Next.js logo

ROSEMARY'S

Updated

Phone: (212) 647-1818

Address: 1820 GREENWICH AVENUE

TLDR

Authentic Italian trattoria w/ rooftop garden herbs. Consistently great pasta & vibes.

Reddit Sentiment for ROSEMARY'S(based on 18 Reddit opinions)

61% Positive33% Neutral6% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo
Achievement logo

Tags

italian 5american-italian 2mediterranean 2italian 3pasta 3patty melt 2View All

Instagram Posts References

Rosemary's is highlighted as an exceptional Italian restaurant in New York City's West Village, praised for its ability to transport diners to Italy with its fresh, flavorful cuisine and charming atmosphere. A key feature is its rooftop garden, which supplies many of the herbs used in their dishes, contributing to the freshness of the food. The establishment offers beautiful cocktails, delectable food, and a 'summer-in-Italy' aesthetic, with both inviting indoor and outdoor seating options. The post identifies it as a top Italian dining destination suitable for date nights or summer dinners.

This post features Rosemary's, a restaurant in the West Village, with a strong emphasis on their pasta dishes. The author expresses consistent satisfaction with the food, using phrases like 'This spot does it right every time' and tagging relevant hashtags such as #pastaporn and #pastaparty. The images showcase a variety of pasta dishes and what appear to be meatballs, suggesting a hearty and flavorful dining experience.

The vodka sauce pasta at Rosemary's was sampled and described as incredibly creamy, with the addition of burrata being a particularly good touch that enhanced the dish.

Details

Rosemary's in the West Village is an Italian restaurant celebrated for its authentic flavors and charming atmosphere, evoking a true Italian experience. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh ingredients, many sourced from its own rooftop garden, contributing to the vibrant taste of its dishes [1]. It's noted for being a consistently satisfying dining destination, perfect for a date night or a delightful summer dinner.

Food Overview

Rosemary's offers a delightful Italian cuisine with a strong emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients. Dishes like the vodka sauce pasta with burrata are highlighted for their creamy texture [1]. The restaurant also features other popular items such as a 'life-changing' patty melt [2], crispy chicken cutlet, and a bread plate [3]. A standout feature is the use of herbs from their rooftop garden in many dishes [4]. While most feedback is positive, one commenter noted a negative impression based on read information about an East Side location [5].

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the vodka sauce pasta with burrata, a 'life-changing' patty melt, and various pasta dishes. Other praised items are the crispy chicken cutlet and the bread plate [1], [2]."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • patty melt(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers consistently praise the food, particularly the pasta dishes, and appreciate the restaurant's ability to provide a genuine Italian dining experience.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About ROSEMARY'S

This thread discusses Rose Marie, with multiple users raving about the 'life-changing' patty melt and other dishes like the crispy chicken cutlet and bread plate. The positive feedback highlights these specific items as exceptional.
In a discussion comparing Italian restaurants, Rosemary's is mentioned with a description of its 'American Italian' food being presented as modern and light, attempting Mediterranean vibes. However, one user expressed a negative impression based on secondary information about an East Side location.
Rosemary's is recommended as a place to consider, particularly with restaurant week approaching, and it's confirmed that their menu is available online.
A commenter found several dishes at Rose Marie to be fantastic, specifically calling out the saltine crusted fish entree, crispy chicken cutlet entree, bread plate, and frozen G&Ts as highlights.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where To Go With Parents That Isnt Fussy Hyped

"Rosemary's was listed as a suggestion for a dining option."

Positive
Apr 16, 2026View Comment →

From post: Room For 3040 People For Sunday Lunch

"Rosemary is listed as one of the restaurant suggestions."

Neutral
Apr 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Graduation Dinner Recommendations

"Rosemary's is listed as a potential restaurant choice for the celebration."

Neutral
Mar 1, 2026View Comment →

From post: Analysis Paralysis Which Is Better Palma

"The commenter has a negative impression of Rosemary's East Side location, based on information they have read."

Negative
Aug 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Analysis Paralysis Which Is Better Palma

"Rosemary's is described as American Italian food that is dressed up as modern and light, attempting to emulate Mediterranean vibes."

Neutral
Aug 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Any Solid Lunch Restaurant Recommendations In

"This user suggested Rosemary's on Third as a potential option that fits the specified budget."

Positive
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter found several dishes at Rose Marie to be fantastic, specifically mentioning the saltine crusted fish entree, crispy chicken cutlet entree, bread plate, and frozen G&Ts."

Positive
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter visited Rose Marie on opening night and found the experience to be solid, expressing excitement to return and observe any changes or improvements."

Neutral
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter recalled liking the previous restaurant, Magdalene, that was in the same space as Rose Marie."

Neutral
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter inquired about the prices at Rose Marie, finding it odd that online menus did not include them. They later responded to a comment stating the total bill for their meal was $138, which they felt was less than expected and worth paying again."

Neutral
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter agreed with the previous statement about how good the patty melt is. They also provided a list of dishes ordered and mentioned the patty melt was the best thing they'd eaten in New York in a couple of months."

Positive
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Marie Is One Of The Best Meals Ive Had In

"This commenter went to Rose Marie a few days ago and found the patty melt to be life-changing."

Positive
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Precomedy Cellar Dinner

"This restaurant is recommended by the commenter."

Positive
Jul 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner Recommendations

"This user confirmed that Rosemary's menu is already available online, indicating it's a viable option for restaurant week."

Positive
Jul 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner Recommendations

"This user recommended Rosemary's in the west village as a place to consider, especially with restaurant week approaching."

Positive
Jul 17, 2025View Comment →