the Upper East Side location has changed to Gnocchi Bar.
"This user noted that the UES location of Numero 28 changed to Gnocchi Bar."
Neutral"This user called Numero 28 a 'hidden gem' and their favorite by a mile."
Positive"This user states Numero 28 is solid and that the staff still speak Italian."
Positive"Numero 28 on Carmine Street is highly recommended for its delicious pizza, which is served in unique long rectangular shapes (Roman style). It's cash only and has affordable wine."
Positive"Numero 28 was mentioned as another good option for outdoor dining."
Positive"The user notes that Numero 28 Pizzeria does not sell slices and is cash-only, but praises the excellent value of their Italian wine bottles."
Positive"The commenter controversially states that Numero 28 Pizzeria, located near John's, has better pizza."
Positive
