TLDR
Classic, red-sauce Italian-American comfort food with massive, shareable portions. A go-to for large groups and festive, casual vibes in Bay Ridge.
Instagram Posts References
The author describes Brooklyn Roots as serving some of the most scrumptious Italian food. Specific dishes highlighted include the Chicken Marsala, noted for its sweet and savory finish and tender chicken, and the Halibut, described as light, juicy, and flavorful. The Bread pudding is called 'to die for'. The author also commends Chef Thomas and the Brooklyn Roots staff for their delicious food, service, and hospitality. The post congratulates the restaurant on its new location and anticipates visiting it.
Brooklyn Roots Italian is embracing the holiday spirit by hosting a "Christmas In July" event. This special celebration will feature a menu of Christmas time favorites, including Seafood Salad, Lasagna, and the traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes, available on Saturday night. Diners are encouraged to celebrate the halfway point of the year with festive cheer. For reservations or takeout, interested parties can call 718-333-5122.
Willa Moore reviews Brooklyn Roots Italian, a Bay Ridge destination that captures the essence of old-school Italian dining with hearty portions and a lively, neighborhood-focused atmosphere.
Details
Located in Bay Ridge, this restaurant is a quintessential destination for generous portions of classic, red-sauce Italian-American comfort food [1], [2], [3]. Known for its casual and festive atmosphere, it serves as a reliable spot for communal dining and group gatherings [1]. While generally celebrated for its consistent quality, diners occasionally find some items to be over-hyped or uneven in execution [1].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on hearty Italian-American classics and family-sized portions [1], [2]. Highlights include the iconic Sunday Night Sauce [1], [3], tender Chicken Marsala, and flavorful Halibut [2], as well as a highly recommended, custardy bread pudding [1], [2]. Conversely, the off-menu burger has been criticized for tough meat [1], and some dishes like the Chicken Francese can be overly eggy in their breading [1].
The Sunday Night Sauce is widely regarded as a standout, frequently providing enough food for multiple meals [1], [3]. Other highly recommended items include the tender Chicken Marsala, fresh Halibut, and the bread pudding dessert [2].
Patrons frequently praise the restaurant for its friendly service and welcoming hospitality [2], [3]. While the majority of guests consider it a reliable favorite, some diners note that the experience can feel slightly overrated compared to its popularity [1].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01bread pudding3 mentions
- 02chicken parm2 mentions
- 03meatballs2 mentions
Caveats
Some diners feel the restaurant can be a bit overrated [1]. Additionally, while portions are famously generous, the preparation of certain dishes, such as the Chicken Francese or the off-menu burger, can be inconsistent [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN ROOTS ITALIAN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"Recommended Brooklyn restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge for its large chicken parm, which they stated provided three additional meals and was very tasty."
PositiveFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge."
NeutralFrom post: Best Affordable Italian Restaurant Nyc
"This user, who has a background in Italian restaurants, recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge for its solid, generous, checkered-tablecloth Italian-American food, noting it's not fancy."
PositiveFrom post: Italian American Spots
"This user questioned why the original poster would travel to Bay Ridge and miss Brooklyn Roots, implying it's a must-try."
Positive