TLDR
Authentic Italian bakery known for incredible brick oven breads & mortadella sandwiches. Don't miss pastries!
Details
This charming Italian bakery in Bay Ridge is a local favorite, renowned for its exceptional brick oven breads and delightful pastries. Customers rave about the quality of their sandwiches, particularly those featuring mortadella and other Italian cold cuts, often enhanced with arugula and a signature balsamic glaze. It's a perfect spot for a casual, delicious meal or a sweet treat, with many recommending pairing a sandwich with a cupcake from the neighboring shop.
Food Overview
This bakery excels in traditional Italian baked goods, with a strong emphasis on their brick oven breads, which are frequently recommended. Sandwiches, especially those with mortadella, are a highlight, with suggestions to add arugula and balsamic glaze. They also offer fantastic pastries, and customers recommend visiting early for the best selection.
Caveats
It is recommended to visit early for the best selection of pastries and breads.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PANEANTICO BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: I Need Everyones Help Finding A Certain Bread In
"This user suggested Paneantico in Bay Ridge for lard bread, also mentioning that they make it in a bagel shape."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter agrees that the combination of Paneantico and the cupcake shop is always a good move."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter agrees that the combination of Paneantico and the cupcake shop is always a good move."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter states that visiting Paneantico and the nearby cupcake shop was their routine for years."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter states that visiting Paneantico and the nearby cupcake shop was their routine for years."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter recommends Paneantico in Bay Ridge and suggests using the balsamic. They also recommend going next door for a cupcake."
PositiveFrom post: Day Off Today And Craving A Really Good Relaxed
"This commenter recommends Paneantico in Bay Ridge and suggests using the balsamic. They also recommend going next door for a cupcake."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Sandwich Shop And Why Is It
"This commenter prefers Royal Crown and Paneantico over Pisillo's."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cannoli Recommendations Had An
"Recommends Pan Antico for amazing brick oven breads and fantastic pastries, suggesting an early visit for the best selection."
PositiveFrom post: What Deli Sandwich Shop Am I Missing
"Paneantico in Bay Ridge was briefly recommended."
PositiveFrom post: What Deli Sandwich Shop Am I Missing
"Paneantico in Bay Ridge was recommended, with a suggestion to get a sandwich with a favorite Italian cold cut, arugula, and their balsamic glaze."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Italian Bread For Sausage
"Paneantico in Bay Ridge was recommended, with a specific mention of their brick oven bread."
PositiveFrom post: Best Sandwich Places
"Panetico in Bay Ridge is recommended as a nice place to sit with family."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get The Best Mortadella Sandwich
"Paneantico in Bay Ridge is recommended for its mortadella sandwich."
Positive