TLDR
Unassuming neighborhood gem w/ a cult following for its legendary Sicilian & Upside Down pies. A true local fave!
The Sicilian slice and the Upside Down pies are highly recommended and frequently cited as favorites.
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, with many declaring it a favorite and even the best in the city, particularly highlighting the Sicilian and Upside Down varieties.
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01sicilian slice4 mentions
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About V.I. PIZZA
A commenter declared VI Pizza their favorite slice despite trying many popular places, specifically shouting out the Sicilian slice.
A commenter praised VI Pizza's Upside Down pies as 'legitimately great'.
This user considers VIPizza in Bayside underrated and claims it serves the best Sicilian slice in NYC.
Recommends the Sicilian or upside down Sicilian slice from VI Pizza in Queens.
A commenter enthusiastically recommended VI Pizza in Bayside, calling their Sicilian pizza the best in the five boroughs.
This commenter recommended VIP Bayside in a discussion about thick crust pizza slices in NYC.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter recommended VIP Bayside in a discussion about thick crust pizza slices in NYC."
PositiveApr 19, 2026View Comment →