Next.js logo

NUMERO 28 PIZZERIA

Updated

Phone: (212) 463-9653

Address: 2628 CARMINE STREET

TLDR

Praised for unique Roman-style pizza & affordable Italian wine [2]. A beloved cash-only spot called a 'hidden gem' with authentic charm [6].

Reddit Sentiment for NUMERO 28 PIZZERIA(based on 8 Reddit opinions)

88% Positive13% Neutral

Tags

italian 9neapolitan 3pizza 8View All

Details

Numero 28 Pizzeria, a much-loved Italian spot, is praised for its delicious pizza, often served in unique long rectangular shapes, reminiscent of Roman style [4]. Reviewers also highlight the excellent value of their Italian wine bottles, with one noting a $40 price point in the West Village as a great deal [2]. The restaurant is also recognized as a solid choice with staff who still speak Italian [5] and has been called a 'hidden gem' by patrons [6].

Food Overview

Numero 28 Pizzeria is highly recommended for its pizza, noted for being served in distinctive long rectangular shapes, akin to Roman style [4]. It's considered by some to be superior to other well-known pizza places in the area [1]. The restaurant also offers a good value on Italian wine bottles [2], and maintains an authentic Italian atmosphere with staff who speak Italian [5]. One reviewer referred to it as a 'hidden gem' [6].

Highlights / Recommended

"The pizza, particularly the Roman-style rectangular slices, is highly recommended [4]. Patrons also appreciate the value offered on their selection of Italian wines [2]."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Numero 28 Pizzeria, frequently praising their pizza as excellent and even better than nearby competitors [1]. The value for money, particularly with their wine selection, is also a recurring positive point [2].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About NUMERO 28 PIZZERIA

This post highlights Numero 28 for its delicious pizza, specifically mentioning the unique long rectangular (Roman style) shapes, and also notes that it is cash only with affordable wine.
In this thread, Numero 28 is mentioned as a solid choice for pizza, with staff still speaking Italian. It is also called a 'hidden gem' by a fan.
This commenter controversially states Numero 28 Pizzeria has better pizza than a nearby competitor and also notes their excellent value for Italian wine bottles.
Numero 28 is mentioned as a good option for outdoor dining.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For Good Italian Restaurants In Manhattan

"Numero 28 is recommended as a place to get pizza."

Positive
May 24, 2026View Comment →

From post: Question Wheres The Best Neapolitanstyle Pizza

"This user noted that the UES location of Numero 28 changed to Gnocchi Bar."

Neutral
Apr 1, 2026View Comment →

From post: Question Wheres The Best Neapolitanstyle Pizza

"This user called Numero 28 a 'hidden gem' and their favorite by a mile."

Positive
Mar 31, 2026View Comment →

From post: Question Wheres The Best Neapolitanstyle Pizza

"This user states Numero 28 is solid and that the staff still speak Italian."

Positive
Mar 31, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sit Down Pizza Spot For Large Groups West

"Numero 28 on Carmine Street is highly recommended for its delicious pizza, which is served in unique long rectangular shapes (Roman style). It's cash only and has affordable wine."

Positive
Jan 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: Outdoor Late Lunch Options In Villagewest Village

"Numero 28 was mentioned as another good option for outdoor dining."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nyc And Bringing Wife And Daughter For

"The user notes that Numero 28 Pizzeria does not sell slices and is cash-only, but praises the excellent value of their Italian wine bottles."

Positive
Jun 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nyc And Bringing Wife And Daughter For

"The commenter controversially states that Numero 28 Pizzeria, located near John's, has better pizza."

Positive
Jun 15, 2025View Comment →