Old-school Italian-American w/ a legendary Sunday sauce & massive portions – a Bay Ridge must-try!
This Italian-American spot in Bay Ridge is a true gem, offering a classic dining experience with generous portions that are perfect for sharing. Customers rave about the rich and delicious Sunday sauce, and dishes like the lobster pasta and chicken parm are frequently highlighted as must-tries. It's the kind of place that feels like a well-kept secret, consistently delivering a satisfying meal.
This restaurant excels in classic Italian-American fare, with a particular standout being their 'Sunday sauce,' described as rich, delicious, and perfectly balanced. Other highly recommended dishes include the lobster pasta, chicken parm (noted for its massive portion and excellent sauce), and meatballs. While most feedback is positive, a few comments suggest that the portion sizes can be excessively large, making it difficult to finish.
"The Sunday sauce is a consistent highlight, described as rich and delicious. Other highly recommended items include the lobster pasta, chicken parm, and meatballs. The Caesar salad is also noted for its generous portion and dressing."
Overwhelmingly positive, with frequent praise for rich sauces, generous portions, and standout dishes like lobster pasta and chicken parm. Some note it can be a bit much for smaller groups.
Important Note
Portion sizes can be very large, potentially overwhelming for smaller parties. One user noted it can be a bit overrated.
"This user, who has a background in Italian restaurants, recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge for its solid, generous, checkered-tablecloth Italian-American food, noting it's not fancy."
Positive"This user questioned why the original poster would travel to Bay Ridge and miss Brooklyn Roots, implying it's a must-try."
Positive"This user highly recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge, stating it 'hits every time'."
Positive"This user mentioned Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge, noting that while they are not the biggest fan and find it a bit overrated, many people seem to love it."
Neutral"Brooklyn Roots is described as top-notch all around, with specific praise for the bartender Willy and their Sunday Night Sauce, which provides generous leftovers."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots Italian is mentioned as serving large, family-portioned pasta dishes."
Neutral"Brooklyn Roots is mentioned."
Neutral"Brooklyn roots was listed as a recommendation for Italian-American food in Brooklyn."
Neutral"The commenter suggested Brooklyn Roots."
Neutral"This commenter noted that Brooklyn Roots' Sunday sauce is very special."
Positive"A commenter recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge for red sauce Italian."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge was recommended, likely for its generous portions."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is suggested as a good choice due to the Italian origins of the Dyker Heights Lights display."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is listed as a potential dining option."
Neutral"Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge is suggested."
Positive"This commenter suggests Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge if the original poster is traveling with a large party."
Positive"A brief mention of 'Brooklyn Roots' as a suggestion."
Neutral"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot in Brooklyn."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is mentioned as a place to consider."
Neutral"The user has been a patron since the restaurant was in Sunset Park and highly recommends Willy the bartender for expertly crafted cocktails before dining."
Positive
