TLDR
Massive, delicious cake slices that are worth every penny, making it a top Brooklyn dessert spot.
Reddit Sentiment for LITTLE CUPCAKE BAKESHOP(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Details
Step into Little Cupcake Bakeshop and prepare to be amazed by the sheer size of their cake slices, a feature that consistently earns rave reviews and a loyal following. It's a place where a single slice can feel like a meal, often enjoyed over two sittings, making the price point feel justified even to the most discerning customer. Among the stars of their dessert menu, the Brooklyn Blackout Cake and Key Lime Pie are frequently highlighted for their deliciousness. The Princess Cake and Oreo Cake also garner significant praise, with one user even declaring the Oreo Cake the best they've ever had. For those who appreciate a more nostalgic flavor profile, the Nutella Banana Cake, described as tasting like banana bread, is another must-try. While the bakeshop excels in many areas, a few customers have noted that cupcakes from the Bay Ridge location can be on the drier side. However, this minor critique is often offset by the enjoyment of other offerings like their brownies and banana pudding. Overall, Little Cupcake Bakeshop stands out as a beloved bakery, with many considering it a top-tier dessert destination in Brooklyn.
Food Overview
Little Cupcake Bakeshop is celebrated for its exceptionally large cake slices, with many customers feeling the generous portions make the prices reasonable. Highly recommended are the Brooklyn Blackout Cake, Key Lime Pie, Princess Cake, and Oreo Cake. The bakeshop also offers other well-received items such as brownies and banana pudding. However, one reviewer found the cupcakes at the Bay Ridge location to be dry.
Highlights / Recommended
"Customers highly recommend the Brooklyn Blackout Cake, Key Lime Pie, Princess Cake, and Oreo Cake due to their excellent taste and generous portion sizes. The Nutella Banana Cake is also a standout favorite."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •cake slice(5)
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Little Cupcake Bakeshop, frequently praising the massive size of their cake slices, which they feel justifies the price. Specific dishes like the Brooklyn Blackout Cake, Key Lime Pie, Princess Cake, and Oreo Cake receive high marks. While most reviews are positive, one user found the cupcakes at the Bay Ridge location to be dry but enjoyed other items like brownies and banana pudding.
Caveats
One user found the cupcakes at the Bay Ridge location to be dry.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE CUPCAKE BAKESHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User fondly remembers the Oreo cake, calling it the best cake they have ever eaten."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User loves the Nutella banana cake, describing it as being like banana bread and expressing obsession with it."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User questions if the original post meant the Park Slope / Crown Heights location instead of Brooklyn Heights."
NeutralFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User found the cupcakes at the Bay Ridge location to be dry, preferring Molly's Bakery or Sugar Sweet Sunshine. However, they enjoyed non-cake items like brownies and banana pudding from Little Cupcake Bakeshop."
NegativeFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User compares cheesecake prices, finding Little Cupcake's ($9) tastier but maybe not three times better value than Monteleone's ($3)."
NeutralFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User believes Little Cupcake Bakeshop is the best bakery in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User agrees with a previous comment praising Little Cupcake Bakeshop, specifically noting that the large cake slices often take two days to eat."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User has visited the Brooklyn location but frequents the Prince St one, calling it their favorite bakery for cake slices. They find the hefty slices worth the price, often taking two days to finish."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User agrees that the cake slices are massive and feels the pricing is fair compared to other places offering less for similar cost."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User highly recommends the princess cake (10/10) and mentions the huge slice sizes."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User finds the cake slices massive, which justifies the price."
PositiveFrom post: Thoughts On Little Cupcake Bakeshop In Brooklyn
"User considers Little Cupcake Bakeshop a solid dessert spot in Brooklyn Heights, praising the Brooklyn Blackout cake and key lime pie, though noting the high prices."
Positive