Old-school Italian-American w/ rich, garlicky Sunday sauce & massive chicken parm. A 'wow' spot w/ dream-worthy lobster pasta & bread pudding.
This Bay Ridge Italian-American gem is a beloved neighborhood spot, lauded for its classic comfort food and generous portions. Reviewers rave about their rich, garlicky Sunday sauce and a standout chicken parm that's smothered in sauce and perfectly broiled mozzarella. Don't miss their dream-worthy lobster pasta or the delightful bread pudding for dessert.
The Italian-American cuisine here is a hit, particularly their Sunday sauce, described as rich and delicious. The chicken parm is a must-try, featuring ample sauce and perfectly broiled mozzarella. Other recommended dishes include the octopus and lobster pasta, with bread pudding as a popular dessert choice. Portion sizes are noted to be very generous, sometimes to the point of being overwhelming.
"The Sunday sauce is frequently praised as rich and delicious. Standout dishes include the chicken parm, lobster pasta, meatballs, and bread pudding. The octopus and Caesar salad are also recommended."
Customers express strong positive sentiment, highlighting the rich and delicious Sunday sauce, fantastic octopus, and generously portioned chicken parm. While some found portion sizes excessive, the overall feedback points to a highly satisfying dining experience.
Important Note
One user found the portion sizes excessively large, making it difficult to finish the food. Another commenter critically suggested that appreciating large portions indicates a lack of culinary knowledge, sparking a debate.
"Brooklyn Roots is mentioned."
Neutral"Brooklyn roots was listed as a recommendation for Italian-American food in Brooklyn."
Neutral"The commenter suggested Brooklyn Roots."
Neutral"This commenter noted that Brooklyn Roots' Sunday sauce is very special."
Positive"A commenter recommended Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge for red sauce Italian."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge was recommended, likely for its generous portions."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is suggested as a good choice due to the Italian origins of the Dyker Heights Lights display."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is listed as a potential dining option."
Neutral"Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge is suggested."
Positive"This commenter suggests Brooklyn Roots in Bay Ridge if the original poster is traveling with a large party."
Positive"A brief mention of 'Brooklyn Roots' as a suggestion."
Neutral"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot in Brooklyn."
Positive"Brooklyn Roots is mentioned as a place to consider."
Neutral"The user has been a patron since the restaurant was in Sunset Park and highly recommends Willy the bartender for expertly crafted cocktails before dining."
Positive"The user stated that the place is awesome."
Positive"The user highly praised the lobster pasta, describing it as dream-worthy, and also raved about the bread pudding."
Positive"Responding to a query about the meatballs, the user described them as perfect: rich, thick, flavorful, topped with fresh ricotta, and notably made with 100% beef."
Positive"The user highly recommended the restaurant, mentioning they catered a daughter's birthday party from there, and everyone loved the food."
Positive"The user critically commented that appreciating large portions indicates a lack of culinary knowledge. This sparked a debate about portion sizes and Italian dining culture."
Negative"The user expressed interest in a specific dish called the 'Matty gunz dish' at the restaurant."
Positive
